Chapter Eight
Sarah flicked the reins over the gelding’s back and waved to Lettie, who had come to see her off from the stable yard. The manse vehicle was a strange-looking contraption commissioned by the First Presbyterian Church and constructed by the village blacksmith into a combination wagon and enclosed carriage. The name FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF WILLOW GROVE, SOUTH CAROLINA on the doors protected it from the likelihood of being searched, the reason Sarah had selected it as the perfect conveyance for spiriting a runaway slave to the port in Charleston under the very eyes of the slave-catchers. Even the most brazen would not stop a white woman on the road who was about the church’s business, and Sarah was becoming recognizable in the area as the replacement for the much-loved and popular Lettie Sedgewick, a cover that offered further protection for her activities.
“Can I take the kerchief off now, miss?”
“Yes, but you’ll have to stay hidden until we get to our destination. The bounty hunters are about.”
Sarah spoke to a Negro man scrunched under the carriage seat. The “kerchief” he removed was a square of black fabric to hide his teeth and the whites of his eyes should anyone have cause to peer into the dark cab. She did not know his name, or he hers. She did not know the name of the plantation from which he had escaped. He had spent the night hidden in the barn with instructions to climb into the carriage after the Reverend Sedgewick, Lettie’s father, had harnessed the horse to the vehicle and left. It was Wednesday morning, not the best day of the week to effect a slave’s escape, but in the relaxed atmosphere of the day before Thanksgiving, vigilance over plantation owners’ property was lax. Most escapes were arranged for Saturday night. Many masters did not make their slaves work on Sundays, and the runaway would not be missed until Monday morning when he would have had a day and a half’s head start to his destination. Notices of the slave’s escape and his description would not be published in the newspapers until the next week, by which time the fugitive might be in a safe house closer to his freedom in the North.
Not until the carriage was well on its way did Sarah breathe easier and her heartbeat slow. So far, so good. Many things—tiny, cruel, unanticipated caprices of fate—could wreck the best-arranged plans and lead to her discovery. It was a fear like a chronic ache in her stomach. Today, if things went wrong at the dock and her “cargo” was captured, it would be only a matter of time before he broke under the lash and told the authorities what they wanted to know. The trail would lead back to her. She would be deported to the North, if not subjected to worse, but at least she could betray no one in the escape system. She did not know the name of the agent who, under cover of darkness, had arranged to have the runaway deposited in the Sedgewicks’ barn last night. She could not tell the authorities the location of the place where he had hidden before then or the route he’d taken. The success of the Underground Railroad depended on concealment of the identities of those involved. If discovered, she could give her interrogators no information that would jeopardize the network organized to help slaves escape to free states and countries where slavery was illegal, like Canada and Mexico. With luck and God’s beneficence, the man under the carriage seat would be stowed away on a boat headed to Montreal by nightfall.
If captured, she’d be asked how she happened to have chosen Willow Grove as a site for her abolitionist activities, and her answer would be simple enough. Jessica Wyndham, her sister’s classmate, had mentioned a teaching post coming vacant when the present schoolmistress married and emigrated with her husband to Texas. Willow Grove was located in the soul of the Deep South. What better place to serve as a conductor for the Underground Railroad than in South Carolina? What better cover than as a teacher in a little town in the heart of slave country? She would keep Jessica’s involvement to herself. Never would they learn from her lips that the daughter of the state’s most prominent planter had not only suggested but had arranged for her to be given the teaching job.
Did Miss Wyndham know you were a conductor for the Underground Railroad?
Of course not! When I learned of the vacant post, I intentionally ingratiated myself to her by pleading a broken love affair and the need for a teaching position far away from Massachusetts.
But Jessica had known. When Jessica learned of Sarah’s affiliation with a group that trained supporters of abolition to infiltrate the South as cogs in an organized system to undermine slavery, she had proposed the teaching position as the perfect job to conceal Sarah’s clandestine activities.
“There’s even a small house you can rent ideal for your purpose,” Jessica had told her. “It’s the property of the First Presbyterian Church in Willow Grove. It’s set on the church grounds behind the cemetery, the reason it stays vacant, but it’s very private and secluded.”
At first Sarah was disinclined to trust her. The school made no secret of its anti-slavery sentiments, and Jessica’s wealthy and powerful father could have enrolled her to gather information about the system that assisted slaves to escape from the South. It did not take long for Sarah to realize that her suspicions of Jessica were unfounded. Jessica’s parents were ignorant of the school’s leanings, or they never would have sent her there, and their daughter genuinely and wholeheartedly abhorred slavery as a cruel and immoral institution. She considered her colored maid Tippy her best friend, and it was for Tippy’s sake that once Sarah was ensconced in her position in Willow Grove, Jessica had regretfully explained she could do nothing to help her in her mission.
“My father will send Tippy to the fields if he discovers my involvement,” she’d said, and Sarah, having met Carson Wyndham and perceived exactly what kind of man he was, had no doubt Jessica’s fears were justified.
“You’ve done enough,” Sarah had assured her. “Keep Tippy safe.”
At boarding school she had explained to Jessica that the Underground Railroad was no railroad at all but a highly secret network of escape routes and safe houses strung from the South to the North and farther into Canada or southward into Mexico. Railroad terminology designated the duties of the brave souls willing to help slaves escape. “Agents” were people who infiltrated the South to distribute abolitionist literature, contact anti-slavery sympathizers, and set up routes and safe houses run by “station masters.” The houses were known as “stations” or “depots” where fugitives could rest and eat. Conductors led the runaway—or “cargo”—from one station to the next, the job Sarah had been trained for.
When Sarah reported Jessica’s offer to the “engineer”—the head of her group—he enthusiastically encouraged her to take the position. An agent was already in place in the area of Willow Grove, he told her. She was not to know his name in case she was caught, but he would know hers and make contact by code. Sarah had mailed her résumé to the school’s administrative body, and a return letter granted her, sight unseen, the position and stated a date to begin her teaching duties the middle of October. Shortly afterwards, she had set sail for her destination to get settled before she assumed her post and was greeted by Lettie and Reverend Sedgewick as she stepped onto the dock in Charleston.
The Sedgewicks were another reason why her real purpose in Willow Grove must remain undetected. If suspicion fell on her, it might also fall on them, and they were innocent of what she was about in the secluded house behind the cemetery. There, having learned the secret, silent “language” by which she and the agent communicated, Sarah had received knocks late at night, found notes written in code slipped under her door or odd markings on her front stoop. Within days of taking up residence, she’d hidden a runaway for pickup at midnight, flashed signals by way of candle and lamplight into the woods across the creek, and left several cryptic messages to be collected from the back porch. The number of runaways and successful escapes had increased in the area, but so far no one had tied it to her arrival. The “freight” had slowed now that winter had blocked routes to points farther north. Sarah felt she’d lived a lifetime since her boat had docked in Charleston less than two months before.
“Fellow,” she said, barely moving her lips, her lowered voice urgent, “there’s trouble up ahead. Put the kerchief back on and lie absolutely still.”
“Oh, Lord have mercy,” her cargo moaned.
A knot of horsemen had emerged from the thickets on one side of the road. Coiled whips hung from their saddle horns and all carried weapons. Sarah, at the raised hand of one of the riders, pulled at the reins and drew Jimsonweed to a stop. She recognized the heavy, well-tailored shoulders of the most affluent among them: Michael Wyndham, Jessica’s brother.
He kneed his fine Arabian stallion toward the wagon, surprise, curiosity, and admiration mingling in his gaze beneath the wide brim of his low-crowned planter’s hat. Sarah felt the back of her neck crawl. The man was a perfect replica of his father. Carelessly, Michael brought his fingers to his hat brim. “Mornin’, Miss Conklin. What brings you along the road this day before Thanksgiving?”
“I’m on my way to the post office in Charleston,” she said. “And you?”
He laughed and threw a glance at his cohorts. “Isn’t it obvious? We’re looking for a runaway from Willowshire. You haven’t by any chance seen a black man running for his life along the road, have you? He goes by the name of Timothy.”
A soft grunt came from under the seat. Timothy. The runaway was from Willowshire. Good God, Jessica, what have you done? Sarah’s breath held from alarm that Michael Wyndham had heard the muffled sound, but his attention remained fastened on her.
“I’m afraid not,” she said, forcing a light but dismissive tone and regripping the reins to suggest she must be on her way.
The press of Michael Wyndham’s muscular thighs urged his horse closer. Sarah knew he was attracted to her as only a man can be who enjoys the thrill of the hunt and satisfaction of the kill. Her patent indifference to him had backfired. If she’d been flirtatious and coy, he would have lost interest, but she presented a challenge he was determined to win. If only he knew how much she loathed him and his kind.
“Perhaps you’ll allow me to ride with you to Charleston, Miss Conklin,” he suggested. “My cohorts can take charge of my horse and pursue the boy without me, and you and I can dine at the Thermidor after you’ve finished your business at the post office.”
Quickly, her heartbeat pounding, Sarah considered how best to respond to his offer. What argument could she give to dissuade the arrogant toad? Please, Timothy, do not make a sound. “I appreciate your kindness, Mr. Wyndham, but I have already accepted an invitation to luncheon with a longtime friend of mine, a gentleman who is visiting Charleston, and the morning is so fine, I confess to preferring my own company on the ride into town.”
Rather than being put off, rebuffed, as she intended, he threw back his head for a hearty laugh. “You seem always to know how to put me in my place, Miss Conklin, but I am not an easy man to stay put.” He touched his hat again, an imposing figure in his polished knee boots with his thickening girth minimized by the outward flare of a long jacket pinched at the waistline, a colorful scarf around his neck. “Enjoy your ride and your luncheon with your gentleman friend, and I shall look forward to another time when I have the pleasure of your exclusive company for both.”
He signaled with his hand, and the horsemen parted. Head held high and back straight, Sarah directed Jimsonweed through the pack without returning a nod of greeting and shortly heard the sound of hooves cantering off in the opposite direction.
There was a stir beneath the carriage board. “We clear, miss?”
Sarah put a hand over her heart to steady its hammering. “We’re clear, Timothy.”