The Tutor's Daughter

Chapter 6





On Sunday morning, the Smallwoods were invited—or rather, expected—to attend church with the Weston family.

At the appointed hour, everyone gathered in the hall until the carriages and carts drew up outside. Everyone except Henry Weston. No one commented on his absence, so neither did Emma. Apparently he did not attend church with his family. Why am I not surprised, she thought, less than charitably. But then her conscience smote her. For the truth was, over the last two years she attended church only because it was expected of her. She and God had not been on close terms since her mother’s death.

Emma wore her long-sleeved gown of deep blue with a high waistband and a gauzy fichu of white lawn tucked into its neckline. Glancing at the other ladies, she felt she had chosen well and in keeping with the modest gowns, capes, and bonnets Lady Weston and Lizzie were wearing. The men wore dark frock coats, sober waistcoats and cravats, and black beaver hats. Men had it so easy, Emma thought, when it came to dressing appropriately for any occasion.

Since there was no church in the small village of Ebford, the family attended services in neighboring Stratton. Sir Giles, Lady Weston, Lizzie, Rowan, and Julian crowded into the family’s large landau, its hood up against the damp mist and driven by the well-dressed coachman.

Mr. Smallwood and Emma shared the rear of a two-wheeled chapel cart pulled by one horse, with Mr. Davies at the reins. Mrs. Prowse sat on the front bench beside him. Other servants—those whose Sunday in rotation it was to attend services—rode in the wagon driven by the groom.

As the cart rumbled along, the steward and housekeeper spoke quietly to each other, leaving Emma and her father to take in the passing countryside in peace.

Fifteen or twenty minutes later, they reached Stratton and soon arrived at St. Andrew’s—an impressive grey stone church with a tall bell tower. They alighted and walked through a churchyard dotted with listing headstones and bright yellow daffodils. Entering the dim, echoing interior, Emma and her father sat several rows behind the Weston family, in the first unoccupied pew. Around them other people filled in, and Emma quietly surveyed the congregation by the light of candles and soft daylight seeping through stained-glass windows. A good-sized crowd, Emma thought, of all ages, from babbling children, to shushing mothers, to old men staring silently ahead. Some were well-dressed and others less so. The hats came off in church, but the coats remained, carrying the lingering smells of tallow, peat, and fish.

Lizzie, Emma noticed, was apparently lost in her own thoughts, for she made no effort to follow along in the prayer book. Emma recalled attending services with her father’s pupils back in Longstaple. How many times had she glanced over at an adolescent Henry Weston and noticed he was not singing, not praying, and not reciting any of the readings. Apparently now, as an adult, he did not even bother to attend.

Mr. McShane mounted the stairs to the high pulpit, welcomed them, led them through the day’s prayers and readings, then launched into a homily based on Matthew seven: Judge not, that ye be not judged.

Had Mr. McShane read her mind—her uncharitable thoughts about Henry Weston? Emma shifted uncomfortably on the hard wooden pew.

Listening, Emma soon decided Mr. McShane was gifted in making sermons. Which was good, she thought, since she was less certain of his teaching ability.

After services, everyone thanked Mr. McShane as they filed out, and then the Westons and their party returned to Ebbington Manor in the same procession as they had arrived. The mist had cleared, but the day continued grey and cloudy.

Reaching the drive in their turn, Emma took her father’s hand and he helped her down. Together they walked several steps behind the Westons as the family strolled sedately toward the house.

The sound of a cart, its tack jingling up the lane, sounded behind them. Already mounting the stairs, Lady Weston turned. Sir Giles, his hearing perhaps not all it should be, turned to see what had caught his wife’s attention.

The same donkey cart that had first delivered the Smallwoods to Ebbington Manor now rolled up the drive. Emma’s heart gave a little leap. For there on the back sat Phillip Weston—the one Weston she had looked forward to seeing. Pleasure and nerves quivered through her, and her stomach tightened. She hoped he would be happy to see her.

Phillip smiled and waved at them. At her? Did he even know they were there?

Sir Giles trotted back down the stairs in a spurt of youthful vigor. “Phillip! What in the world? We were not expecting you.”

Phillip hopped off the back of the cart. “Hello, Father.” He extended his hand, but Sir Giles pulled him into an embrace and soundly thumped his back.

Lady Weston descended the stairs more slowly, her expression inquisitive.

Phillip removed his hat. “Hello, Mother.”

Emma wondered if Henry also addressed his stepmother as such. She had yet to hear him do so.

Lady Weston offered her hand, and Phillip pressed it briefly. She asked, “Has Balliol burned down, or have they called a special recess?”

“Neither. But I heard that Mr. and Miss Smallwood had come, and I could not wait to see my dear old friends.” He walked over and shook hands with John Smallwood. “What a pleasure to see you again, sir.”

“Phillip.” Her father beamed. “How well you look.”

“Thank you, sir.” Phillip turned to Emma, a smile dimpling his cheeks, eyes shining. “And Miss Smallwood. As lovely as ever. How are you, old girl?”

Emma bit back a retort at the word old. She was, after all, only a year older than he was. “I am well, Mr. Weston. Thank you.”

Phillip’s brows rose. “Mr. Weston? Now, now. We are old friends, are we not? You must call me Phillip, as always.”

Emma glanced at Lady Weston but made no reply. She only smiled at Phillip, feeling her mood brighten. Seeing him on that grey Sunday was like seeing the first crocus poke its cheery face from the dregs of winter snow. His warm greeting a welcoming fire after Lady Weston’s chilly reception.

Julian and Rowan came forward and shook hands with their brother. Behind them, Lizzie hung back, waiting her turn.

“Hello.” Lizzie greeted Phillip almost shyly, followed by an awkward curtsy.

Apparently Lady Weston’s presence could dampen even Lizzie’s exuberant spirits. Emma certainly empathized, feeling self-conscious whenever the woman was near.

“Hello, Lizzie,” Phillip replied, his reserve matching hers.

Emma studied him. In many ways, Phillip looked much the way she remembered. Mischievous blue eyes. Broad smile—his thin upper lip in such contrast to his full lower one. Yet his shoulders were broader than she recalled, and he was taller as well, a few inches taller than she. His brown hair seemed a shade darker, his face a bit rounder—she supposed with all his sitting and studying he had gained a stone. A few lines crinkled the corner of each eye and crossed his forehead. He seemed too young for such creases. Were they new smile lines or evidence of worry or fatigue? She wondered if he found university difficult. Of the two, he had certainly struggled more with schoolwork than had Henry.

“How go the studies?” her father asked. “What have you decided to take up?”

Phillip grimaced. “I am reading law but confess I find it frightfully dull. I think a visit home is just what I need at present.”

Lady Weston asked, “But will that not put you behind in your studies when you return?”

Phillip shrugged, apparently unconcerned. “Not insurmountably.”

Henry Weston jogged down the stairs, a grin playing at the corner of his mouth. “Phillip! So you were the cause of all the commotion I heard.”

“Hello, Henry.” The two brothers shook hands. “Thank you for your letter.”

“I thought you should know.”

Lady Weston’s brows rose. “Know what?”

The brothers’ eyes met, and then once again Phillip beamed at Emma. “Why, that the Smallwoods had graced us with their presence, of course.”

Lady Weston glanced at Emma, then Henry, before smiling stiffly. “Is that so?”

The woman didn’t seem convinced, Emma noticed, and she wondered if Henry had written to Phillip for some other reason.

Sir Giles bustled forward. “Well, come in, my boy. Come in. You must be tired from your journey.” He paid the driver and gestured everyone inside.

In the hall, Lady Weston inserted herself between Phillip and Emma. “His family has first claim on him, Miss Smallwood. You understand.” She took his arm and escorted him into the drawing room.

Phillip sent her an apologetic smile over his shoulder. As the doors closed, he mouthed, “See you later.”

And Emma found a small pocket of happiness in Cornwall.





In the dining room that evening, Henry noticed Phillip survey the candlelit table, from his father at the head, he and Phillip on either side of him, to his stepmother at the distant foot, her sons and Lizzie clustered around her, and all the empty chairs in between.

“Where are the Smallwoods taking their meals?” he asked.

“With Mr. Davies,” Lady Weston replied, and added, “As befits their station.”

Phillip frowned. “But we all ate together at the Smallwood Academy. This seems so dashed formal. So cold. If they take their meals separately, and are busy in the schoolroom all day, I shall hardly see them.”

Lady Weston lifted her wine glass. Light from the candle chandelier glinted off her jeweled necklace and a ruby ring that had been his mother’s. “Mr. Smallwood is hardly locked in the schoolroom all day. It seems to me he spends more time taking the air or playing backgammon with Henry than teaching the boys.” She eyed Sir Giles pointedly. “Really, my dear, what are we paying him for?”

“I have never cared for brisk walks,” Sir Giles confessed. “But Mr. Smallwood says he finds them invigorating to body and mind. So I cannot begrudge him his daily exercise.”

Phillip persisted. “Why do we not ask them to join us?”

Lizzie’s face brightened. “Oh yes. Let’s do. I find Miss Smallwood quite diverting.”

Lady Weston shot her a glare. “They do perfectly well with Mr. Davies.”

With a glance at his stepmother, Phillip changed tack. “Might they not at least take breakfast with us? Surely we need stand on no formalities in the breakfast room. They would not disturb any order of precedence there.”

“Would disturb me,” Rowan muttered. “Trapped with that man enough as it is.”

Sir Giles did not acknowledge the remark, though he no doubt heard it. Henry was disappointed his father did not reprimand Rowan. He would never have gotten away with such disrespect at that age.

Instead, Sir Giles gently addressed his wife, “You know, my dear. As you take breakfast in your rooms most mornings, I hardly think it would inconvenience you.”

“It is not about convenience,” she snapped. “It is about propriety.”

Their father gave Phillip an empathetic look, then said more firmly, “I would enjoy Mr. Smallwood’s company and would use that time to keep abreast of our sons’ progress.”

Henry silently agreed, often wishing his father took a more active role in the boys’ upbringing.

Phillip nodded. “Excellent notion, Father.”

Lady Weston slanted Phillip a shrewd look. “And how would you use that time?”

“Very much the same way, I imagine. To renew my acquaintance with my old tutor, and Miss Smallwood as well.”

Her eyes glinted. “I do hope you don’t plan to flirt with her or raise her hopes, Phillip. You know she is not your equal. You and Henry are destined to marry fine, accomplished young ladies with good connections.”

Phillip’s lip curled. “And a shipload of money, I suppose? No pressure there.”

Lady Weston smiled, unconcerned. “Family and breeding are of upmost importance, of course. And, fortunately, they are often accompanied by a generous dowry.”

Phillip’s eyes flashed and his jaw tensed—quite unlike his normal, easygoing demeanor.

Henry spoke up quickly. “I am sure Phillip has no improper intentions toward Miss Smallwood, Lady Weston. The two are of an age and were friends in their younger days. I am certain that is all it is.”

Was he certain? No. But seeing the mounting annoyance on his brother’s face, Henry thought it wise to defuse the tense conversation.

“I certainly hope that is all it is,” Lady Weston said with an edge of warning in her cultured voice. She signaled the footman to remove the cover of the silver soup tureen, beginning the meal and ending the discussion.

After dinner, Lady Weston and Lizzie withdrew, urging Rowan and Julian to accompany them into the drawing room for a game of whist.

Henry remained where he was, idly rolling his table napkin and keeping his father and Phillip company as the two sipped port. He studied his brother closely and noticed his distracted look. “Phillip, why have you come home . . . really?”

Phillip stared back silently, downturned mouth lacking its usual smile.

Their father’s bushy brows lowered. “What are you driving at, Henry? Phillip has told us why he’s come. He was eager to see the Smallwoods again.”

Henry’s gaze remained on his brother. “So he said.”

Sir Giles added, “Did you not write to him yourself to inform him they had come?”

“Yes, among other news I thought he should know. But I did not expect him to leave Oxford midterm. You gained permission from the dean, I trust?”

“My goodness, Henry,” Phillip said dryly. “I have no need of two fathers, I assure you.”

“Why do you doubt his word?” Sir Giles asked. “Phillip has always been fond of the Smallwoods.”

“Far more so than you ever were,” Phillip added, boldly holding his gaze.

Henry looked away first. “I don’t doubt Phillip’s affection for the Smallwoods. Or his curiosity about our other news. But I do doubt that those are the only reasons he is here. The Easter term ends on—what?—May twenty-fourth? Surely this little social visit—if that’s what it is—might have waited.”

Phillip made no answer.

Henry felt frustration rising. “Tell me you have not come to grief at Oxford. It was bad enough when Julian and Rowan were expelled from Blundell’s.”

“Julian was mistreated there,” Sir Giles said. “That is why the boys came home.”

Henry shook his head. “That is not what the headmaster wrote in his letter.”

Sir Giles brushed his words away with a wave of his hand. “At all events, Lady Weston could not abide them being so far away from her.”

“Tiverton is not so far.”

“A good fifty miles.”

“About the same distance as Smallwood’s,” Phillip spoke up. “I still don’t know why you did not send the boys there.”

“It was Lady Weston’s preference,” Sir Giles explained. “Strong preference, I might add.”

Phillip asked, “What were the boys accused of doing?”

“Accusations are all it was,” Sir Giles insisted. “Julian said Rowan was only trying to protect him.”

“A fight, was it?” Phillip asked.

“Not . . . exactly,” Sir Giles hedged.

Henry wished his father would not try to cover for the boys’ behavior. But sensing his discomfort, Henry returned the conversation to Phillip. “How long will you be staying?”

“Have I overstayed my welcome already?” Phillip’s eyes glinted, belying his grin. “I was under the impression this was my home as well.”

“Of course it is, of course it is.” Sir Giles patted his knee. “Henry didn’t mean to imply otherwise.”

Henry ran a hand through his hair. “But you do plan to return and finish out the term?”

Phillip shrugged. “I don’t know. What I really want is a good long respite.”

“Not now, Phillip,” Henry said, trying to moderate the disapproval ringing in his voice. “Finish this term and the next, and then you shall have most of July through September for your respite.”

Ignoring Henry’s counsel, Phillip said to Sir Giles, “I’ve been thinking, Father. Perhaps it is time we consider my grand tour.”

“Your grand tour?” Henry’s voice rose. “When I have yet to have mine?”

“That isn’t my fault, is it? I want to live life, Father, not merely learn about it in the dusty, hallowed halls of your alma mater.”

Their father’s jaw tensed. “I always meant for you to have your tour after you earned your degree. That is the way these things are done, my boy—as well you know.”

“But I think travel would give me the inspiration I need to return and finish strong.”

Sir Giles shook his head. “I don’t know, Phillip. This isn’t a good time.”

“Why? Do you mean because of him? Or because of the Smallwoods?”

Sir Giles looked at Henry, then replied, “Both.”

“Personally, I think either is beside the point,” Henry said. “You need to earn your degree, Phillip. Westons don’t quit; we finish what we start. Have you not always said so, Father?”

“Have I?” Sir Giles looked troubled.

Henry nodded and said quietly, “You used to say it, when we were boys.”

Sir Giles nodded vaguely.

Did his father not remember? He had certainly changed since he and Phillip were young.

Henry asked, “What does your Oxford tutor have to say about all this?”

“He will clear things with the dean, I know, if I ask him.”

“Are you telling us you’ve come home without informing your dean?”

Phillip threw up his hands. “It was a spur-of-the-moment decision. But now that I’m here, I cannot stomach the thought of returning.”

Sir Giles challenged, “Is all the money I’ve spent on your education to be wasted?”

“No,” Phillip insisted, yet sullenly refused to look his father in the eye.

“Need I remind you, Phillip, that you are not my eldest and heir? I will make what accommodation for you I can, but you will need a profession.”

“No, you needn’t remind me, Father.”

Over Phillip’s bent head, Henry and his father shared bewildered looks.

Sir Giles sighed and heaved himself to his feet. “Let us speak no more of this tonight. We are all of us tired and frustrated. And I fear further arguing will only lead to words we might regret. Let us leave it for now. I shall write to your tutor and explain.”

Henry erupted. “You ought not lie for him, Father.”

“I don’t intend to lie, Henry. I shall tell him the truth. That there are family troubles here at home and Phillip is needed.”

“Family troubles?” Phillip echoed dubiously.

“That is true enough. And, now I think of it, Phillip may help you in our search. Perhaps he might have more success than you have.”

Phillip looked worriedly at Henry. “I . . . I am happy to help, of course. But Henry is the best man for the job.”

“That has yet to be proven.”

Henry was about to protest when lightning flashed outside the window, followed by the rumble of thunder. He glanced at his father but saw no concern or even awareness there. With an inward sigh, Henry rose and quickly excused himself.





An unlesson’d girl, unschool’d, unpractised;

Happy in this, she is not yet so old

But she may learn.

—William Shakespeare, The Merchant of Venice