Tone Deaf

To what? Falling for him? No, I’m not letting that happen. Jace is a player—a player with a very long, very public track record of breaking hearts—and I’m not going to let myself get swept up in his fleeting touches.

So why can’t I take my eyes off him? I watch as he leans over and grabs a water bottle from the bottom shelf of the fridge. There’s something about the way he moves that’s almost hypnotic. He’s all grace and power, wrapped up in a package of complete nonchalance, like he’s not even trying to look hot. Which he’s not, of course. He has no one to show off for in this room.

Killer nudges me in the side, making me cringe and effectively getting my attention. “So Arrow and I saw you on TV last night,” he offers. “I had no idea you were planning to outdo us in the fame department.”

I raise my eyebrows at Jace, hoping he’ll save me by changing the subject. After all the stress of last night, I have no desire to talk about this anymore. The Amber Alert doesn’t immediately change anything—traveling with Jace is still my safest option, so I’ll just have to keep lying low and staying out of sight.

Jace catches my glance and pins Killer with a glare that would melt me into a puddle of shame. But Killer doesn’t even react, and I get the feeling he’s used to this grumpy side of Jace.

“Now really isn’t the right time to be making jokes, Killer,” Jace says.

Killer rolls his eyes. “You just have no sense of humor.”

Before Jace can retort, Arrow strides into the kitchen. He nods to Jace and Killer, but doesn’t bother acknowledging me. Jace tenses a little, and I wonder if it’s because Arrow is being rude, or because he’s anxious to get out of here before Killer annoys him any more.

Arrow lays his hands on Killer’s shoulders, then leans over and kisses him on the cheek. “Jon’s ready to go,” he says. “You want to take off?”

Killer nods. “Yeah, just one sec,” he says as he pulls out his phone. He quickly types out a message and tilts the screen so only I can read it:

Jace is trying to pretend he has no emotions, which is always a sure sign he’s feeling too many. Sorry he’s being a grump. Just give him some time. He’ll eventually work up the nerve to talk about whatever’s going on between you two.

I give him a grateful smile, and Killer winks before hopping down from the stool. He grabs Arrow’s hand and pulls him away from the kitchen, his lips moving at the speed of light while he plans their trip into the city. As Arrow is tugged along, he looks back and flicks his gaze between Jace and me. His expression tightens with uncertainty, and he says to Jace, “Don’t do anything stupid.”

Jace just rolls his eyes and sticks up his middle finger. Arrow doesn’t get a chance to return the gesture as Killer pulls him away from the room.

As soon as they leave, Jace turns to me and signs, “Sorry. Arrow’s still worried you’re going to get the band in trouble. But he’ll warm up eventually.”

I nod and try not to look too relieved. As awkward and quiet as Jace has been this morning, I was starting to wonder if he was still okay with me traveling with them. Apparently he is, but I’m also guessing that Killer is completely right. Jace isn’t going to open up a discussion about last night unless he absolutely has to.

Jace sighs and rubs at his temples. “And sorry for Killer being insensitive,” he says, although he looks away a little, and I get the feeling he’s not apologizing for just his bandmate. “I swear he’s the dumbest human being to ever get accepted into Mensa.”

I try to hold back a laugh, sure that I read his lips wrong. “Mensa?”

Jace nods. “As ditsy as he acts, Killer is technically genius. Mensa is a high-IQ society he tested into.”

“Yeah, I know what it is. I was—” I snap my mouth shut, cutting off the words about to emerge. Because none of that matters anymore. My life as a musical genius is done, over, finished, kaput. And there’s no going back.

Jace leans against the counter and cocks his head. “You were . . . ?”

I sigh, realizing it’s too late and I’m going to have to give him an answer. “I was in Mensa.”

“Isn’t it like a lifelong thing? Like, once you’re in, you stay in?”

I shrug. “Yeah. I guess.”

“So shouldn’t you say you’re in it, not you were in it?”

“Why are you suddenly so interested in grammar tenses?”

He holds up his hands, as if warding off my sharp tone. Then he signs, “It’s just, most people like to brag about that stuff. And you’re not. I’m just wondering why.”

“I don’t really belong in it anymore,” I sign.

He raises a skeptical eyebrow. “Why not? Did you get a bad grade or something?”

“Just drop it, okay?”

Jace nods. Apparently, he’s one of the few people in the world who can actually drop a subject, because he snags his water bottle off the counter and starts walking out of the room. He pauses at the exit to sign, “I’m heading out to a local studio for the day. They’re doing some promo thing, and I’m supposed to be their poster boy. You stay here and lie low, okay?”

Olivia Rivers's books