Mom: Our buffer cat.
Sammie: What?
Mom: We found a sweet little cat and gave it milk and whenever one of us was mad at the other we would find the cat and give it to the other as a peace offering.
Dad: It was an ugly feral cat. Let’s be real.
Mom: But it always worked to calm either of us down.
Dad: That buffer cat was our only friend. We couldn’t find a real community. We ended up hating it there because we hated the selves we had turned into.
Mom (in a fake punk rocker voice): Smokin’, drinkin’, stealin’ records.
Dad: Your mom worked in a movie theater and we used to steal popcorn from the concession stand for dinner.
Mom: I stole the popcorn.
Dad: Yes, yes, Gia stole the popcorn.
Mom: Anyway, we had this huge fight. Like a massive, massive fight. I still can’t believe it.
Sammie: What was it about?
Dad: Hmmm, nothing.
Mom: I can’t remember, either.
Dad: And the cat was nowhere to be found.
Mom: Oh god, Sammie, your dad looked everywhere for that thing. He was gone for three days straight, only coming home for some food, and then he’d be back out again.
Dad: And the worst part about it was the cat had no name. So I was just yelling, “Kitty! Kitty!” hoping it would come out.
Sammie: Why didn’t you name it?
Mom: You know what I think?
Dad: What? I’d actually be curious to hear that.
Mom: I think we secretly didn’t name it because we knew it wasn’t ours. Like we didn’t want it to be ours, because that meant we were there permanently.
Dad: All I know is… (eyes well up) Sammie: Aw, Dad!
Dad: That stupid cat made me realize that I wanted to marry Mom. And that I wanted to have children with her. You know, out on the streets of Brooklyn for three days, and you ask yourself, what are you doing here? And you realize… (sniffs) Mom: He just wanted someone to love. People to care for.
Sammie: So you came back?
Mom: He wrote a lot of songs about that cat.
Sammie: I want to hear Dad’s punk rock songs.
Dad (composing himself): So anyway, we came back and settled here, among familiar faces.
Sammie: Wait, wait, going back. Is that why you named Puppy just Puppy?
Dad (buries his face in Puppy’s fur): Yuuuusss.
Mom: Let’s see… when we got back and moved into this place, Cooper’s mom and dad were here, and Father Frank was just Frank, he hadn’t gone to seminary school yet, and Mrs. T was working at a preschool actually…
Sammie: Mrs. T?!
Mom: Beverly, yeah.
Dad: It was strange at first, so tight with people we knew but so much space at the same time.
Mom: But your dad got a job right away because he knew a guy working for the City of Lebanon, and that gave me time to get my associate’s degree, and then you came along! I mean, I wonder, Sammie, with all of your talk about getting out… You think we only stay in the Upper Valley because we don’t have enough money to leave?
Sammie: I don’t know. I guess so.
Mom: We’re lucky to be here. Maybe it’s because the mountains are bigger than everyone, they give people perspective. Listen, you can go anywhere you want, you can conquer the world, you could have gone to New York and been incredibly successful, and I know you would have been. (breaks in voice, sniffing) But the more you win, the more people you might have to beat out, or have to leave behind, the smaller your world becomes.
Dad: That’s absolutely right.
Mom (points out to the yard, to the mountain): We’ve got a big world here, Sammie.
Sammie: I know. I know now.
A LETTER I HAVEN’T SENT
Dear Coop,