WHEN I GO to bed, I never want to get up. There’s an ache deep in my bones that won’t go away; I jolt awake in the night sobbing in pain. Nothing will ever get better. It will only get worse. I pull the blue wool blanket Papa made tighter around me and finally drift to sleep. When I wake several hours later in the astringent light of morning, I bury my face in my pillow.
Al comes into my room. I can hear him, see him, though my eyes are shut and I pretend to be asleep. “Christina,” he says softly.
I don’t answer.
“I found some bread and jam for breakfast. Sam and Fred are in the barn. I’ll bring eggs to Mother and Papa when chores are finished.”
I sigh, tacit acknowledgment that I hear him.
Behind my eyelashes I see him look down, hands on hips. “Are you sick?”
“Yes.”
“Do you need a doctor?”
“No.” I open my eyes, but I can’t rouse myself to an expression. He looks back at me steadily. I don’t remember ever holding his gaze like this.
“I would like to kill him,” he says. “I really would.”
My bed feels like a shallow grave.
I TAKE THE stack of letters from Walton, tied with their pale pink ribbon, and place them in a box. Part of me wants to set them on fire and watch them burn. But I can’t bring myself to do it.
At the top of the first flight of stairs is a small closet door on the side wall. When no one is around, I slide the box into a dark corner of the closet. I don’t want to see his letters. I just want proof that they exist.
IN TOWN NOBODY says a word about it, at least not to me. But I see the pity in their eyes. I hear the whispers: She was abandoned, you know. Their sympathy fills me with a shame so deep that I can understand why someone might sail off to a distant land, never to return to where he’s from.
GETTING READY FOR a late afternoon sail with my brothers on a warm June day, I tuck the shell Walton gave me into my pocket. On the sloop I stroke it with my fingers, probing its rough crevices and silky exterior. It’s the perfect weight and shape to nestle in my palm. Toward the end of the trip, as the sun dips in the sky, I move to the back of the small sailboat and sit alone, peering down at the scalloped water. How easy it would be to slip over the side and sink to the bottom of the ocean. Blackness, only blackness, and merciful unconsciousness. I taste the tears running down my face, salty sweet in my mouth. Before long, no doubt, my brothers will marry, my parents will weaken and die, and I will be alone in the house on the hill, with nothing to look forward to but the slow change of seasons, my own aging and infirmity, the house turning to dust.
Walton and I sat together at the back of the boat just like this. I adore you, he whispered in my ear. How devoted he was; he couldn’t get enough of me, loved only me. Only me. His solid shoulder against mine, his long finger pointing toward the sky, the constellations, all the names I learned so eagerly: Orion the Hunter, Cassiopeia, Hercules, Pegasus. I look up now at the darkening sky, as solid as slate. The stars are washed away, present only in memory.
Closing my eyes, I lean over the side, the salt spray on my face mingling with tears. I weigh the shell in my palm—this cameo shell that has no place with the others. A store-bought trinket with no history, no story. I knew, deep down, when he gave it to me that he didn’t understand anything about me. Why didn’t I recognize it as a warning?
I feel a hand on my arm and open my eyes. “Nice night, isn’t it,” Al says mildly. “Careful back here. It’s slippery.”
“I’m all right.”
He tightens his grip on my arm. “Come sit with me.”
“In a minute.”
“Did anyone ever tell you you’re as stubborn as a mule?”
I laugh a little. “Once or twice.”
We gaze out into the dusk. On the shore, faint lights glow in the windows of a faraway house. Our house. “I’ll stay here with you, then,” he says.
“You don’t need to do that, Al.”
“Wouldn’t want anything to happen. Couldn’t forgive myself if it did.”
The weight of sorrow presses on my chest. I grip the shell, feeling its blunt knobs. Then I let it slip from my fingers. It makes a small splash.
“What was that?”
“Nothing important.”
The shell sinks quickly. I’ll never have to look at it again, or hold it in my hand.
WHAT PROMISES I MAKE
1946
Hel-loo? Christina?” A woman’s artificially high voice comes through the screen.
“In here,” I say. “Who is it?”
The woman pulls open the door and steps into the kitchen like she’s stepping onto a sinking ship. She’s of indeterminate middle age, wearing a worsted wool suit and stockings and pumps and carrying a casserole. “I’m Violet Evans. From the Cushing Baptist Church? We have a hospitality club, and—well—we’ve put you on our list for a stop-in visit once a week.”
My back stiffens. “I don’t know about any list.”
She smiles with aggrieved patience. “Well, there is one.”
“What for?”
“Shut-ins, mostly.”
“I’m not a shut-in.”
“Umm-hmm,” she says, glancing around. She holds up the dish. “Well. I brought you chipped beef and noodles.” She squints into the gloom. It’s late afternoon, and I haven’t lit a lamp yet. Until she came inside, I hadn’t really noticed how dark it is in here. “Maybe we could switch on a light?”
“No electricity. I’ll find a lamp if you’ll wait a moment.”
“Oh—don’t go to any bother for me. I won’t stay long.” She steps gingerly across the floor and sets the casserole on top of the range. “I spilled a little on my skirt, I’m afraid. Can you point me toward your sink?”
Reluctantly I direct her to the pantry. I know what’s coming.
“Why, this is—a pump!” she says with a little surprised laugh, just as I knew she would. “My heavens, you don’t have indoor plumbing?”
Obviously we don’t. “We’ve always managed fine without it.”
“Well,” she says again. She stands in the middle of the floor like a deer poised to bolt. “I hope you and your brother like chipped beef.”
“I’m sure he’ll eat it.”