I shake my head.
“I know you, Case. I see you thinking at breakneck speed.”
It snowed. That’s what I’m thinking. That it snowed a day ago, and that should make tracking Benjamin easy.
Still something about that niggles at my brain, the same way Jen’s accusation had, the same way Isabel’s story had, the same way Benjamin’s “final” words had, when he’d declared his innocence.
Something about this isn’t right. The snow … the trail …
“Tell me what you’re thinking,” Diana says. “Maybe I can help.”
“It’s nothing.”
She pulls back, rejected again, and I fight the urge to give in and tell her. It’s so hard breaking those habits. For years, she was the one I’d talk to. The only one I talked to. Even now it goes beyond mere habit. She’s sitting here looking like a whipped puppy.
I haven’t overreacted to her betrayals. I can’t trust her. I don’t ever want to be best friends again, and that’s self-protection, not bitterness and spite. But when she gives me that look, I feel like I’m the one who’s done her wrong.
I’ve never been able to understand why Diana stayed with Graham. As a female cop, I was often called on to speak to victims. So intellectually, I understand. Emotionally? No. Despite my confidence issues, I cannot imagine staying with a man who treated me like shit.
How many times has Diana—like a fickle lover—wandered off to greener pastures only to come crying back to me? How many times has she used me? Abused our friendship? Yet I’ve taken her back, and now seeing her flinch when I refuse to share my thoughts, that wounds me. Makes me feel like I’m kicking that whipped puppy.
And in that analogy, I find a distraction and pounce on it.
“You know what I really need? Some puppy therapy,” I say. “Petra said Storm was downstairs. Do you mind bringing her up?”
Diana goes still. I sit up, ignoring a stab of pain.
“Is she with Petra?” I ask.
More silence. Then, “She … It happened right after Petra left. Or maybe when Petra left. I’m not blaming her. Not blaming anyone.”
I tense. “Storm’s gone.”
“Devon is looking for her. He came by with cookies an hour ago, and I was freaking out about the puppy, so he went after her. Mathias is looking, too—he joined after I sent Devon to the butcher for scraps to lure the puppy, and Mathias joined the hunt. We’ll get her back.”
I push off the covers. “I need to—”
Diana stops me. “No, you don’t, Casey. People are searching. It’s only been a couple of hours. She slipped out somehow, and she’s having a grand old time running around out there, I’m sure, but she’s a puppy.” She gives me a wry smile. “She’s going to want her mommy soon.”
“Exactly. She doesn’t know Devon or Mathias well enough to come to them. I’m not running off into the forest, Diana. I’m just going to step outside and call.”
“Fine. Do it from the balcony. You aren’t ready for the stairs.”
SIXTY-SIX
Diana’s excuse about the stairs is bullshit. I’ve been shot in the left shoulder; I can walk just fine, even shoot just fine. That’s what I argue when ten minutes of calling from the balcony doesn’t bring Storm. Diana is adamant. I’m not going out into the forest.
“If she smells Eric, she might get lost trying to find him,” I say. “And she has no idea how to defend herself against predators.”
“No, Casey.”
I lean over the balcony railing. Paul is patrolling the yard, making regular circles around the house, and as he passes again, he waves again and calls, “They’ll find your pup, Casey. She’s just off playing in the snow.”
Snow.
My brain snags on that and again, I feel the reason should be obvious, but between the sedative and the painkillers, I feel like I’m slogging through mental molasses.
Snow. Puppy. Benjamin.
What am I miss—?
“Yes,” I murmur. I turn to Diana. “Exactly how did Storm disappear?”
“We don’t know. Petra said she’d put Storm in the kitchen because she kept trying to get upstairs. When I arrived, I went straight up to check on you. You seemed warm, so I took your temperature, and it was fine. Then I settled in. It was maybe a half hour later before I remembered the puppy. I’m sorry about that.”
“Your priority was me, and you thought Storm was safely in the kitchen. Except she wasn’t, right?”
Diana nods.
“And the backdoor was closed and locked?”
She hesitates.
“Diana…?”
“I’m walking a minefield here, Casey. You know how I feel about Petra. When I arrived in Rockton, Petra and I hung around. Then you came along, and it was just like with Will—Casey arrives, and I’m persona non grata.”
I squeeze my eyes shut.