Ali's Pretty Little Lies (Pretty Little Liars: Prequel)

“Sure,” Ali said, a strange feeling settling over her. “We’ll have to do it again sometime.”

 

 

A heartbreaking smile appeared on Emily’s face. “Really? I would love that!” Now her thigh was definitely touching Ali’s knee. Emily placed a hand over Ali’s and then pulled it away, seeming embarrassed. “I’ve been thinking about that day a lot, Ali.”

 

Suddenly, all Ali could see in her mind’s eye were those tiny letters spelling out I love Ali on Emily’s notebook. The air seemed charged—Emily seemed eager to get something off her chest. Ali was afraid she knew what it was, too. She moved her knee away in one clean jerk and touched Emily’s shoulder. “I have something to tell you,” she blurted. “It’s a secret.”

 

Emily pressed her lips together. Her eyes shone.

 

Ali licked her lips and took a deep breath. “Well, I’m sort of seeing someone. This older guy. He’s absolutely amazing.”

 

For a moment, the tree house was utterly silent. “O-oh,” Emily stammered. Her eyes darted in a lot of directions.

 

“I wanted you to know because you’re my favorite, Em. You always have been.”

 

Emily swallowed audibly. “Th-that’s great. What’s his name?”

 

“It’s . . . well, I don’t want to tell you yet. Soon though, okay?”

 

“Okay,” Emily said.

 

They were silent again. Static electricity hung in the air, as scratchy as a dryer sheet. The birds chirped. Far in the distance, someone barked out a laugh. And then, suddenly, Emily twisted her body toward Ali. Before Ali knew what was happening, Emily’s lips were touching hers. They felt soft, normal, just like a guy’s lips, really, and for a split second, Ali shut her eyes and let the sensation wash over her. In many ways, it felt good to be adored so purely. It felt good to give someone exactly what she wanted.

 

But then she came back to herself and pulled back. This wasn’t what she wanted. And people would think it was weird. How dare Emily just assume Ali would be into this?

 

All Ali could see were the whites of Emily’s eyes. Ali felt a nasty smile settle across her lips. “Well,” she heard herself say, her voice taut and mean, “I guess that’s why you get so quiet when we’re changing for gym.”

 

Emily flinched. A horrible, tortured, fake laugh leaked from her mouth. “God, sorry,” she said. “I don’t know what happened to me just then. I guess I was thinking about the guy I like and got confused.”

 

Ali laughed crudely. “I don’t think you like anyone at all, Em. I think you’re lying to me.”

 

Emily’s eyes widened. “I do like someone.”

 

“A guy?” Ali teased.

 

Tears gleamed in Emily’s eyes. She shot up and lunged for the rope ladder. “I have to go.”

 

Ali didn’t say another word as Emily climbed down and started across the yard. She watched her from the tree house as she mounted her bike and wobbled down the street, her ponytail bouncing. Emily didn’t look back once.

 

For a split second, Ali could feel Emily’s hair in her hands again, her soft skin against her face. And then she bit down hard on her lip, the emotions too jumbled inside her to make sense. On one hand, she felt disgusted. On another, she felt restored. And on another . . . well, even more than what she’d done to Hanna, she knew that she’d just altered things with her best friend for good.

 

And although Emily was probably even more in her power than ever, it felt sort of . . . awful.

 

 

 

 

 

26

 

OVER THE EDGE

 

“We’re getting close,” Nick whispered in Ali’s ear.

 

“Where are we going?” Ali stifled a nervous giggle. Grass prickled under her feet. The scents of honeysuckle and lilacs drifted through the air. In the distance, she could hear water rushing and birds chirping.

 

“It’s a surprise,” Nick said, squeezing her hand. “But I promise it’s good.”

 

It was later that afternoon, and Ali was out with Nick. They’d met at the King James, and Ali had assumed they were going to do some shopping, but then Nick had wrapped a blindfold around her and said that where he was taking her next was something she couldn’t see until they got there. As far as she knew, they’d gotten into a taxi, Nick whispering the directions so Ali wouldn’t hear. The drive had been about fifteen minutes, and gravel had crunched under the tires when they arrived.

 

“You know, I must really trust you,” Ali said now. “I wouldn’t let just anyone lead me around blindfolded.”

 

“I’m honored,” Nick said. “I just hope you like where we are.”

 

Sara Shepard's books