When We Were Enemies: A Novel

Perched on the edge of her velvet settee, I sat there in my mother’s penthouse, considering who my grandfather might be. I’d pondered Antonio Trombello often and wondered if my grandmother had somehow fallen for the same kind of forbidden fruit that I’d been tempted with.

With the cameras rolling, my mother did her best “loving mother” impression, even though we hadn’t spoken in four weeks. Chris and Lawrence were there too. Chris had refused to be in the same room with my mom for years but was suddenly desperate to be by her side. Jim was still on location, so he couldn’t attend the big moment, but he also didn’t need the publicity as much as my other brothers. One boy on each side, holding their mother’s shoulders for support. And me by myself, spinning the ring on my right hand, counting the seconds till we finally knew the truth.

Using a fancy golden letter opener, my mother opened the sealed envelope in one swoosh. The DNA had been provided from the Highward family, which was just about all my long-lost New York cousin who had no idea of our familial connection until our visit was able to supply. All the samples were processed in a prestigious facility, and it was finally the moment of truth. She took her own sweet time sliding out the paper and unfolding it dramatically.

“He’s my dad,” she said, teary-eyed. But it wasn’t clear whom she was speaking about, so Mac made her try again.

“Tom Highward is my dad.” We all reacted again with hugs and relief, yes even me. As far as we know, this great scandal was nothing more than my sweet grandmother covering for her deadbeat, AWOL husband. The Highwards seemed to know even less than we do about Tom, contributing only a few pictures from his childhood and stories told by his sister, Moira Highward, before she passed. Some “bombshell” that turned out to be.

On our way out of the boardroom, Monique gasps and points to my right hand like she’s a kid at Disneyland who has spotted Mickey Mouse.

“Is that the ring? The one your grandma passed down?”

The three-carat stone sparkles up at me. Even with its pristine luster, it’s easy to forget about since I rarely take it off.

“It is,” I say, covering the antique piece of jewelry with my bare left hand.

“I love that you wear it even after . . . everything. Boss move,” Monique says.

“Thanks,” I say, feeling nothing like a “boss”—not in the way Monique means it at least. People read far too deeply into the ring. Some people say I wear it for revenge; others say I wear it because I can’t let go—that I’m not over Hunter or even Dean. Of course, it has to be all about a guy.

What the internet gossips fail to understand is that I left Hunter after the shady stuff with the documentary, not the other way around. The more popular narrative is that Hunter dumped my ass after the story broke about the priest scandal, but there’s little need for a public correction. Mac could’ve cleared it up easily if he’d included the entirety of the hidden camera confrontation, but instead, it ended up on the proverbial cutting-room floor.

The story went away quickly, flaring up only briefly when Bombshell went through its publicity cycle and again when awards season hit. But none of it hurt Hunter’s image; in fact, it seems to have been a net positive. He married a wealthy entrepreneur/reality show star within a year of our breakup. From what I hear, they have a baby on the way.

I knew I was over him when I could see a picture of the pair in my newsfeed and not unfollow that particular media outlet. I don’t believe Hunter did what he did because he wasn’t in love with me. I think it was more likely because his view of love was so altered by his upbringing that he didn’t know how to have a real relationship outside of the media spotlight. And it turned out that I wasn’t interested in that kind of relationship.

My marriage to Dean may have worked—we were young enough and naive enough to give ourselves over to love wholeheartedly. But who knows? Maybe that was a broken heart waiting to happen too. In a way, I’m glad I’ll never know.

“I’m not even kissing up to try and get a job. It’s the truth—you guys deserved those Emmys.” Monique continues with her compliments, and though I know she means well, it’s getting a bit awkward. “And Mac Dorman’s acceptance speech? I see clips on TikTok all the time.”

“Well, thanks, Monique,” I say, smiling at her reference to all the things I’ve actively avoided. “You should hear from us soon. Oscar will show you out,” I add quickly, ready to escape.

Mom and Mac had broken up by awards season, and she attended with my thirteen-year-old niece, Nora, keeping the fame cycle running for another generation. Nonna passed a lot down to us—Variety says it’s her smile, but that’s one minor part of our inheritance. She worked tirelessly for her place on the screen, and it pulled her and her family out of poverty. I do wonder whether it’s fair to benefit from her fame rather than pave our own paths. It’s a hollow existence wondering every time I find success if I’d have reached it without my family’s name following my own.

I politely disengage from the conversation, and Monique eventually departs. RROCK is my domain now, and I want to be immersed in it. As Oscar and Ciara walk Monique out and greet our next candidate, I return to my spot and think of Nora at the Emmys all dolled up in a gown and fake lashes. I’ll see if Jim will let her spend part of her summer with me working in the community kitchen, maybe taking a trip to my dad’s ranch. I’m not pretending to know what’s right for my brother’s kid, but I know what helped my soul, and very little of it had to do with red carpets or flashing lights. If I’d remembered that a little sooner, I would’ve walked away from Bombshell before all the damage happened. No boom mic; can lights; camera lenses; Edinburgh, Indiana; or Father Patrick.

My phone buzzes just in time to keep me from going down the well-trodden path of regret labeled “Patrick Kelly.”

OSCAR: Got our next one. Be right in.

It’s no use reliving that storyline anymore. Walking away from Patrick was different from walking away from the film or Hunter or even my mom. Patrick was innocent. He was my friend. He was real. And unlike Hunter—I still miss him.

I take out the next résumé without looking at it and place it on the table as the boardroom door opens. I hope our next applicant doesn’t know me, or if she does, she isn’t gutsy enough to bring it up. Though it’s pretty likely any candidate will do a healthy amount of research before their interview, so maybe it’s a red flag if they haven’t seen the documentary. I chuckle at the irony as everyone returns to their seats.

Oscar clears his throat and starts the meeting.

Emily Bleeker's books