21
When I woke up the next morning, Lucas was gone. I stared at the empty space beside me in the bed for a long minute, trying not to blame him for running. If anyone understood the urge to run, it was me. I sat up in bed with a heavy sigh.
“Morning, Hero,” Lucas said. “I got you a hot chocolate.”
Snatching my glasses off the nightstand, I turned my head to find a fully dressed Lucas sitting on the bare mattress on the other side of the room, a newspaper spread out in front of him. Not only was he awake before me, but his hair was wet so it even looked like he’d showered.
Smiling so widely my cheeks hurt, I padded across the room and kissed him on the side of the head before accepting my drink.
“Didn’t think I left you here, did you?” he said teasingly. Apparently my sigh hadn’t gone unnoticed.
“Not at all,” I said mildly. “I was just regretting the idea of sleeping over here in your pygmy-sized bed. The crick in my neck regrets it, too.”
“Agreed,” Lucas said with a laugh. “All future sleepovers will be conducted at your apartment where there is not only a double bed but also no roommates. Luckily for us, Danny is trying to spend all his free time with his girlfriend before she leaves for her internship.”
My brain snagged on the words “future sleepovers” and didn’t even take in the rest. My heart did a little flip at the idea that Lucas was still thinking of a future with me despite everything I’d told him. Then I remembered how many times he’d told me he loved me the night before and my heart did a double flip.
His attention drawn back to the newspaper, he held out a paper take-out bag from the coffee shop. “I got you a cruller,” he said as he took a bite of a raspberry danish.
I peered into the bag suspiciously. “No chocolate icing?” I complained.
Raising his eyebrows at me, Lucas grabbed me by the waist and pulled me down onto the bed in front of him, tickling me mercilessly. “Not even a, ‘Thank you, Boyfriend, for going out in the rain to get me a tasty breakfast?’” he said as I squealed and squirmed, crushing the newspaper underneath me. Then he leaned forward and gave me a kiss so deep that suddenly I didn’t feel much like laughing at all. “How can you stand that much chocolate so early in the morning, anyway?”
I gave him a look that was equal to the alarming nature of his question. “How much you have to learn,” I said, shaking my head.
As I hoisted myself up off the bed, I pressed my hand down on the newspaper, crushing it further. “Careful, I’m reading that,” Lucas said. As he straightened out the page, I looked down to see the front page headline.
Kindergarten On The Run?
I spun around, holding my stomach as it clenched painfully. Telling Lucas had not stopped the automatic reaction I had whenever I caught wind of a news story about Brandon.
Lucas took my hand and pulled me back around while simultaneously folding the newspaper over with his other hand. “There, it’s gone,” he said. Getting to his feet, he took me in his arms. I breathed in his scent and breathed out the bad memories. After about a minute of breathing like this and feeling his arms around me, my stomach had unclenched.
Like I said, magic arms.
“That’s why you ran away from Tim and me that day on campus, isn’t it?” Lucas said, putting it together. “I remember there was a news report blaring out of his ear buds. That idiot always plays his music too loud.”
“You remember that?” I said.
“Of course I remember it,” Lucas said. “About five seconds later you slipped and fell on your ass. How could I forget that?”
I pressed my hand against his cheek as his dimples popped. “That’s not what I remember,” I said. “I remember you picking me up.”
“I’ll always pick you up,” Lucas said. “I’ll always be there for you, Katie.” I closed my eyes at the sound of his lovely words and wondered if I would ever believe them completely without wondering why. “I promise I’ll throw the paper out right after I finish reading this article.”
“Deal,” I said, giving him my best half-smile.
Lucas shook his head, still looking down at me. “I still can’t really believe you’re ‘the babysitter.’ I must have read dozens of articles about you over the years. I think I even saw a picture of you once, but your head was turned away from the camera.”
I remembered that picture, too, and the way my father had torn it out of every newspaper he could get his hands on. He’d walked down the block ripping the front page off the newspaper on every front stoop until my mother screamed at him to get a hold of himself.
“Yeah, that was me. Being the sole surviving victim of a notorious child murderer sure can do wonders for your celebrity status,” I joked. I was trying to lighten the mood, but Lucas didn’t laugh. I think he could tell I didn’t really think it was funny, either.
“I’m sorry,” Lucas said, shaking his head. “I hide the paper and then a second later I bring it up all over again. I shouldn’t be talking about my amazement like it’s important. It’s just a lot to get my mind around. But we don’t have to talk about any of it if you don’t want to. Not if it hurts you.”
I shrugged. “It’s a good hurt. I’ve been holding that day inside of me for six years. I have to get used to talking about it. Making the subject off-limits would just be more hiding.”
“So they know he left Vancouver?” I asked tentatively as Lucas picked up the folded paper. Though I didn’t want to read any details about the crime, which always surfaced in any article about Brandon, I definitely did want to be aware of a possible manhunt.
“His probation officer reported him missing when he didn’t show up for an appointment,” Lucas replied cautiously, watching my face for distress. “The cops are on it—if he left the province, it’s a violation of his community supervision—but they don’t seem to be aware that he’s in Kingston.”
I nodded, unsure how to feel about this news.
“Although,” Lucas went on, “they could know where he is if I anonymously tipped them off.”
Grabbing the cruller, I stuffed a piece of it in my mouth to stem my rising anxiety. Sugar beat panic, right?
“They’ll put together in about two seconds that I go to school here, Lucas,” I said as I chewed. “They’ll realize he’s after me and start asking why.”
“They’ll probably assume he’s just still blaming you for the whole thing,” Lucas said. “His lawyers did try to pin it on you. They’ll probably issue a restraining order to protect you.”
I swallowed the last bite of doughnut before answering. “I’m pretty sure staying away from me is already part of his sentence. ‘Stay away from the victims.’ I remember hearing it during sentencing. The only living victim right now is me.”
As those words sunk in, Lucas placed a hand under my chin, gently urging me to raise it instead of hanging my head in shame as I had been. “All the more reason to call in the tip,” Lucas insisted. “He’s already breaking two of the rules of his parole. They’ll have to take him back into custody.”
“Not before the press gets wind of it,” I said. “If they start digging even a little… It always amazed me that nobody ever saw the two of us together at the park. Six years is a long time for a witness to sit around wondering if they really saw what they did, to stew in their guilt. The right question from a journalist and the case could blow wide open again.”
“You don’t even know if this witness exists,” Lucas said patiently.
“I lied on the stand, Lucas,” I replied. “I lied with the whole country watching. We can’t take any chances right now.”
“You mean like the chances you’re taking with your life?” Lucas said, and I pulled out of his arms in frustration. I was beginning to realize that telling the truth came with some unforeseen consequences. Like Lucas’s opinions about everything.
Facing the mirror above the nightstand, I eyed my frizzy hair and tried to remember the last time I’d washed it. I couldn’t. Instead of having pointless discussions about turning Brandon in, what I really needed to do was get home and take a shower. “Do you have a comb?” I said, not even bothering to cover up the hostility in my voice. If Lucas wanted to be with me, he was going to get all of me.
Unzipping a canvas bag sitting on the floor, Lucas took out a plastic comb. “You know I’m right,” he said as he handed it to me.
I let out a groan of frustration, both at Lucas’s persistence and because my hair was so knotted I could barely move the comb an inch. As I glared down at the nightstand, I noticed it was oddly bare, as were the shelves of Lucas’s wardrobe. I knew he didn’t have to clear out of the Res for another few days—he still had two exams this week—and Lucas might have been many things, but he didn’t strike me as the pack-five-days-ahead type.
“What’s with the suitcase?” I asked, pointing at it with the comb.
“Well, I figured since I have to be out of here soon anyway,” Lucas explained, “and since we’ve already established you have that awesome double bed, I thought I’d just…move in.”
“To my apartment?” I squeaked, taking in the larger suitcase by the door. In addition to showering and picking up breakfast while I’d been snoozing this morning, he’d apparently also been packing.
I tried not to hyperventilate at the thought of Lucas living full-time in my apartment, with my hair clogging the drain and my dirty underwear and my enormous jar of Nutella.
“Did you really think I was going to let you out of my sight?” Lucas said into my ear. “I need to be there every second so we can continue this argument ad nauseum.”
“Can’t wait,” I said, giving him a spiteful look as he began to strip the sheets off his bed. But as he finished his packing, I thought about how nice it would be to have him there, to lean on, to snuggle up with, and to do other things with in my double bed.
I turned my head so he wouldn’t see my smile. After all, I was still mad at him.
Can’t wait, I thought.
Lucas and I spent the next few of days getting to know each other all over again. I’d been so hesitant to tell him anything about my past that he realized he knew almost nothing about my life back in Vancouver. His curiosity piqued, he started quizzing me about my history, asking some silly questions, like what board games I’d hated as a kid and what kind of apples I’d liked packed in my lunch, and other less silly questions, like what it felt like when they put me on anti-depressants.
It was hard for me to answer without being evasive. My years of avoiding ever talking about my past had me tensing my shoulders and bracing for the worst, my lips clamping shut, my eyes searching for the exit. One day, when we were both supposed to be studying but instead he was asking about my mother’s reaction during the trial, I felt tears running down my cheeks before I even realized I’d started to cry. Lucas caught each tear with his fingertips and wiped my face dry, but the next day he was back at it. I never asked him to stop. He said he wanted to know everything about me, that he couldn’t help it, and truthfully that was what I wanted, too. I wanted Lucas to know me through and through. The questions felt like a different kind of exam, a test of my courage. Once every detail of me was laid out for Lucas to see, as nobody else ever had, I knew I would feel better than if I’d aced a test. It was like a cleanse.
His love was washing me clean.
There were other lessons, too. I learned that Lucas was a lot neater than me, folding his clothes at the end of the day instead of leaving them in a pile on the floor for him to trip over like me. I learned that Turner far preferred Lucas to me. Turner’s little ears perked up every time he heard Lucas’s voice and he spent all his time tangling himself around Lucas’s legs, purring like a lawn mower, which didn’t make me jealous in the least. I also learned that Lucas did not know how to cook—he managed to botch boiling pasta—and since neither could I, we ordered in a lot. Because leaving the house was definitely not on the menu. My flight back to Vancouver was booked for Saturday morning, and until then Lucas had appointed himself my personal bodyguard. With Brandon still on the loose, he ruled that we should stay inside at all times except for exams. Granted, when he said this his hand was on my ass, and when I agreed I was slipping my tongue into his mouth, but the seriousness of the situation wasn’t lost on us.
Though he tried to do it when I wasn’t looking—a hard thing to do in an apartment with only two rooms—Lucas was still reading the paper obsessively, trying to track Brandon’s movements by the police reports. They still didn’t know he was in the area. There were no new threats stabbed through the door, and no texts, either. I tried not to wonder what that meant. Lucas thought it was a good sign—maybe Brandon was losing interest—but I knew better. If six years hadn’t worn him out, six days of watching me shacked up with my boyfriend wasn’t going to do the trick.
Letting myself think of Lucas as my boyfriend—that was another lesson.
Our argument over calling the police continued without much progress. Finally realizing I was never going to budge on the issue, Lucas stipulated instead that once I was safely installed in my parents’ home he would go ahead and make the call to the cops. I countered that calling the police once I was gone didn’t solve the problem. Kingston was still the town where I went to school. Brandon’s presence there would still be linked to me. Lucas then agreed that he would wait until Brandon had followed me back home, as we knew he would, before calling in a bogus tip about this whereabouts. But how would that help? How could we know exactly where Brandon was at that point? What kind of tip could Lucas give then except to tell the police what they already knew, that he’d violated his parole by missing an appointment with his P.O. Then Lucas inevitably circled back to calling the cops right away and the argument started all over again.
One thing he wouldn’t give up on was that if Brandon hadn’t been picked up by the time I got home, I had to tell my parents the truth. He was a little fanatical about it. I think the idea that he wouldn’t be there to protect me was making him a little mad, and he wanted to be sure that my parents understood the threat Brandon posed. I was also pretty sure he knew that when they heard the truth they’d be on the phone to the cops themselves in a blink. I never agreed to tell them—I didn’t want to lie—but I never flat out disagreed, either. I was being Switzerland on that one, and Lucas knew it.
One cloud hanging over us—besides the homicidal ex, that is—was the thought of being apart all summer. Now that I had Lucas, I found I couldn’t bear to lose him, and the very thought of all those days without being able to look at his breathtaking dimples was enough to drive me to distraction. Even his half-naked body in my bed couldn’t keep my attention, as we both learned one night when one moment we were kissing and the next I was picturing my lonely bedroom back home and making lists of all the movies I could watch to pass the time over the summer. When I shook myself out of my reverie and looked up at Lucas, he said, “What kind of alarm system do your parents have in their house?”
I guess we were both a little distracted.
But not so much that when my hand brushed over his boxers a few minutes later I didn’t feel his now-familiar arousal.
“Thinking about alarm systems, eh?” I said, and he turned on his side so we were spooning. In this position, I could feel him even more.
I could hear the grin in his voice as he whispered, “I told you, anytime you’re near me…”
For the next twenty minutes, before our minds wandered again, I learned about some of the other perks of having a live-in boyfriend.
One lazy afternoon, as the sun streamed through the windows onto the couch, I lay with my head in Lucas’s lap trying to keep the names of the Pre-Raphaelites straight in my head. (I kept forgetting the second Rossetti.) Turner had reluctantly given up his place on Lucas’s lap to me, opting instead to lie on the floor by his feet. Every once in a while he swiped at Lucas’s shoelaces.
Lucas’s questions that day had been getting more and more esoteric. Did I think of my father as strong? What was my friendliest memory? Then one of his questions struck a chord.
“What are you most afraid of?” he said. He felt my body react and immediately his hands went around me, tugging me closer, if that were possible. I felt his fingers digging into my shoulders, trying to loosen the muscles.
“I’m afraid of losing,” I replied softly. “That’s always been my biggest fear. Of telling the truth and losing the people I love. Losing you. Losing my parents. Losing Emily. When they know the truth about me, I’m afraid I’ll lose their love.”
Lucas sighed and smoothed his fingers over my hair. “You lived so many years thinking such awful things about yourself, Hero,” he said, “without anybody having the chance to contradict you. You’ve thought these horrible things for so long that you’ve convinced yourself they’re true. But they aren’t true. You told me everything and I still love you. There’s nothing awful about you at all. You aren’t going to lose anyone.”
I clung to his arms like they were a buoy as fear pumped through my veins, spurred by something I couldn’t explain. The idea of his love. And the idea of losing it. The idea of telling the truth to more and more people. And the idea of lying instead.
“Think of it this way,” Lucas said, gazing down into my eyes, “if you do lose your family over this, then what?”
My body actually spasmed at the very thought. I dug my fingers into Lucas’s skin. “Don’t,” I whimpered.
He shook his head. “You won’t, but let’s say the world turns on its head and you do. You have to know you’ll be okay. Look at how strong you are. You’ve lived with this secret eating away at you for six years and you’re still standing. I can’t say I could have done the same. You moved away and made a life for yourself. You make beautiful art. You’re in school, doing what you love. You made it, Katie. You survived. You can survive anything. You’re so much stronger than you think.”
“I’m not,” I protested, tears stinging my eyes, but I blinked them back angrily. “I-I’m not strong. I’m weak.”
“Being afraid isn’t the same as being weak. You’re brave,” Lucas said.
“I’m a liar,” I said.
“You’re a survivor.”
“Coward.”
“Smart.”
“Manipulative.”
“Cunning.”
“Selfish.”
“Human.”
“Cold-hearted.”
“Warm-blooded.”
“Ugly.”
“I’m not even going to dignify that with a response,” Lucas said, prying my hands away from my face. I was trying to hide again.
I looked up at him, his golden eyes, his kind face, and a new word came to my mind, one I never could have said before I met him: “Hopeful.”
Lucas nodded. “And remember,” he said, “even if everything goes wrong, and you find yourself feeling weak, there’s one thing you’ll always have, one thing you’ll never lose no matter what.”
“What?” I asked. If he said something like “your self-worth” I was going to puke, but of course he didn’t. He said the perfect thing instead.
“Me,” he said softly, and brushed my lips with his. “Forever.”
On the day of Lucas’s last exam we treated ourselves to Chinese food. Up until then we’d been going cheap and splitting every bill because I knew Lucas didn’t have a lot of extra cash. I didn’t even know how much money he was losing by not showing up to his shifts at the club all week, though he said it was no big deal. This philosophy exam, however, was one he’d been studying hard for, and, as it was an evening exam, I felt he needed a big dinner to get through it. Besides, my credit card, which my parents paid for, was happy to take the hit.
We were sitting on the stools at the kitchen counter, eating spring rolls and leaving sticky fingerprints all over each other when I heard the muffled sound of my phone ringing. I’d misplaced it the day before and had forgotten all about it.
“Check who it is first,” Lucas warned as I jumped off the stool, wiping my hands on a napkin.
“Okay, Dad,” I sassed as I searched for the source of the ringing.
It turned out my phone was underneath the rug in front of the couch—God knew how it had gotten there. Pulling it out and dusting it off, I saw that there were at least a dozen texts from Emily, and her name flashed across the screen as the phone continued to ring.
Crap.
I answered the call with a timid, “Hello?”
“I cannot believe you!” Em said. She was someplace loud. Over her yelling I was able to make out a voice asking passengers to report to the gate, final call.
Oh big, big crap.
“Oh, no. Did I—”
“Did you forget to help me pack up all my stuff?” Emily interrupted. “Did you forget your only sister was flying back to Vancouver today? Did you forget she’s terrified of flying alone?”
Due to our conflicting exam schedules, Emily was flying home three days earlier than me, though if I’d known my anthropology exam had been moved up, we could have flown together—a fact she’d been holding against me.
“I’m so, so sorry,” I said, eyeing Lucas miserably. He mouthed the word, “Uh-oh.”
“I lost my phone and I totally forgot and—”
“That’s not even what I’m mad about. Did you even look at any of my texts?”
I’d only scanned them. I wanted to read through all of them right that second, but that would have meant taking my ear away from the phone. “No,” I answered lamely.
“We haven’t even spoken since you left me that stupid note on your pillow,” Emily said, her voice shrill. She always sounded like that when she was trying to scream instead of cry. “Mariella called me that night, hysterical, saying you were screaming at her. By the time I got to your apartment you were catatonic. It was terrifying. Katie, what the hell is going on?”
I sat down on the arm of the couch and realized that amid all of Lucas’s questions I hadn’t asked any of my own. Like what exactly had happened the night I’d waited for Brandon to come and find me. I hadn’t even known that Mariella had been involved at all, though that did explain the chicken stir-fry she’d left at my door with a note saying she hoped I felt better and to call her, which I hadn’t done.
“Oh, Em,” I said, my heart filling with regret.
“Obviously the story you told about the creepy guy in the building was a lie,” she went on. “Lucas totally freaked out at me for leaving you alone.” My glance darted back to Lucas. “I was so busy with packing and studying for that insane exam for my accounting class that I had no time to come by your place and scream at you.”
I closed my eyes. I didn’t even bother replying. She needed to have her say.
“You’re keeping something from me,” she said. “I know you are. Something big. And you’ve been keeping it from me for a while.”
My heart broke a little as she said this, knowing hers must have been doing the same. The one thing Emily prized more than anything else was her belief that we told each other everything.
She said, “I just want to know one thing.”
“Okay,” I managed to say.
“Are you all right?” she said.
Lucas was sitting with his hands folded, his eyes riveted on me. “I will be,” I said, and then I continued, shocking even myself, “and I’m going to tell you everything. I promise.”
“Good,” Emily said before hanging up.
I slunk back to my chair and nibbled at my food half-heartedly as Lucas rubbed my back. “Be strong,” he said.
I guessed I was going to have to be.
An hour later I was in no mood to accompany Lucas to his exam, not after the calamity of that conversation with Em, but Lucas insisted. Even an offer to stay over at Mariella’s place wouldn’t sway him.
“If I could I’d take you into the exam room with me and make you sit right in front of me. That way you’d be in my line of sight at all times,” Lucas said as we walked through the windy evening toward campus, sauntering at Lucas’s usual pace. Apparently not even a final exam could make Lucas hurry up.
“I know what you’re after, Matthews,” I teased. “You’re only saying that because the top I’m wearing is kind of see-through.” It really was. I pulled the zipper on my jacket higher just in case.
“It’s what he’s after that I’m worried about,” he replied, his manner tense. I squeezed his hand. For the first time it occurred to me to wonder how he was dealing with the atomic bomb I’d dropped on him when I’d told him the truth. The thought of Lucas losing himself to the paranoia I often fell prey to made my stomach twist into knots. I didn’t want that for him. Nobody deserved that.
Not even me.
By a stroke of luck, Lucas’s exam had been moved to the fine arts building because of a water leak in Watson Hall. As part of their final grade, the fourth year art students had to turn all of Ontario Hall into a gallery with their own art on the walls, and I was eager to see the paintings of the advanced students. Walking down the hall toward the classroom we passed lots of students from our painting class, many of who knew us both by name, but for once Lucas and I weren’t the center of attention. We barely even merited a glance. Their eyes were glued to the art on the walls as they stood in clumps, evaluating aloud like it was crit day, debating which drawing or painting had the most merit. I couldn’t help but feel glad none of my work was on display. It wasn’t that I didn’t think my paintings would measure up. But I did feel my paintings that year had closed me in, locking me to the past, and I knew I wanted to tackle new subjects now, paint new things. I was ready to look ahead.
The crowded hallway seemed to reassure Lucas as we reached the door to his exam room. I knew he thought I couldn’t be in danger when I was surrounded by people. Of course, he wasn’t the girl who’d found a note threatening her boyfriend’s life in the middle of a busy coffee shop. But I didn’t point that out right then.
“Don’t go anywhere,” Lucas said, pressing a kiss to my lips that started out soft, but deepened as the moments passed. The hallway faded to nothing around us as his arms pulled me closer, his hands roaming dangerously close to my ass.
“I think you’re getting a little bit off topic,” I said, struggling out of his arms. The students filing into the exam room were either smirking or giving us dirty looks. We were sort of blocking the door.
“Can you blame me?” Lucas murmured. He tried to kiss me again, but I pushed him toward the door.
“Go!” I said. “Exam now. Kisses later.” I would have said something a lot dirtier than “kisses,” but there was a hallway full of people listening. But Lucas apparently had no such qualms.
“Oh, I plan to do a lot more than kiss you later, trust me,” Lucas said, giving me a smoldering look before flashing his dimples and strolling into the classroom, leaving me blushing with desire and embarrassment.
After that, I did get some attention, or as much as a group of preoccupied art nerds could muster. Naomi called me over to examine a black and white photograph of a crowded restaurant. For a short minute everyone wanted my opinion, as if by virtue of being Lucas’s girlfriend my thoughts held more weight, but when they found my take on the photo’s composition differed from theirs they quickly turned on me and my moment of notoriety was over.
As I wandered away from the fray, my mind drifted back to my call with Emily and I felt the weight of what was coming. Telling my family the truth would be even harder than telling Lucas, not because they were more important to me, but because they were there. They got the call that I was in the hospital and ran to my bedside. They shielded me from the reporters and stood by me through the trial. They were the ones I’d tested my lies on first.
Staring at a charcoal drawing of a swing set in a back garden, I felt myself growing angry, and for once my anger wasn’t aimed at myself. I was angry at the lies themselves and all the chaos they’d caused. I was angry that I’d wasted so much time hating myself. I was angry that now I had to face the prospect of hurting my family again. If Lucas was right and what happened really wasn’t my fault, then the only person to blame was the same one I was hiding from. And I was angry about that, too. I was furious with Brandon Tomko for the mess he’d made of all our lives: mine, Tommy’s, the Wesleys’, his parents’, my parents’, Emily’s, the whole country’s.
The door to the art studio at the very end of the hall stood open. Wandering inside, I found my final painting sitting on the easel where I’d left it. In the painting I held Tommy by the hand and the train tracks ran beneath our feet. Tommy was smiling. It was a painting of what might have been, or almost. But there was still that sky above us, filled with threatening clouds to the east, and the figure lurking behind, dressed in black, waiting for just the right moment to spring.
“You did this,” I said, my eyes narrowing on that black form, almost melting away to nothing in the trees.
“Keep telling yourself that, Katie Kat,” a voice said, and I spun around, flattening myself against the wall so hard I smacked the back of my head. It began to bleat with pain, or maybe that was my internal alarm telling me to run, run, run.
There was nobody there. The studio was empty, and when I stepped out into the hall I saw the other students were still congregated far down at the other end, out of earshot. Nobody was close enough to tell me if they’d heard it, too. Pressing a hand to the back of my head, I backed away from the doorway to the studio, still unsure if I’d imagined it or if Brandon was going to leap out of a shadow. When I hit the opposite wall with my back I staggered. I was having trouble breathing. Air, I needed air.
Pushing through the door to the stairwell, I scrambled down the two flights of stairs and fell out into the night. The wind was blowing harder now, a gale beginning to build, and the air forced its way into my lungs, leaving me gasping. I looked up at the stars as my breathing returned to normal and thought that no matter how many times I painted it I could never really capture the immensity of that sky, or the horror of it. That sky had watched as Brandon had killed Tommy. It had been the only witness. That sky knew the truth.
Truth or lies—that was what it always came down to. My lies or Brandon’s truth—neither really covered what happened that day. Maybe no article or painting or piece of testimony ever could. Maybe trying to make right something that was so wrong to begin with was the real problem. No truth I told would ever bring Tommy back. No lie would fill the gaping hole in his mother’s heart. Maybe the trick to moving on with your life was saying goodbye.
I closed my eyes and painted myself into the clearing. The train tracks ran ahead of me and behind. The sky was blue and clear. And I was not running or bleeding or crying. I was still. The woods were peaceful, just like I hoped he was. Just like I hoped I would someday be.
“Goodbye, Tommy,” I whispered. As I opened my eyes again, a star winked brightly, exactly above my head. I knew it wasn’t Tommy, but it made me smile.
“Alone at last,” a voice said, and I knew it was him. I would have known that voice anywhere. I’d been hearing it in my dreams for six long years.
Brandon Tomko had found me.