I sit up and grab her ankles, spreading her as wide as possible. “Open her up for me, Justin. We should all watch this together.”
Justin reaches down and spreads her pussy lips apart, showing her clit and the tiny hole we’re supposed to fit in. “Goddamn, Lucky. You’re so fucking pretty down there.” He sucks her nipples after he says this, and I can see her pussy clench at the feeling. He presses the pads of his fingers against her clit, rubbing in circles. Her need continues to grow as more of her juices drip down to her ass.
I put one of her ankles over my shoulder, and reach down to put my dick at her opening. Fuck, this virgin pussycat is going to suck my dick off. I just put the tip against her and I can feel her sucking me in. Her cunt is pulsing with need. She’s never been fucked and she’s already so horny for it. I can’t imagine how she’s going to be once she gets our dicks a few times.
I look up and see her eyes are locked on the spot where our bodies are about to be connected. “Look at me, Lucky.” She looks up and meets my gaze. I want to tell her I love her, and I want to ask her to be our wife, but the only thing that comes out is, “Thank you.”
She reaches up and touches my face, nodding her head. I look at Justin, and he nods at me too, letting me know it’s time.
My cock leaks cum, and so that, combined with all her juices coating her pussy, lets me know she’s ready. I thrust hard, breaking her virginity and seating myself fully inside her hot, slick channel. She lets out a small squeal, but I see Justin rubbing her clit and sucking her nipples to try to make her pleasure outweigh the pain.
“Oh fuck. She’s too tight.” I start to pull out because I can’t take it. The pressure is too much, and it feels too fucking good.
“Don’t,” Justin warns me. “Just wait. Let her adjust and just breathe through it. Rock back and forth a little.”
“She’s so fucking tight. Oh God, it’s so good. I can’t hold on.”
Stella wiggles underneath us, but I’m so far gone that Justin is having to pet her and help her body relax. I don’t know how one man can do this on his own. She feels incredible, and I’m having a hard time focusing on anything. I’m glad he’s here to ensure this is good for her, because I’m losing it.
I gently rock in and out of her, and I can feel her pussy clench around me. “Fuck,” I gasp. It’s all I can manage to get out as I start to cum.
“Goddamn, he’s already going,” I hear Justin murmur to Stella.
I should probably be embarrassed to be cumming so fast, but the only thing I can think of is how perfect her pussy feels wrapped around my cock, and how her little pulses are sucking the cum out of my cock and into her virgin womb. I push my cock as far inside her as her tight cunt will allow, and fill it up.
Once I’ve come down from my orgasm, I start to breathe normally again, and I can focus on what’s happening. The need to cum in her was so strong, I couldn’t process anything other than my base instinct. I start to rock into her again, and I look down to see Justin still playing with her clit.
“I’m good to go for a few more minutes. Let’s make Lucky feel good.”
Justin nods his head in agreement and leans down to suck her nipples again. I take longer strokes, easing out of her young pussy, watching it eat my dick up as I push back inside. Her greedy cunt just got its cherry popped and filled with cum, and she’s pulling me back in like she wants more.
“Fuck, baby. This pretty pussy feels so good.” She clenches at my words, and I have to grit my teeth not to lose my nut again so soon. Goddamn, does she want it bad. “I think maybe Justin should get you off while I’m inside you. What do you think?”
Stella moans and grips Justin’s hair. I lower her legs to the bed, but remain sitting up, still inside her. I lean back a little, exposing her pussy for Justin, and he kisses his way down her belly. Once he gets to her clit, I pause my thrusts, and just hold my dick still inside her, letting her feel full of me, while Justin spreads her pussy lips and sucks her clit. I feel her clench around me, but I don’t move. Justin reaches up and pinches her nipple, sucking her clit at the same time. Stella moans so loudly, I know she’s close to the edge. All I have to do is hold my dick inside her as he sucks her pussy into cumming.
Her back bows off the bed a little, but Justin holds her down and makes her take it. She grips me so fucking tightly that I can’t even move, but I’m already starting to cum. Justin sucks her a little more and gives her gentle licks as she comes back down to earth.
When he pulls away, I thrust twice more and cum inside her for the second time tonight. I smile to myself because there are so many more times to come.
“Hurry up and pull out, I’ve got to get off.”
I look down and see a puddle of cum on the bed, and it looks like Justin has already gotten off once too. But his cock is still just as hard as mine. I pull out, falling to the side while he moves into position.