“I want to see you. Lift both hands over your head.”
I raise the diffused light until I can peer around the semidark. I see his hands. Raised and empty. Ten feet away.
“Keep your hands up and come my way. Walk past me and stand in front of the door.”
The hands start moving. “Just remember, Detective, if you shoot me, you lose Nicole.”
“I’m well aware of that.”
Those raised hands move toward the door. Are they definitely his hands? Could he have taken another hostage?
I see a head. The hood is raised. Yes, that’s it. He has a hostage—
The figure looks over. It’s Benjamin. I give a start, and he smiles.
“Jumpy, Detective?” he says.
I clench my teeth. It must be a trick.
Yet what is he doing? Exactly as I say. Staying calm. Following orders. That’s good, isn’t it?
He’s a desperate man. He may not believe I’ll let him go, but this gives him a chance. Lead me into the forest, let me think I’m in charge, and then, when we’re safely away from Rockton, turn the tables. Take me captive.
That’s the answer. It’s always been the answer. He accused me of being arrogant, but that’s him projecting his own hubris onto his opponent. He’s going to walk into that forest for the same reason he thought I would—confident we can escape.
“Good enough?” he says, standing in front of the open doorway.
“Stay where you are.”
“Yes, Detective.”
I walk two steps. A bird calls outside, and I look over, startled. Benjamin’s foot flies out sideways, and I’m trying to figure out what the hell he’s doing, when the stack of lumber beside me gives way with a roar and a crash. Logs smash into my legs. He leaps at me as I stumble.
We go down, my gun skittering across the wooden floor. I’m facedown, and I go to flip over, but the cold steel of a blade bites into the back of my neck.
“You knew it was too easy,” he says. “You knew, but you couldn’t resist. So damned predictable.”
“Now what?” I say.
He hesitates, as if he expected more, maybe a sob or a plea for mercy. I know what comes next, and I’m not terribly concerned. The moment he pushes me outside that door, Mathias will be on him. Or at least on our trail.
“Now what?” I repeat. “If you think I’m going to go with you, I answered that one already.”
His thumb digs into the back of my shoulder. Into the gunshot wound. I hiss in pain. That’s what he’s looking for, and he gives a small grunt of satisfaction.
“No, Miss Casey,” he says. “This time I bow to your will. You’re not going anywhere.”
“You’re going to kill me? Is that why we’re chatting? So you can give me the gory details before you do?”
“You’re the one who started this conversation. I’m not going to kill you, Detective. You won’t die today. You won’t die tomorrow. Nor are you leaving this lumber shed.” He pauses. “No, technically, I suppose that’s not true. You are leaving it. In a way.”
Before I can respond, he says “Crawl to your left. I’ll guide you. Try anything, and I still won’t kill you. I’ll just cut the back of your neck. Do you know what happens with that? Ask Roger. Well, not now, I suppose. He and I were out hunting with his brother. Bear got the kid. Clawed the back of his neck. Roger scared the beast away, but his brother couldn’t walk after that. The settlement put the kid out of his misery. Roger didn’t like that. Didn’t like the fact I didn’t help with the bear either. I don’t know why I would. His brother was a whiny brat. So Roger left the settlement. Which is the long way of saying that I know what happens if I put this blade through the back of your neck.”
“Just tell me where to go.”
He directs me left and walks behind me. I’m thinking of ways to take him down, ways to alert Mathias, weighing odds, when he says, “Stop,” and I see that he’s removed a couple of boards, opening the floor to the permafrost gap below.