The Deposit Slip

2





SEVEN MONTHS LATER

HENNEPIN COUNTY COURTHOUSE

MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA


Twenty minutes after eleven, and the bench was still empty. Lawyers’ time means nothing to a judge, Jared Neaton thought. Two lawyers—him at a hundred seventy-five dollars an hour, his overdressed opponent three times that—that was over two hundred dollars in billings for a judge twenty minutes late.

Phil Olney pushed Jared with his elbow. “When’s he coming?”

“Soon,” Jared assured him. But in the courtroom, the judge was the master of the universe. He’d arrive when he arrived. No point in fighting it—you just had to learn to adjust.

“Counsel?” It was Blake Desmond, his opponent, seated at the next table, offering him a piece of paper that had slid onto the floor.

Jared thanked him with a nod, but thought, Don’t get friendly with me now. When Jared entered the courtroom half an hour ago, Desmond wouldn’t even accept his hand. He was one of those lawyers who had to show his client how tough he was. His type prowled the halls of the five Tigers, the biggest firms in the Twin Cities. With his thousand-dollar suit and Gucci shoes, Desmond exemplified the worst of the breed.

Jared glanced at his client. It had only been three days since Phil’s world took a significant turn for the worse—when he’d stumbled over a second set of books his brother, Russell, had been keeping for the check cashing business they ran. The records revealed a secret bank account in Russell’s name holding $110,000 from the brothers’ business.

That discovery was upsetting enough. The crowning insult was the new Lexus Phil saw in Russell’s garage when he went over to his house to confront him. With a wife, two kids under six, and a mortgage two months overdue, Phil’s fury almost got him jailed.

He arrived at Jared’s office on the advice of another of Jared’s clients. Over three long days and nights, Jared had earned every penny of Phil’s three-thousand-dollar retainer check preparing a motion for a temporary restraining order to freeze bank accounts, pulling together affidavits, summarizing financials, preparing the backstory, and organizing an argument why the court should grant the TRO.

The arrival of this case—and retainer—had been welcome. Jared needed the money, and not having to wait thirty days to earn it was especially good news this month.

The panel door behind the judge’s bench opened. A matronly calendar clerk stepped through, a docket sheet clutched in her hand.

“Mr. Neaton,” she called, as she dropped into her seat, “are you still with Paisley, Bowman, Battle, and Rhodes? Because we have you listed at the Paisley firm.”

“No,” Jared answered, explaining that he was on his own now. The Neaton Law Firm.

Desmond stiffened slightly and turned to Jared. “When were you with Paisley? Did you know Michael Strummer?”

“Two years ago, and yes,” Jared tossed back, before turning to dig into his briefcase for an imaginary document. It was too late for respect.

Jared glanced at his fidgeting client, then settled back in his chair and tried to look calm enough for both of them. It took practice to project confidence while waiting for a motion he was likely to lose.

Another nudge from his client. The panel door behind the judge’s bench was opening again.

“All rise,” the calendar clerk croaked. A heavy-lidded court reporter holding a stenography machine trudged into the room, followed by a young, eager-looking law clerk.

Judge Kramer entered last. Stout and slow, a long black robe draping his enormous belly, he ascended the steps to his chair, then dropped with an audible grunt.

“You may be seated,” the bailiff called. The judge, out of breath, sucked air in restrained gulps.

Jared looked to his opponent, sitting bolt upright at the table to his right, jotting final notes on a pad. Farther along sat Russell, looking straight ahead and as rigid as his brother was shaky.

Jared looked back up to the bench. The judge, his breath recovered, had opened his file and was paging the briefs from Jared and Desmond, glaring through reading glasses that teetered near the end of his nose.

Judge Kramer was a tough draw for this motion. He knew the law, but his patience had diminished the longer he sat on the bench. He often took shortcuts in his rulings.

Jared hoped that might work for them today. The law was against Phil Olney on this motion. Their chance of success hung by the thin thread of fairness—which didn’t always equate with the law. That and whatever advantage Jared could create for his client in the next few minutes.

The judge looked up and cleared his throat.

“Gentlemen, I have read your briefs.” His voice resonated with command. “This is a motion for an injunction. The plaintiff, Philip Olney, seeks to freeze Russell Olney’s bank accounts pending an audit of the brothers’ joint business. Does that about sum it up, Mr. Neaton?”

Jared rose and responded that it did.

“Proceed with your argument.”

He stepped to the podium, giving a quick thought to how cold the law could be. In his hand was a fistful of proof that Russell Olney had stolen a six-figure sum from his brother. Yet Russell’s lawyer, now watching Jared prepare to argue, would almost certainly defeat the motion today: the law was on his side.

Jared acknowledged in his opening words that an early order to freeze a party’s bank accounts was unusual. There was no point in denying it: precedent disfavored a court prejudging a case by issuing a TRO when the victim could get a judgment to recover their lost money after a trial. Though Jared did not say it, this meant that Judge Kramer should rule for Russell Olney, deny the motion, and set the case on for trial.

But Jared and his opponent understood another truth: this case would never see a trial. If Phil lost this round, he didn’t have the money to pursue it further. In the less likely event that Phil won and the judge froze Russell’s bank accounts, the opposite was true—Russell would be forced to settle or starve. Today was Phil and his brother’s only “day in court.”

“However, while it may be unusual to freeze bank assets at the start of a case,” he continued, shifting his pace, “it is not unprecedented in the right circumstances. And in this case that ruling is essential. Because Russell Olney is a thief. Not an ordinary one. Russell Olney is a thief of unusual talent, ambition, and ruthlessness.”

“Your honor,” Desmond spoke out in a deep timbre, rising slowly to his feet behind Jared’s shoulder. Jared did not turn or acknowledge him, but continued to speak.

“A thief willing to steal from his own brother, his sister-in-law, his young nephews—”

“Your Honor?”

“A man,” Jared called, brandishing an affidavit in his hand, “so cold and calculating that he was depositing stolen proceeds from the business in his secret account on the way to his own sister-in-law’s birthday party—”

“ I object!”

Oh, sweet music, Jared thought, watching the rising tide of red in Judge Kramer’s scowling face. Desmond should have done his homework.

Some judges abhorred a fight in the courtroom. They expected cordiality above all else in their domain and would punish the unwary aggressor. Judge Kramer, a former Golden Gloves champion thirty years ago, wasn’t one of them. Jared kept his face expressionless, noting the crooked profile of the judge’s nose. In his courtroom, a fight was fine. What Judge Kramer abhorred was pomposity and grandstanding.

“My client is not a thief,” Desmond went on, ignoring the storm cloud of the judge’s face. “This man”—a finger jabbed toward Phil—“this ungrateful brother would attack his own sibling with scurrilous accusations without a shred of evidence to support them! I ask for a ruling upon my objection!” he concluded, arms thrown wide.

Jared stood mute, barely able to mask his thrill of pleasure.

The judge’s red face looked near to exploding. “Mr. Desmond. Is there a jury here that is visible only to you?” Jared saw the court reporter suppress a snort. “At this moment, Mr. Neaton is not presenting evidence. He is making an argument. Do you know what an argument is?”

Russell’s face went as dead white as the judge’s was red.

“Well, Mr. Desmond, you can’t ‘object’ to an argument. Sit down.”

Desmond sat as the judge turned to Jared and proclaimed, in a softened tone, “Mr. Neaton, you may continue.”

Jared nodded and continued with a litany of Russell’s repeated, after-hours transfers of money—juxtaposing the transfer dates against the backdrop of family birthdays, business milestones, and even a Christmas Eve. Someone willing to steal from his own brother on the eve of Christmas would not hesitate to abscond with the ill-gotten funds during the long months of litigation. This, Jared concluded, was that special case justifying special measures.

Desmond’s responding delivery, though chastened, was meticulous, mapping out the same precedent that Jared had researched to reach his own conclusion that Russell had the law on his side. But the judge’s eyes remained stony throughout the presentation.

Desmond sat down at last. The judge pushed back his chair and crooked a finger toward his law clerk, who stepped up to the bench. Their whispered exchange lasted several minutes before the clerk returned to his desk.

“Gentlemen,” the judge said, leaning into the bench, “Philip Olney’s motion is granted. I will sign the order to freeze all bank accounts of the defendant, Russell Olney.”

Jared suppressed a jolt of satisfaction at these words; felt his client squeeze his arm. “Thank you, Your Honor,” he said, quickly gathering his papers. You win a motion, you get out of the courtroom fast before the judge has a chance to change his mind.

“Your Honor,” Desmond called out. “There is the matter of a bond.”

Not fast enough. Jared had hoped, if he won, that Desmond would be too startled to bring this topic up.

The judge halted in the middle of the difficult task of raising himself to leave the bench. “Are you requesting a bond?”

“Yes, Your Honor.” Desmond learned quickly, and his pitch was short and to the point. “It is generally mandatory, sir.”

The judge glowered and turned to Jared. “Counsel?”

Desmond was on the right side of the law again. The bond could be waived, but seldom was. He glanced at Phil, who he knew was running on empty. Jared had asked for a seven-thousand-dollar retainer when he took the case. Phil had responded that all he could raise was three, even after maxing out his credit cards.

“Your Honor, under the circumstances, my client is in no position to post a bond. His funds,” he said, waving toward Russell, “are in the hands of his brother.”

Jared hoped Desmond would belabor the point and annoy the judge into the leap of denying the bond. But he did not. Judge Kramer looked down to his papers and rubbed the crook of his nose between his finger and thumb.

“Very well,” he said at last. “A bond is required. But given the facts of this matter, I will require a nominal bond only, and I will give some extra time for it to be raised. Mr. Philip Olney will post a three-thousand-dollar bond with this court within ninety days, or the injunction will be dissolved.”

Jared heard a soft groan from his client. The judge ponderously descended the steps of his bench and disappeared back through the courtroom door, his staff in his wake.

Jared did not even try to shake Desmond’s hand this time, but waited until his opponent and Russell had left the courtroom. His client stood staring at him as Jared finally looked up.

“You did great,” Phil began, his eyes blank, “but no way I’ve got that kinda cash. We might as well’ve lost. I can’t put it together. An’ I can’t raise it, with the business frozen.”

Three days and nights. All the bills this one was going to cover. Jared reached into his coat pocket and pulled out his wallet. The retainer check was in the side flap. He held it up for Phil to see.

“No time to cash it. I’ll apply it to the bond.”

Philip looked uncertain. “Uh, I don’t know what to say.”

“Just say you’re good for it, Phil.”

“I am. I’m good for it, Counselor.”

Jared stuffed his papers into his battered valise. “Well, okay then.”





Back in his office, Jared sat leaning back, looking through a bar journal, when the door swung open. It was his assistant, Jessie Dickerson, her eyes lively.

“You snuck in while I was at lunch. Justice served today?”

“Clarence Darrow would have been proud.”

“Come on. Win, lose, or draw?”

Jared explained the outcome, leaving out returning the check.

“Awesome. Olney seemed all right to me.”

“Yeah, he is.” Jared couldn’t keep the pleasure entirely off of his face. He was always pleased to beat the pompous thousand-dollar-suit crowd. But Desmond wouldn’t miss a meal: knowing how the Tigers worked, he showed up in court today fully paid for his service—in advance.

It wasn’t that simple in a younger practice like Jared’s. You had to take chances with clients, like he did with Phil, hoping they weren’t deadbeats before he got too deep into their cases. He still got stung once in awhile, but that wasn’t the issue that landed his practice in the hole it was now. That happened because he’d rolled the dice on a big case—his “breakthrough case.” The Wheeler trial.

The breakthrough case: the one that catapulted your career to a new level. If you were an associate at a big firm, it generated the huge fees that made partnership a certainty. Out on your own, it was the case that made the rest of your career a choice. Some lawyers never saw one; others didn’t have the guts to seize one and hang on when it came along. Because, as Jared had just proved this past summer, the flip side of winning a breakthrough case was losing one—for him, eighteen months of work without fees and a dry well for a bank account.

There was a cough. Jared looked up to Jessie, holding out a pair of pink slips. “Phone calls for you.”

The first slip said Clay Strong. “What’s it about?”

“Don’t know. But he said it was urgent.”

The second slip was Sandra Wheeler.

“Are you going to call Mrs. Wheeler back?” Jessie asked, raising her eyebrows.

“No. Not now. I’ve already told her we won’t know anything on the appeal for months yet.”

Jessie brushed back some strands of hair from her eyes and nodded in agreement, but Jared could see she wanted to speak.

“What is it?”

“You told me there’s almost no chance of overturning the jury verdict in her case.”

“So?”

“So why not drop the appeal? Tell her it’s over.”

That would be the simplest; just surrender and move on. It was something he’d never done. One of Clay Strong’s first lessons as Jared’s mentor was that taking on a case, like marriage, was “for better or for worse.”

“No,” he answered, “I don’t think so.”

There was worry in Jessie’s eyes, but she shrugged noncommittally and left the room.





The late-afternoon sun had dipped below his window when Jared set aside the last folder on his desk and looked wearily around the office. Shadows from the building next door left the room’s light soft and gray.

His eyes stopped on a small stack of files on the sofa. There was some work there, but not a case among them had more than a thousand dollars of legal work.

Things were different before he took Sandra Wheeler as a client. Back then, his practice had momentum—steady litigation referrals from other attorneys, regular clients coming back for follow-up work. Then he took the Wheeler case. For over a year and a half, his regular clients’ work got stretched out. Calls got put off.

With too few exceptions, his clients found lawyers elsewhere—attorneys who returned their messages the same day, instead of later in the week or not at all. If not for a few loyal clients he’d brought over from Paisley—like Stanhope Printing, a company he’d represented since it was a startup—Jared wondered if he could have kept the office open.

When he got things built back up again, Jared promised himself, he wouldn’t touch another Wheeler case. Too much risk. Too much pain.

Speaking of which—Jared rotated his neck to loosen a kink tightening toward a headache. Jared just wanted to go home and lie down. He reached for his coat on the client chair next to his desk, when something pink caught his eye. He bent and picked it up. It was the slip from Clay Strong, the urgent one. When had they spoken last? At least six months.

He couldn’t afford to miss a possible referral from his old mentor. Jared sat back down in his chair and dialed the number.