“I don’t know what that means,” I reply.
She doesn’t answer me, though. Kit just stares up at the sky and lets the snow bathe her face with its infinite variation.
I pull out my phone. Text my mother. One word and a question mark: Why?
She writes back immediately.
Mom: Let’s do this in person.
Me: No. Just tell me. Simple question.
Mom: It’s complicated.
Me: Try me.
Mom: You won’t understand.
Me: Never mind.
Mom: I was lonely. And stupid. But mostly lonely.
—
“I texted and asked and my mom says she was lonely,” I say to David, ignoring the absurdity of the whole situation. Me sharing the intimate details of my family life with him of all people. That we are sitting here in McCormick’s, eating hamburgers in a purple vinyl booth, like an almost-date. That he looks like an ad from a magazine for boxer briefs and I’m dressed again in my dad’s shirt, making the same mistake twice. That I’ve listened to David in the first place and broken my silence with my mother and texted at his casual suggestion. That we keep talking about this concept of open loops, like everything can be fixed if we just put our collective brain power into it.
He smiles, like this is good news.
“That makes sense,” he says.
“No, it doesn’t,” I say. “Nothing makes sense.”
“It’s sad to think about, though,” he says, as though he didn’t hear me. “Being married and still being lonely.”
“She’s just making excuses for herself.”
“Have you ever heard of twin prime numbers?” David asks. I see him revving up to a new topic, and I can’t decide if I want to go down this road with him. My mind feels mushy and overused. Maybe this wasn’t a good idea. Skipping class, taking this long walk in the snow. I liked holding David’s hand, though. That part—the snow dampening my face, letting my tears mix without anyone seeing, his fingers snug in mine—that was nice. His hand was heavier than I would have guessed. More solid. Like he could keep me from flying away.
“Nope,” I say. I take a bite of hamburger, think about Annie’s obsession with the concept of mindfulness. She’s always telling me it’s important to be in the here and now. To taste your food. To feel your breathing. To notice when you go from sitting to standing. Since her parents’ divorce, her mother has gone total hippie. She takes Annie on meditation and yoga retreats and burns incense in the house to get rid of bad energy, and whenever I go over there, she tells me all about her adrenal fatigue, as if those are words I understand put together.
Of course that stuff has trickled down to Annie and then out to me and Violet. And so I decide to be here, in the now, whatever that means. I taste my burger; I really taste it. It’s over-ketchuped and too pickle-y. The here and now is overrated.
I let David fill our table up with conversation, his words like cartoon bubbles taking up the space I can’t seem to fill. Which is a long way of saying if he wants to talk prime numbers, so be it.
“Twin primes are prime numbers that differ from each other by two. Like three and five. Or forty-one and forty-three. But what’s cool about them is that they still exist even as you go higher and higher. Even though, as everyone knows, the gap between primes grows the higher the numbers.”
“Of course everyone knows that,” I say.
“Right, so it’s this strange, wonderful phenomenon.”
What does that mean, I was lonely and stupid? My mother is the smartest person I know. And I say that while I’m sitting across the table from David Drucker, who scored the highest on his PSATs of anyone in the tri-state area. Though my mother rarely lets her nerd flag fly, when she does, her brain is a phenomenal thing. I wonder if that’s why Jack liked her. Wait, was it like? Or was it love? Did Jack love her? Does he love her? Are they going to get married and Evan and Alex will become my stepbrothers, and we’ll go on family vacations all together again, and we’ll pretend that it’s not weird we’ve found ourselves in this new, previously unfathomable combination? Will we pretend that my dad never existed in the first place?
“I’m not sure what prime numbers have to do with anything,” I say in a gentle voice.
“Prime numbers have to do with everything. But to clarify, that’s what I imagine falling in love is like and then staying married. You start out as low twin primes and as time goes on, if you manage to defy the statistical odds and not get divorced, you become like those rarer twin primes, still only separated by two. That’s an amazing feat.”
“How romantic,” I say sarcastically, because to me the idea of falling in love, admittedly something I’ve never had the pleasure of experiencing, has nothing to do with prime numbers or mathematics or even quantum mechanics. It’s more like music or art or poetry. Something awe-inspiring and beautiful. Maybe even surprising, like how I used to see my parents’ relationship.
“It actually is. Super-romantic.” David looks down and fiddles with his straw. I think he’s blushing, which makes me blush, even though I have no idea what he’s talking about. Of course, when a good-looking guy uses the word romantic in all seriousness and blushes, whatever the context, even if you are talking about prime numbers, you’re going to blush too. It’s reflexive. It doesn’t mean anything. “I just thought, like, maybe your parents were, um, prime numbers that were drifting apart, and that’s why your mom felt lonely. Because her twin was too far away.”
“Maybe,” I say, not able to share his sympathetic views. I don’t think my mother was lonely. She was just selfish. Or even worse: horny. Ew. I am seriously feeling ill.
“Is that why you were crying? Because of your mom and dad?” David asks. I haven’t quite gotten used to this about him. As if the only way to go is straight through.
And, of course, there’s the flip side to David’s directness. I don’t really want to talk about my crying.
“It’s just…a lot of things.”
“You look beautiful even when you cry. I mean, not that you don’t look beautiful when you’re happy. Of course you’re beautiful all the time. But out there in the snow, you were stunning.” My stomach tightens and I let out a little laugh. No, more like a gasp. What are you supposed to say when a guy says you are beautiful? This has never once come up. My body warms and buzzes with his words.
My mind is racing. McCormick’s is a good place. They sell milk shakes and have a little sign discouraging you from talking on your cell phone. I like sitting here with David, basking in his undeserved compliments.
“Thanks,” I say finally, after what feels like a long time in which I’ve been trying to think of what to say next. “Thanks for that.”
“You’re welcome.” He jumps up, reaches out for my hand, and I let him take it. “Now let’s go check out the place your dad died and close that loop.”