“Thanks.” I take the messages. “Will you do me a favor and make some coffee?”
“I could use some myself.” Her eyes fall on Tomasetti—and stick. I know the look of feminine interest when I see it, and I’m surprised. He doesn’t exactly fall into the nice-looking category. His eyes are too intense. His mouth is thin and snarlish. His nose is slightly hooked. He’s probably not much over forty, but his face sports the lines of a man who’s lived hard and long.
What is it about young women being attracted to men old enough to be their fathers? “Mona, this is John Tomasetti with BCI out of Columbus.”
He extends his hand to Mona. “Nice to meet you.”
Her smile widens as they shake. “We’re glad to have you on board.”
Rolling my eyes, I start toward my office. Once inside, I shed my coat and flip on my computer. While it boots, I dial Glock. “Anything on Lapp?” I ask.
“Nada. Either he keeps his nose clean or he’s dead.”
“Keep digging.” I reassure myself it was an offhand comment; Glock can’t possibly know Lapp is dead. If he’s dead. “Did you guys find anything at the Augspurger farm?”
“There were some old tracks, but they were almost totally obscured by new snowfall and drifting.”
“Were you able to get impressions?”
“No impressions. No prints. Either he’s lucky or he knows all of our tricks.” He pauses. “We canvassed, but no one saw anything. This guy’s a fuckin’ ghost.”
Tomasetti enters my office holding two cups. I motion for him to sit. “Thanks for the update, Glock. Get some rest.”
“You, too.”
I disconnect. Tomasetti sets one of the cups in front of me and takes the chair adjacent to my desk. “If you’re trying to win over my undying admiration with coffee,” I say, “you just scored a few points.”
“I could make another pot.”
I give him a passable smile.
He doesn’t smile back. “They turn up anything?”
I recap my conversation with Glock.
He rubs his hands together like a man preparing for a meal. “You have time to show me what you have so far?”
“It’s not much.” I hand him the old Slaughterhouse Killer file. “This is the file from the early nineties.”
Pulling reading glasses from his breast pocket, he opens the folder. While he reads, I rise and cross to the fax machine. Sure enough, Doc Coblentz has sent the preliminary autopsy report for Ellen Augspurger. I scan the particulars as I take it to the copy room.
Death is attributed to a deep incised wound of the neck severing the carotid artery. Cause of death: exsanguination.
No photos were faxed, but I don’t need them. I see it all when I close my eyes. Her partially decomposed body hanging from the ceiling beam at the Huffman farm. The grief-ravaged faces of Bonnie and Ezra Augspurger as they try to absorb news of their daughter’s death.
I think of my own secrets and what might have happened all those years ago had I not picked up my father’s shotgun and defended myself. I could have been Ellen Augspurger or Amanda Horner, my butchered body reduced to a cold piece of evidence. Staring down at the report, I think about Daniel Lapp and I wish to God I’d shot him in the head instead of the torso.
Tomasetti looks up from the file when I return to my desk. He’s scribbled notes on a legal pad. “What’s your theory on this?” he asks.
“It’s either the killer from before, or we have a copycat on our hands.”
“This is no copycat.”
“How can you be so sure?”
“The Roman numerals carved into the torsos of the vics was never made public.” He looks at me over the tops of his glasses, his expression telling me that should be obvious.
“The information could have leaked.”
“If that was the case, you would have seen it in the news.”
He’s right, but I say nothing.
He shakes his head. “The similarities are too striking. This is the same guy.”
“How do you explain the hiatus?”
“He changed locales. Look at the gap in numbering.” He studies me with those intense eyes. “Have you plugged any of this into VICAP?”
VICAP is the acronym for the FBI’s Violent Criminal Apprehension Program. It’s a database that matches major crimes by detecting similar signature aspects and patterns of modus operandi. We both know I should have already done this. Tomasetti’s wondering why I didn’t.
“I was hoping you could help with that,” I say.
“I’ll get this signature plugged in right away.”
“I’ve got queries going in OHLEG as well,” I add.
“While we’re on the subject of resources, is there a specific reason why you didn’t contact the FBI?”
There’s no recrimination in the question. Just simple curiosity. As if I might have a good reason for not doing what I should have. Of course, I don’t. He’s backed me into a corner I can’t get out of unless I lie. “Some of the town council members were concerned about tourism. They didn’t want the national media involved.”