No nightshirt at all.
He was bared to the hips, every inch of his torso hard and gleaming in the firelight, like a sculpture cast in bronze. She was rocked by the impulse to reach for him, but some ingrained voice of warning held her back—not the voice that warned a girl away from dangerous men but the voice that kept her from reaching for a potato that had fallen in the coals.
He would singe her fingers.
“Then you cheated,” she managed to whisper, dragging her gaze back up to his. “You told more than one lie. You rogue. Men have been called out for less.”
“What is this? We’re dueling now? No one gets called out for parlor games.”
“No. They get called out for trifling with a gentlewoman’s virtue and ruining her chances at happiness. This is my life at stake. And you lied to me.”
The sleep was gone from his expression now. He was awake, and angry. “I said that Piers loves you. Why is that so damned hard to believe?”
“Because my lie was so close to the truth. He never even kissed me, Rafe. Not once in eight years of betrothal.”
He shook his head in disbelief.
She folded her hands in her lap. “It’s true. When you kissed me in the tower a few days ago . . . ? That kiss was my first.”
“Your first?” Rafe couldn’t believe it.
He sat up in bed. The linen bedsheet pooled about his waist. “That’s not possible.”
“I assure you, it’s true. It’s beyond humiliating to admit it, but it’s true.”
He stared at her, with her delicate profile and her unbound hair falling down her back in golden waves. She was so lovely, he ached. For the first time, he began to question his brother. Could Piers be one of those men who preferred his own sex?
Surely not. Rafe dismissed the idea out of hand. When they were youths, his brother was forever “borrowing” Rafe’s best French engravings from his bottom drawer, even though he pretended to know nothing about it when confronted. And there’d been stories of the usual debauched adventures in his university days. Not a lot of stories, but a few.
No, Piers liked women.
Which made Clio’s confession all the more baffling to comprehend. How could Piers resist kissing this woman?
Rafe had excellent reasons not to kiss Clio, and he’d succumbed to temptation—multiple times—despite them.
“I was truly your first?” he asked.
She nodded.
White-hot triumph forked through him like a lightning bolt. Rafe could have run a victory lap around the castle. He hadn’t felt this good since winning his first championship bout. He couldn’t even be angry with his brother now. Knowing that he was Clio’s first kiss, her first touch . . .
It made him want to be her first everything.
Not just her first, but her last. Her best.
His hands made fists in the bedsheets. “You need to return to your own chamber.”
Instead of leaving, she eased herself farther onto the bed and tucked her crossed legs under her nightrail. Making herself right at home.
To be fair, he supposed she was in her own home. Very well. He could be the one to leave. Not just this room, but the castle. If he went to saddle his gelding right now, he could be in Southwark by daybreak.
He nodded at his shirt and trousers, draped over the arm of a chair—just out of reach. “Hand me my clothing, will you?”
She didn’t move, except to toy with a lock of her unbound, golden hair. When she spoke, her tone was husky. “Would you like to hear a bedtime story?”
“Not particularly, no.”
Laying a hand to his chest, she pushed him back against the mattress. “You’re going to hear one anyway.”