Execution Dock

chapter Seven
Monk sat quietly in the parlor and went through all Durban 's notes yet again, and found nothing in them that he had not seen before. So many pages held just a word or two, reminders in a train of thought that was gone forever now The only man who might be able to make sense of it was Orme, and so far his loyalty had kept him silent about all except the most obvious.

Hesitantly and with deep unhappiness, Hester had told Monk what the prostitute, Mina, had said about Jericho Phillips, and finally, white-faced, she had added that Durban had grown up in the same area. The whole story of the schoolmaster and the happy family living in a village on the Estuary was a dream, something he created out of his own hungers for things he had never known. Hester had knotted her hands and blinked back sudden tears as she had told him.

Monk had wanted to disbelieve it. What was a blank school registry, a parish record, the word of an injured prostitute, compared with his own knowledge of a man like Durban, who had served the River Police for a quarter of a century? He had earned the love and loyalty of his men, the respect of his superiors, and the healthy fear of criminals great and small the length of the river.

And yet Monk did believe it. He felt guilty, as if it were a kind of betrayal. He was turning his back on a friend when there was no one else to defend him. What did that say of Monk? That he was weak in faith and loyalty, placing himself first? Or a realist who knew that even the best of men have their flaws, their times of temptation and vulnerability?

He could argue with himself forever and resolve nothing. It was time to look harder for the truth, to stop using loyalty to justify evading it. He put the papers away and found Orme.

But it was late in the morning before they were alone where there would be no interruption. They had very satisfactorily solved a warehouse robbery and the thieves had been arrested. Orme stood on the dock near the King Edward Stairs as Monk finished congratulating him on the arrest.

"Thank you, sir," Orme acknowledged. "The men did a good job."

"Your men," Monk pointed out.

Orme stood a trifle straighter. "Our men, sir."

Monk smiled, feeling worse about what he had to do. There was no time to delay it. He liked Orme and he needed his loyalty. More than that, he admitted, he wanted his respect, but leadership was not about what you wanted. There would not be a better time to ask; maybe not another time at all today.

"How well did Durban know Phillips, Mr. Orme?"

Orme drew in his breath, then studied Monk's face, and hesitated.

"I have a good idea already," Monk told him. "I want your view of it. Was Fig's death the beginning?"

"No, sir." Orme stood more stiffly. The gesture was not one of insolence-there was nothing defiant in his face-just a stiffening against an awaited pain.

"When was the beginning?"

"I don't know, sir. That's the truth." Orme's eyes were clear.

"So far back, then?"

Orme flushed. He had given himself away without meaning to. It was obvious in his tightened lips and squared shoulders that he also saw that Monk knew, and that evasions were no longer possible. It would have to be the truth, or a deliberate, planned lie. But Orme was not a man who could lie, unless it were to save life, and even then it would not come lightly.

Monk hated everything that had put him in the position of having to do this. He still did not wish to give away Durban 's own lies about his youth. Orme might guess; that was different from knowing.

"When was the first time you knew it was personal?" Monk asked. He phrased it carefully.

Orme took a deep breath. The sounds and movement of the river were all around them: the ships, swaying in the fast-running tide; the water lapping on the stones; light in ever-shifting patterns, reflected again and again; birds wheeling and crying overhead; the clank of chains; the grind of winches; men shouting in the distance.

"About four years ago, sir," Orme replied. "Or maybe five."

"What happened? How was it different from what you'd seen before?"

Orme shifted his balance. He was very clearly uncomfortable.

Monk waited him out.

"One minute it was just Mr. Durban asking questions, the next minute the whole air of it changed an' they were shouting at each other," Orme replied. "Then before you could do anything about it, Phillips had a knife out-great long thing it was, with a curved blade. He was swinging it wide..." He gestured with his own arm. "Like he meant to kill Mr. Durban. But Mr. Durban saw it coming an' moved aside." He swerved with his body, mimicking the action. There was both strength and grace in it. What he was describing became more real.

"Go on," Monk urged.

Orme was unhappy.

"Go on!" Monk ordered. "Obviously he didn't kill Durban. What happened? Why did he want to? Was Durban accusing him of something? Another boy killed? Who stopped Phillips? You?"

"No, sir. Mr. Durban stopped him himself."

"Right. How? How did Durban stop a man like Phillips coming at him with a knife? Did he apologize? Back off?"

"No!" Orme was offended at the thought.

"Did he fight back?"

"Yes."

"With a knife?"

"Yes, sir."

"He was carrying a knife, and he was good enough with it to hold off a man like Jericho Phillips?" Monk's surprise showed in his voice. He could not have done that himself At least he thought he could not have. Possibly in the closed-up past, further back than his memory, he had learned such things. "Orme!"

"Yes, sir! Yes, he was. Phillips was good, but Mr. Durban was better. He fought him right back to the edge of the water, sir, then he drove him into it. Half drowned, Phillips was, and in a rage fit to kill us all, if he could have."

Monk remembered what Hester had told him about Phillips and the water, and about being cold. Had Durban known that? Had Orme? He looked across at Orme's face and tried to read it. He was startled to see not only reluctance, but also a certain kind of stubbornness he knew he could not break, and he realized he did not want to. Something innate in the man would be damaged. He also saw a kind of pity, and knew without any doubt that he was not only protecting Durban 's memory, he was protecting Monk as well. He knew Monk's vulnerability, his need to believe in Durban. Orme was trying to keep a truth from him because he would be hurt by it.

They stood facing each other in the sun and the wind, the smell of the tide and the swirl and slap of the water.

"Why did that make you think they knew each other?" Monk asked. It was only part of the question, allowing Orme to avoid the answer if he wanted to.

Orme cleared his throat. He relaxed so very slightly it was almost invisible. "What they said, sir. Don't remember the words exactly. Something about what they knew, and remembered, that sort of thing."

Monk thought about asking if they had known each other long, since youth, maybe, and then he decided against it. Orme would only say that he did not hear anything like that. Monk understood. The water was the answer, the cold, and Phillips's hatred. Hester's prostitute was not lying.

"Thank you, Mr. Orme," he said quietly. "I appreciate your honesty."

"Yes, sir." Orme totally relaxed at last.

Together they turned and walked back towards Wapping.

***

For the next two days Monk called into the station only to keep track of the regular work of the police. Reluctantly he took Scuff with him. Scuff himself was delighted. He was quite aware that some of the earlier errands had been to keep him safe rather than because they needed doing. Monk had imagined himself tactful, and was somewhat taken aback to find that Scuff had read him so easily. He certainly could not apologize, at least not openly, but he would be less clumsy in the future, at least in part because Scuff was so determined to prove his value, and his ability to take care not only of himself but of Monk also.

Their paths crossed Durban 's several times. He had learned the names of almost a dozen boys of various ages who had ended up in Phillips's care. Surely among them there must have been at least two or three willing to testify against him.

They followed one trail after another, up and down both banks of the river, questioning people, searching for others.

At one point Monk found himself in a fine old building at the Legal Quay. He stood with Scuff in a wooden-paneled room with polished tables and floorboards worn uneven with the tread of feet over a century and a half. It smelled of tobacco and rum, and he almost felt as if he could hear age-old arguments from the history of the river echoing in the tight, closed air.

Scuff stared around him, eyes wide. "I in't never been in 'ere before," he said softly. "Wot der they do 'ere, then?"

"Argue the law," Monk answered.

"In 'ere? I thought they did that in courts."

Maritime law, Monk explained. To do with who can ship things, laws of import and export, weights and measures, salvage at sea, that sort of thing. Who unloads, and what duty is owed to the revenue."

Scuff pulled a face of disgust, dragging his mouth down at the corners. " Lot o' thieves," he replied. "Shouldn't believe a thing they tell yer."

"We're looking for a man whose daughter died and whose grandson disappeared. He's a clerk here."

They found the clerk, a sad, pinch-faced man in his fifties.

"How would I know?" he said miserably when Monk began his questions. "Mr. Durban asked me the same things, an' I gave 'im the same answers. Moll's 'usband got killed on the docks when Billy were about two year old. She married again to a great brute wot treated 'er real 'ard. Beat Billy till 'e broke 'is bones, poor little beggar." His face was white, and his eyes were wretched at the memory, and his own helplessness to alter it. "Weren't nothin' I could do. Broke my arm when I tried. Off work for two months, I were. Damn near starved. Billy ran off when 'e were about five. I 'eard Phillips took 'im in an' fed 'im reg'lar, kept 'im warm, gave 'im a bed, an' far as I know, 'e never beat 'im. I let it be. Like I told Mr. Durban, it were better than 'e'd 'ad before. Better than nothin'."

"What happened to Moll?" Monk asked, then instantly wished he had not.

"Took ter the streets, o' course," the clerk answered. "Wot else could she do? Kept movin', so 'e wouldn't find 'er. But 'e did. Killed 'er wi' a knife. Mr. Durban got 'im for that. 'Anged, 'e were." He blinked away tears. "I went an' watched. Gave the 'angman sixpence to 'ave a drink on me. But I never found Billy."

Monk did not reply. There hardly seemed anything to say that was not trite, and in the end, meaningless. There must be many boys like Billy, and Phillips used them. But would their lives without him have been any better, or longer?

Monk and Scuff ate hot meat pies, sitting by the dockside in the noise of unloading, watching the lightermen coming and going across the water. There was a long apprenticeship to the craft of steering them, and Monk watched them with a certain admiration. There was not only skill but also a peculiar grace in the way they balanced, leaned, pushed, realigned their weight, and did it again.

There was steady noise around them as they ate their pies and drank from tin mugs of tea. Winches ground up and down with the clang of chains, dockers shouted at one another, lumpers carried kegs and boxes and bales. There was the occasional jingle of harness and clatter of hooves as horses backed up with heavily loaded drays, and then the rattle of wheels on the stone. The rich, exotic aroma of spices and the gagging smell of raw sugar drifted across from another wharf, mixed with the stinging salt and fish and weed of the tide, and now and then the stench of hides.

Once or twice Scuff looked at Monk as if he were going to say something, then changed his mind. Monk wondered if he were trying to find a way to tell him that boys like Billy were better off with Phillips than frozen or starved to death in some warehouse yard.

"I know," he said abruptly.

"Eh?" Scuff was caught by surprise.

"It isn't all one way. We aren't going to get boys like Billy to tell us anything."

Scuff sighed, and took another huge bite of his pie.

"Would you like another one?" Monk asked him.

Scuff hesitated, unused to generosity and not willing to chance his luck.

Monk was not hungry, but he lied. "I do. If you fetch one for me, you might as well get one for yourself."

"Oh. Well." Scuff considered for about a second, then stood up. "Don't mind if I do." He held out his hand for the money. "D'yer want another cup o' tea, an' all?"

"Thank you," Monk replied. "I don't mind if I do."

It took them quite a while to find a boy willing to speak to them, and it was Orme who finally succeeded. It was in one of the alleys close to the water. The passageway was so narrow a tall man could stretch his arms and touch both sides at the same time, and the buildings almost met at the roof edges, creating the claustrophobic feeling of a series of tunnels. It was crowded with shops: bakers, chandlers, ships' outfitters, ropemakers, tobacconists, pawnbrokers, brothels, cheap lodging houses, and taverns. There were openings into workshops and yards for the making, mending, or fitting of every piece of wood, metal, canvas, rope, or fabric that had to do with the sea and its cargo or its trade.

The wood creaked and settled, water dripped, footsteps sounded uneasily, and the shadows on the walls were always moving. Sometimes it was caused by light from the shifting tide in a dock inlet, water slapping against stone walls, or the thump of timber against the sides. More often it was someone running or creeping, or carrying a load. The stench of river mud and human waste was overpowering.

The boy refused to be named. He was thin and sallow. It was hard to tell his age, but it was probably somewhere between fifteen and twenty. He had a chipped front tooth, and one finger missing on his right hand. He stood with his back to the wall, staring at them as if expecting an attack.

"I in't swearing ter nothin'," he said defensively. "If 'e finds me, 'e'll kill me." His voice wobbled. "Ow d'yer find me, anyway?" He looked first at Monk, then at Orme, ignoring Scuff.

"From Mr. Durban's notes," Orme answered. "It's worth two shillings to you to answer truthfully, then we'll forget we ever saw you."

"Answer wot? I dunno nothin!"

"You know why so few boys ever run away," Monk told him. "Young ones we can understand. They've nowhere to go, and are too small to look after themselves. What about older ones, fourteen or fifteen? If you don't want to go to sea, why not simply leave? Customers are coming and going from the ship, aren't they? Couldn't you go out with one of them? He can't keep you locked up all the time."

The boy gave him a look of withering contempt. "There's twenty of us or more. We can't all go! Some are scared, some are sick, some are just babes. Where can we go? 'Oo'd feed us, get us clothes, give us a place ter sleep? 'Oo'd 'ide us from Phillips, or 'is like? There's just as bad on shore."

"You're on shore now and safe from him. And I'm not talking about the young ones. I asked about boys your age," Monk pressed him. "Why don't they go, one by one, before he sells them to a ship?"

The boy's face was bitter. "You mean why'd 'e kill Fig, an' Reilly an' them like that? 'Cause they stood up agin 'im. It's a lesson, see? Do as yer told an' yer'll be all right. Fed, somewhere ter sleep, shoes and a jacket. Mebbe a new one every year. Make trouble an' yer'll get yer throat cut."

"Escape?" Monk reminded him.

The boy gulped, his thin face twisting painfully. "Escape, an' 'e'll 'unt yer down an' kill yer. But before that, 'e'll 'urt the little kids left be'ind, burn their arms an' legs, maybe worse. I wake up in the night 'earin' 'em scream... an' find it's just rats. But I still 'ear 'em in me 'ead. That's why I wish I 'adn't left, but I can't go back now. But I in't swearin' ter nothin'. I told Mr. Durban that, an' I'm tellin' you. Yer can't make me."

"I never thought to try," Monk said gently. "I couldn't live with it either. I have enough already, without adding that. I just wanted to know." He fished in his pocket and pulled out the two shillings Orme had promised the boy. He held them out.

The boy hesitated, then snatched them. Monk stood aside so he could pass.

The boy hesitated.

Monk backed further away.

The boy dived past him as if terrified he would be seized, then he ran with surprising speed, almost silent on the cobbles. Only then did Monk realize his feet were bound in rags, not boots. Within seconds he had disappeared into one of the many alleys like a tunnel mouth, and he could have been no more than the voice of a nightmare.

As they walked back towards the open air of the dockside, they kept in step with each other, walking single file because there was no room to do anything else. Monk went first, glad of the enforced silence between them. What the boy had said was hideous, but he never questioned the truth of it. It explained not only why no one had testified against Phillips, but also why Durban had been fired by an uncontrollable anger. Helplessness and a sense of the terror and pain, the sheer despair of others, had drowned the outside world and its balance, its values of caution and judgment.

Monk felt closer to Durban as he made his way along the tortuous alleys, following memory and the sound of water yard by yard towards the open river. He understood not only his actions but also the emotions that must have crowded his mind and made his muscles clench and his stomach churn. He shared the anger, the need to hurt someone in return for all the wrong.

But was Monk remembering him as he had really been? Or was grief painting it in warmer colors of companionship than reality? He did not believe that. It was not only dishonest, it was also cowardly to pretend now that the sense of friendship had been artificial. He could still hear Durban 's voice and his laughter, taste the bread and beer, and feel the companionable silence as dawn came up over the river. They watched the light spread across the water, catching the ripples and brightening on the drifting mist that hid some of the harsher outlines, lending beauty to the crooked spars of a wreck and blurring the jagged line of utilitarian buildings.

Scuff was immediately behind him now, padding along, looking warily to either side. Narrowness frightened him. He did not want to think about what hid in the passages. He had heard what the boy said about the others that Phillips had taken. He knew it could happen to him also. Without Monk, it could happen very easily. He wanted to reach out and take hold of Monk's coat, but that would be a very undignified thing to do, and it would tell everybody that he was afraid. He would not like Orme to think that of him, and he could not bear it if Monk did. He might even tell Hester, and that would be worse still.

They worked for several more days questioning lightermen, ferrymen, dockers, and mudlarks. They found thieves and beggars, heavy horsemen, and opulent receivers, asking each about Durban and his pursuit of Phillips. It took them upstream and down both sides of the river, on docksides, and into warehouses, alleys, shops, taverns, doss-houses, and brothels.

On one occasion the search for information took Monk and Scuff into the Strangers' Home in Limehouse. It was a handsome and commodious building on the West India Dock Road.

"Cor!" Scuff said, deeply impressed by the entrance. He stared up and round at the sheer size of it, so utterly different from the narrow and squalid houses they had been in earlier where men slept a dozen to a room.

They were passed by an African seaman, his smooth, dark skin like a polished nut against his white shirt. Almost on his heels came a Malay in striped trousers and an old pea jacket, walking with a slight roll, as if still aboard ship.

Scuff stood transfixed. He heard a score of languages and dialects around him in the main room crowded with men of every shade of skin and cast of feature.

Monk yanked him by the hand to waken him from his daydream, and half-dragged him towards the man he was seeking, a seaman from Madras who had apparently given Durban information several times.

"Oh, yes, sir, yes," the seaman agreed when Monk put the question to him. "Certainly I spoke to Mr. Durban on several occasions. He was seeking to apprehend a very bad man, which is uncommonly difficult when the man is protected by the fact that he is using children who are too frightened of him to speak out."

"Why did he ask you?" Monk said without preamble.

The man raised his eyebrows. "There are certain men that I know, you see? Not from any choice, of course, but in a way of business. Mr. Durban thought I might be aware of earlier... how shall I express it? Weaknesses? Do you understand me, sir?"

Monk had neither time nor patience for obliqueness. "Patrons of Phillips's boat, and its entertainment?"

The man winced at Monk's bluntness.

"Exactly so. It seemed to me that he had the belief that certain of these men had great influence when it came to bringing the law into such matters, and quite naturally a strong desire that it remain a private affair."

"Among Phillips, these gentlemen, and the children they abused?" Monk said brutally.

"Quite so. I see that you understand entirely."

"And were you able to help him?"

The man shrugged. "I gave him names and instances, but I have no proof."

"What names?" Monk said urgently.

"Certain harbormasters, revenue men, the owner of a brothel, a merchant who is also a receiver, although very few know it. Another name he looked for was the master of a ship who came ashore and set up his own importing business. Friend of a revenue man, so Mr. Durban said."

"That sounds more like corruption of the revenue than anything to do with Phillips," Monk answered.

"Oh, it was about Phillips," the seaman insisted. "Mr. Durban almost had 'im, two or three times. Then the evidence just vanished away like mist when the sun comes up. You can see it happen, but you can never put your hand on it, do you see?" He shook his head. "Mr. Phillips's goods are not cheap to buy, at least not the ones he sells on his dirty little boat. The men who buy them have money, and power comes from money. That's why Mr. Phillips is very difficult to catch in the hangman's noose."

Monk asked more questions, and the man answered him, but when Monk rose to leave, closely followed by Scuff, he was not certain how much more he knew. All kinds of men were involved, and at least some of them had the power to protect Phillips from the River Police.

"Yer better be careful," Scuff said, his voice tight and a little high with anxiety. He had abandoned even trying to look as if he were not frightened. He kept pace with Monk now, putting in an extra little step every so often to make up for his shorter stride. "Them revenue men is summink wicked. Get them on yer tail an' yer might never get out o' trouble. Mebbe that's why Mr. Durban backed off, like?"

"Maybe," Monk agreed.

The day after that Scuff accompanied Orme, and Monk went alone to pursue the few friends or informants he had gained in the short time he had been on the river. He began with Smiler Hobbs, a dour north countryman whose lugubrious face had earned him his nickname.

"Wot are yer after now?" Smiler asked when Monk walked into his pawnshop and closed the door behind him. "I got nothin' stolen, an' don't yer stand there like the judgment o' the Almighty. Yer put off me customers. Worse than buildin' next to a garbage dump, yer are."

"Good morning to you also, Smiler," Monk replied, making his way through the piles of pots and pans, musical instruments, flat irons, several chairs, and an endless variety of odd china. "I'll go as soon as I learn what I want to know."

"Then yer in fer a long wait, 'cause I in't got nowt stolen an' I don't know nowt about owt." Smiler glared at him.

"Of course you don't. And as to what you haven't got, I don't care," Monk responded.

Smiler looked surprised, then his eyes narrowed.

Monk remained exactly where he was. "But I could always become interested," he observed. "Nice sextant you have there. Pity it isn't at sea, doing some good."

Smiler's expression became even more dismal, as if he were staring at the ultimate disaster.

"When Mr. Durban was trying to prove that Jericho Phillips was responsible for the boy's death, did he speak to you about it?" Monk asked.

"Which boy's death?" Smiler retorted.

Monk was about to snap back with Fig's name, then he saw the wider opportunity and seized it. "Reilly," he replied. "Or any of the others?"

"'E asked everyone," Smiler told him. "Like I said, I know nowt about it, or anythin' else. I buy things as people need ter sell, an' I sell things they need ter buy. Public service, it is."

"I know you do. I need to buy information."

"I don't give away nowt."

"Neither do I," Monk agreed. "At least not often. You tell me what I want to know, and I'll pay you by not coming back here to keep on asking."

Smiler pulled down the corners of his mouth until his face was a mask of tragedy. "No better than Durban, yer aren't. Pick on the easy ones an' twist them, an' all the while creatures like Phillips, Pearly Boy, an' the Fat Man cut people's throats like they was rats, an' wot do yer lot do about it? Nowt! Absolutely, bloody nowt!"

"The Fat Man's dead," Monk told him.

"Yeah? Maybe." Smiler was skeptical.

"For certain," Monk responded truthfully. "I saw him go down, and I know for sure he never came up. I was there."

Smiler gave a long sigh. "Then yer done summink right fer once. But yer made an almighty mess o' gettin' Phillips. I s'pose someone got ter yer too, just like they did ter Durban. Yer can't beat the devil. Yer'll learn, if yer live long enough." He sighed again. "Which I doubt."

Monk swallowed. "Who got to Durban?"

"Ow do I know?" Smiler asked sadly. "'Arbormaster, magistrates, men with money and their heads in politics. Lumpers, fer all I know, judges too. Yer cut off one arm, an' while yer lookin' for the second one, it'll grow the first one back again. Yer'll not win. Yer'll just end up dead, like Durban. No one'll care. They'll say yer were a fool, and they'll be right."

"They won't say I didn't try!"

Smiler pulled an exaggerated expression, curling his lips downwards. "An' what good'll that do yer, in yer grave?"

"I'm going to see Phillips hang, I promise you," Monk said rashly. He could feel the rage boil up inside him and see in his mind Phillips's sneering face in the dock as the verdict came in.

"Yer'd best slit 'is throat, if yer can catch 'im," Smiler advised. "Yer'll not catch him fair, any more than Durban did. After 'im like a terrier with a rat one minute, an' the next he backed off like 'e'd been bit 'isself Then six months later, back after 'im again. Then out of the blue sky, 'ands off an' leave 'im alone as if 'e were the Lord Mayor o' the river. Durban din't call the tune, I can promise you that. An' neither will yer, for all yer swank coat an' yer quality boots. Yer'll end up just like 'im, bitin yer own tail. I'll give yer ten shillings fer them boots, if yer don't ruin 'em first?"

"So someone's protecting him," Monk said acidly. "I'll get them too. And I'll keep my boots."

Smiler gave a sharp bark that with him passed for laughter. "Yer don't even know 'oo they are. An' before yer start threatening me, like Durban did, I take bloody good care not ter know either. Offer's open on the boots."

"Who is Mary Webber?"

"Gawd! Not yer too?" Smiler rolled his eyes. "I got no idea. I never 'eard of 'er till Durban came threatenin' everyone with Gawd knows what if we didn't tell 'im. I dunno!" His voice rose sharply aggrieved. "Get it? I dunno!" Now get out of 'ere an' leave me to do me business, before I set the dog on yer... by accident, like. I keep 'im on a chain, but sometimes I think it in't too strong. Not my fault. Not that that'll 'elp yer much."

Monk retreated, his mind crowded with thoughts. He was quite sure Smiler would lie if it suited him, but what he had said fit in too well with the facts so far.

Durban was not the simple man that Monk had thought, and that he had wanted him to be.

He crossed the road and turned back towards Shadwell High Street.

Yet Monk could remember the man he had known vividly: his patience, his candor, the way he unquestioningly shared food and warmth, his optimism, his compassion for even the most wretched. Could it all have been a lie, even his laughter?

He shivered even though the sun was bright off the water and the air was warm. There was a sound of music in the distance from a hurdy-gurdy somewhere out of sight.

What a living hell this world was. But for boys like Fig, and perhaps Reilly, and any number of others whose names he would never know, there had been no choice, and no escape, except death.

No wonder Durban had done everything he could to catch Phillips and have him hanged, even at the cost of bending a few rules. Or that the men who had already paid so much paid even more to protect their provider and tormentor. It gave new layers to the concept of corruption.

Who had paid Oliver Rathbone to defend this man in court? And why?

Monk was on the open dock now, not far from Wapping. The tide was rising, and the water lapped over the stone steps, creeping higher and higher. The smell of it was harsh, and yet he had become accustomed to it, welcomed it. This was the greatest maritime highway in the world, beautiful and terrible in all its moods. At night its poverty and dirt were hidden. Lights of ships from Africa and the Pole, China and Barbados, danced on the tides. The city, domed and towered, was black against the stars.

At dawn it would be misted, softened by silver, fast-running waters glittering. There were moments in the flare of sunset when it could have been Venice, the dome of St. Paul 's above the shadows a marble palace floating on the lagoon towards the silk roads of the east.

The sea lanes of the world met here: the glory, the squalor, the heroism, and the vice of all humanity, mixed with the riches of every nation known to man.

He faced the question deliberately.

What would Monk have done were it someone he loved who faced exposure and ruin from Phillips? Would he have protected them? Belief in your ideals was one thing, but when it was a living human being who trusted you, or perhaps deepest of all, who loved and protected you in your need, that was different. Could you turn away? Was your own conscience more precious than their lives?

Did you owe loyalty to the dead? Yes, of course you did! You did not forget someone the moment the last breath left their lips.

He looked around the skyline to the north and south, and across the teeming water. This was a city of memories, built of the great men and women of the past.

Around midafternoon of the next day, Monk faced the opulent receiver known as Pearly Boy. He had been known that way for so long nobody could remember what his original name had been, but it was only since the death of the Fat Man the previous winter that he had taken over a far larger slice of business along the river, and prospered to the degree of wealth that he now possessed.

He was slender and soft-faced, and he wore his hair rather long. He always spoke quietly, with a very slight lisp, and no one had seen him, winter or summer, without his waistcoat, which was stitched with hundreds of pearl buttons that gleamed in the light. He was the last man one would expect to have a reputation for ruthlessness not only for a hard bargain, but if necessary, with a knife- pearl-handled, of course.

They were sitting in the small room behind Pearly Boy's shop in Limehouse. The shop was ostensibly to sell ships' instruments: compasses, sextants, quadrants, chronometers, barometers, astrolabes. Set out in order on a table was a variety of dividers and parallel rules. But Pearly's main business took place in the back room, largely concerning stolen jewelry, objets d'art, paintings, carvings, and jewel-encrusted ornaments. He had already taken over most of the Fat Man's territory.

He looked at Monk blandly, but his eyes were as cold as a polar sea. "Always 'appy to 'elp the police," he said. "What are you looking for, Mr. Monk? It is 'Monk,' isn't it? 'Eard word, you know. Reputation."

Monk did not take the bait.

"Yes, indeed," he said with a nod. "Something we have in common."

Pearly Boy was startled. "What's that then?"

"Reputation." Monk was unsmiling. "I understand you're a hard man too."

Pearly Boy thought that was funny. He started to giggle, and it grew and swelled into rich chortling laughter. Finally he stopped abruptly, wiping his cheeks with a large handkerchief. "I'm going to like you," he said, his face beaming, his eyes like wet stones.

"I'm delighted," Monk replied, sounding as though he had smelled spoiling milk. "We might be of use to each other."

That was language Pearly Boy definitely understood, even if he was dubious about believing it. "Oh, yeah, an' how's that then?"

"Friends and enemies in common," Monk explained.

Pearly Boy was interested. He tried to hide it, and failed. "Friends?" he said curiously. "'Oo's friends o' yours, then?"

"Let's start with enemies," Monk answered with a smile. "One of yours was the Fat Man." He saw the flash of hatred and triumph in Pearly Boy's eyes. "One of mine too," Monk added. "You have me to thank that he's dead."

Pearly Boy licked his lips. "I know that. I 'eard. Drowned in the mud off Jacob's Island, they say."

"That's right. Nasty way to go." Monk shook his head. "Would have fished the body up, but it was hardly worth it. Got the statue, which is what mattered. He'll keep down there nicely."

Pearly Boy shuddered. "You're a hard bastard, all right," he agreed, and Monk was not sure whether he meant it as a compliment or not.

"I am," Monk conceded. "I'm after several people, and I don't forget either a good turn or a bad one. Who is Mary Webber?"

"No idea. Never 'eard of 'er. Which means she's not in my business. She int a thief nor a receiver nor a customer," Pearly Boy said flatly.

Monk was not surprised; he had not expected her to be. "And I'm after a boy named Reilly, and even more than that, I'm after whoever was forced into looking after him, seeing to it that he didn't get hurt."

Pearly Boy opened his eyes wide. "Forced? Ow could anyone be forced? 'Oo would do that, an' why, Mr. Monk?"

"Mr. Durban would have done it," Monk replied steadily. "Because he didn't like having boys murdered."

"Well, I never." Pearly Boy affected amazement, but his curiosity overcame his judgment, as Monk had hoped it would. Pearly Boy dealt not only in stolen goods but in rare or precious information as well- that too at times stolen. "'Oo could stop that 'appening, then?"

"Someone with power." Monk said it as though he were thinking out loud. "And yet someone who had a lot to lose as well, a lot in danger, if you understand me?"

Pearly Boy was still two steps behind. "'Oo'd be killin' boys, then?"

"Jericho Phillips, if they get out of line, rebel against..." He stopped, seeing Pearly Boy's face go suddenly pallid and his body in its decorated waistcoat stiffen until his arms were rigid. Suddenly Monk was as certain Pearly Boy was one of Durban 's informants against Phillips as if he had written it in his notes. He smiled and saw in Pearly Boy's eyes that he had read the understanding, and it knotted his stomach with terror.

"One of Phillips's clients," Monk went on, his voice quite casual now. He leaned elegantly against the mantel, watching Pearly Boy's discomfort. "I can imagine it happening, can't you? Durban would have followed the man until he could confront him, maybe somewhere near Phillips's boat. Perhaps it would be just after this man, whoever he is, had left a night's entertainment, and the excitement and guilt were still hot inside him."

Pearly Boy was motionless, eyes on Monk's face.

"No lie would come to him easily then," Monk continued. "No matter how often he had prepared for such a moment. Durban would have chosen a place where there was enough light to be sure the man recognized his marks of office, his uniform, his cudgel. Yes, he'd definitely take a cudgel, just in case the man was desperate enough to fight. After all, he would have a lot to lose-public disgust, ridicule, loss of position, friends, money, power, perhaps even his family."

Pearly Boy licked his lips nervously.

"Then Durban would make the offer," Monk said. "'Use your power to protect Reilly, the boy most in danger because of his age and his courage, and I'll protect you. Let Reilly die, and I'll expose you to the whole of London.'"

Pearly Boy licked his lips again. "So 'oo was it then?"

"That is what I want from you, Pearly Boy," Monk answered.

Pearly Boy cleared his throat. "An' if I don't? It could 'ave been lots o' people. I dunno 'oo's got that kind o' weakness. It could be a revenue man, a magistrate, a rich merchant, an 'arbormaster. They got all kinds o' tastes. Or it could 'ave been another policeman! Ever thought o' that?"

"Of course I have. Who could have protected Reilly? That's the key to it. Who had the power? Above all, who was important enough to Phillips that he would listen to him?"

Understanding flashed in Pearly Boy's soft, clever face, and the excitement of knowledge. "You mean 'oo's got an appetite 'e can't control, an' needs Phillips ter feed it, an' yet 'e's got some kind o' power to 'elp Phillips that's so good Phillips 'as got to keep 'im sweet too? That's a nice one, Mr. Monk, a very nice one indeed."

"Yes, it is. And I want a nice answer," Monk agreed.

Pearly Boy's eyebrows rose. "Or what?" He was shivering very slightly Monk could smell the sweat of fear in the closed air of the room. "What if I can't find out?" He tried a bit of bravado. "Or if I decide not to?"

"I shall see that Phillips knows that you told Mr. Durban about this very interesting client, and are on the point of telling me, when we can agree on a price."

Pearly Boy was white, the sweat beading on his face. "And what price would that be?" he asked hoarsely.

Monk smiled, showing his teeth. "Future silence, and a certain shortsightedness now and then, where the revenue men are concerned."

"Dead men are silent," Pearly Boy said through thin lips.

"Not those who can write, and leave clear instructions behind them. Mr. Durban might have been very nice to you. I won't be."

"I could 'ave you killed. Dark night, narrow alley?"

"The Fat Man's dead. I'm not," Monk reminded him. "Take the easy way, Pearly Boy. You're a receiver, not a murderer. You kill a River Policeman, you'll be tracked down. Do you want to be buried feetfirst in the Thames mud, never come back up again?"

Pearly Boy went even paler still. "You'll owe me!" he challenged, his eyes flickering a little.

Monk smiled. "I told you, I'll forget about you... to a point. I'll put you last on my list to close down, rather than first."

Pearly Boy said something obscene under his breath.

"I beg your pardon!" Monk snapped.

"I'll find 'im," Pearly replied.

Suddenly Monk was gracious. "Thank you. It will be to your advantage."

But as he left his emotions were tangled. He walked warily along the narrow street, keeping to the middle, away from the alley entrances and the sunken doorways.

What was the difference between one blackmail and another? Was it of kind, or only of degree? Did the purpose justify it?

He did not even have to think about that. If he could save any child from Phillips, he would, without a thought for the morality of his actions. But did that make him a good policeman or not? He felt uncomfortable, unhappy, uncertain in his judgment, and closer to Durban than ever before. But it was a closeness of emotion, rage and vulnerability.

And of course when Durban had died at the turn of the year, the protection of Reilly had disappeared. He had been left naked to whatever Phillips had wanted to do. That thought made him feel sick, even as he came out of the alley into the wind and the sun of the open dock.