The Witch is Back

Chapter Four




Brooklyn? Who the heck is Brooklyn?

I stared at Asher, but he was no longer focused on me. His mouth was actually hanging open; he looked slightly in shock. I’d never seen him lose his cool before. And here it was, over another girl.

Please don’t let her be pretty . . . give her a hideous growth on her chin or an awkward limp or even blah brown hair. Anything that would make me feel better about the look that is currently on Asher’s face.

But when I turned around, I found that my pleas had fallen on deaf ears. In fact, what I saw was worse than I ever could’ve imagined.

The girl staring back at my boyfriend was stunning. Like total glamazon, Victoria’s Secret model stunning. She had this whole hot runway thing going on. We were in the same league, only on total opposite sides of the spectrum.

Where my long hair was the color of dark chocolate, this girl’s was a vibrant blonde. It hung in soft, loose waves around her face, which was equally stunning. Her skin was dewy and sun-kissed, and a perfect shade of pink streaked across her cheeks. With lips like two plump pillows completing her look, her face could’ve been plastered across billboards in Times Square.

And with my luck, it already was.

Before I could ask him about her, Asher stepped around me and crossed the room to where the girl was standing, frozen in place. They hesitated once they were within touching distance, but after a brief pause, they hugged.

It was like I was witnessing a private moment between a couple, and out of habit, I let my eyes drift quickly to the ground.

Wait a minute.

This was my boyfriend I was watching hug another girl. I didn’t have to give them privacy.

My eyes shot back up and I forced myself to take in every gut-wrenching detail of their embrace. Because that’s what it was like for me to see Asher touching someone else. It was painful. It didn’t matter that I had no idea who the girl was or that I knew in my heart that Asher loved me. The fact was, this horrible, soul-sucking sickness had begun in my stomach, and I had no idea how to deal with it.


But, just like that, the hug was over, and they were once again standing a safe distance from each other. Of course, it still seemed too close for comfort for me.

“What are you doing here?” Asher asked incredulously.

“This is my second summer at Brighton,” Brooklyn said, showing her perfect pearly whites as she smiled. “What are you doing here?”

“My aunt and uncle thought Abby and I should come,” he said.

I noticed that he didn’t mention me or the rest of the Cleri.

“So you did go to stay with your aunt,” she said, slowly. “I’d heard that, but . . . well, I wasn’t sure.”

“Oh, yeah,” Asher said, looking down at the ground and running his fingers through his hair. He did that when he was nervous . . . and when he was flirting. I couldn’t tell which it was in this particular moment, but I didn’t like it.

“Who is this girl?” I asked myself quietly.

“Brooklyn,” a voice answered from beside me. I started slightly before turning to see Abby standing there, a book in hand, but closed down by her side. “She’s Asher’s ex-girlfriend.”

My heart dropped and hit the bottom of my stomach with an awful thud. Nausea crept up my throat before I could realize it was happening and I scanned the room for a bathroom to no avail. So I just stood there instead, frozen in disbelief.

“His . . . ex-girlfriend?” I asked, eyes wide. Then, almost to myself, I said, “I didn’t even know there was an ex. And she’s what . . . a supermodel?”

“Not a model. Just a witch,” Abby said as we watched Asher and Brooklyn’s reunion   from afar.

This was unbelievable. Sure, I guess in the back of my mind I’d known that Asher had to have had a past. I mean—look at him. He’s hot. But the subject of exes had never come up, so I thought he was like me, and hadn’t really had any relationships before ours that were significant enough to merit the term “ex.” And even if he had, who wanted to think of her boyfriend as having a love life before theirs? Not me. I wanted to be the only one special enough to have been with Asher like that.

Unfortunately, I could no longer convince myself that I was his one and only, because the proof was currently standing in front of me, all leggy and blond. And she was impossible to ignore.

“You just disappeared, Asher,” Brooklyn said. It was almost a whisper and I found myself straining to hear their conversation.

“Look, Brooklyn, I can explain . . .”

But before he could finish, Brooklyn’s gaze swept our way and her face changed instantly.

“Abby!” she shouted and ran in our direction.

“Oh, here we go,” Abby muttered under her breath, but then abruptly shut her mouth, as if she hadn’t meant to say it out loud.

I barely had time to raise an eyebrow at her comment before the eight-foot-tall stunner pranced her way over to us as easily as a ballerina crossing a stage. If I hadn’t already disliked her, I might’ve been impressed that she’d managed to do this in five-inch heels. Christian Siriano to be specific. And with a curved heel and additional panel under the toe, this was an incredible feat.

Of course, this only succeeded in annoying me further.

Despite her lack of enthusiasm, I noticed with jealousy that Abby wasn’t recoiling from their embrace out of solidarity with me. In fact, she even dropped her book during the exchange, which fell with a clunk on top of the wooden coffee table. As the pages fluttered closed, I read the title: The Inferno, by Dante.

Talk about light summer reading.

“I’ve missed you so much, Ab!” Brooklyn said, squeezing the smaller girl in her slender arms. When she pulled away, she gave Abby the once-over while still holding her hands. “What have you been up to?”

“Oh, you know . . . reading,” Abby answered in her signature monotone voice. She gestured to the novel that was now lying on the table below them.

“Sounds about right,” Brooklyn said, laughing easily. “Anything else? It’s been a while you know . . .”

“It has,” Abby mumbled.

“Whatever you’ve been up to, I’d love to hear it!” Brooklyn said quickly. “We have so much to catch up on.” Then she looked over at Asher who had wandered back over to us while the two were talking. He seemed to have recovered from his initial shock and was back to his usual self. Only, despite his laid-back demeanor, I could tell something was up. “All of us should catch up,” she concluded.

That’s it. Time to step in.

I cleared my throat and sidled up to Asher, placing my hand in his territorially and kissing him lightly on the cheek. “Hey, babe! Making friends already?”

Brooklyn seemed to notice me for the first time, and then I watched as she went through the same flood of emotions that I had a few minutes before. The smile remained on her lips but her eyes gave her away. They went from friendly to murderous in point two seconds, and I knew instantly that there was going to be trouble.

“Um, right. Hadley, this is Brooklyn. Brooklyn, this is my girlfriend, Hadley.” At least when he said it, he didn’t sound uncomfortable. And he’d remembered to actually identify me as his girlfriend and not just, “This is Hadley.” In fact, he was making the introduction the same way he would to anyone else we might be meeting at camp. It made me wonder if I was making too big a deal over this whole ex thing. Maybe they were totally over each other.

Then I thought back to the moment they’d hugged and all my defenses shot back up.

“Hi!” I said, more brightly than I’d intended, but wanting to convey that I didn’t think she was a threat. I still wasn’t sure if this was true, but no need for her to know that I was rattled by her appearance.

I didn’t put my hand out to shake hers and neither did she. We were in a mental standoff and, considering the way she was staring at Asher and my entwined hands, I decided I was in the better position.

“Brooke!” a brunette shouted from across the room.

I took my eyes off of Brooklyn to see this other girl who was flanked by three others, all of whom were standing with their hands on their hips. The girl who’d called out to Brooklyn had short hair that was cut in a sharp, artsy bob, with bangs that just grazed the tops of her eyebrows. “You coming? There won’t be any good tanning light left if we don’t get out there soon.”

“Be there in a minute, Eve!” she yelled back, without letting her eyes drift from us. “Well, my friends are waiting for me. Let’s catch up later?”

She was looking straight at Asher as she said this. Then she turned abruptly and strutted off, leaving everyone in the room staring after her as she went. Including myself.

“She’s a cheery one, isn’t she?” I said, unable to keep the sarcasm out of my voice. Then I turned back to Asher. “Old friends?”

True, I already knew the answer, but I wanted to hear it from him. Would he admit how he knew her? Try to downplay their involvement? Given his track record of lying to me in the past, I couldn’t help but wonder how easy it would be for him to fall back into it. Guys held back on telling the truth all the time, mostly to avoid an uncomfortable conversation with the girls questioning them. Asher wasn’t like other guys, but it was still possible this was just a part of his male DNA, and he wouldn’t be able to help himself.

“We used to date,” Asher said simply.


I stared at him, unable to decide if I was happy that he’d told me the truth or upset that he didn’t feel guiltier over having obviously just shared a moment with his ex. With me standing right there. So, I didn’t say anything.

Abby looked from me to Asher and then back to me. “Well, that wasn’t awkward at all,” she said, breaking up the moment. Bending down to retrieve her book, she began to back away slowly. “I’m just going to . . . go find our room.”

She’d only made it a few steps before I told her to wait up. Then I gave Asher the only smile I could muster before turning and walking away.



“Hello?” I called into the room with a big 3C on the door. It was the number we’d been assigned, but when we’d arrived in front of it, the door was cracked open about an inch and I could hear shuffling inside. And I didn’t want to just barge in if our new roommate was changing or something so I made our presence known.

“It’s open!” a voice called out from behind the door.

I looked at Abby, who simply shrugged before leading the way inside.

Nothing could’ve prepared me for what I saw on the other side of the door. As soon as my eyes settled on the scene in front of me, I gasped and dropped my iced coffee onto the ground, the liquid splashing all over my legs and shoes.