When we got back to the living room, Sophie was still on the couch, but now she wasn't alone. Will had joined her, and from the looks of it, they were having some sort of argument. Sophie was saying something, her face pinched, while Will seemed to be only half listening, glancing around the room as she talked.
"Better not bug them right now," I said to Emily. "We'll come back. Anyway, I have got to pee. Any idea where the bathroom is?"
"I thought I saw one over there," she said, nodding toward a nearby hallway. "Come on."
There was a bathroom there, but also a line, so we decided to try our luck on the second floor. We were navigating a long hallway when I heard someone yell out my name.
I stopped, then doubled back to an open door we'd just passed to see Michael Kitchens and Nick Lester, two seniors I'd spent all semester suffering through art history with, playing pool.
"See?" Nick said. "I told you I saw Annabel!"
"What do you know," Michael, who was bent over the table about to take a shot, said. "And here I thought you were just hallucinating."
Nick turned around, then put a hand to his heart when he saw me. "No, it's Annabel," he said. "Annabel, Annabel, Annabel Greene."
"You promised when the year was over, you'd let that go," I told him. He'd done some senior project on Poe and had bugged me with this line endlessly. "Remember?"
"No," he said, grinning at me.
Michael took the shot, the balls splitting apart with a clank. "Nick's drunk," he informed us. "Consider yourself warned."
"I'm not drunk," Nick said. "I'm just cheerful."
"Is there a bathroom in here?" I asked. "We've been looking for one everywhere."
"Right over there," Michael told me, nodding across the room.
"Come on," I said to Emily, and she followed me inside. "This is Nick and Michael," I said, handing her my beer. "And this is Emily. I'll be back in a sec, okay?"
She nodded, looking a bit nervous. "Do you play?" Michael asked her, gesturing at the table.
"Kind of," she said.
He walked over to the wall, pulling off a stick for her. "Yeah, right," he said. "You say that, and then you'll beat me in ten seconds."
"She does have that pool-shark look to her," Nick said. Emily laughed, shaking her head. "It's always the quiet ones."
"Just go easy on me," Michael said to her. "That's all I ask."
By the time I came out of the bathroom two minutes later, Emily was holding her own. She was also in full-on flirt mode with Michael, who seemed more than happy to reciprocate. Which left me with Nick, who sat down beside me on the nearby couch and announced he had something to say.
"You know," he said as he took a sip of his beer, "since school is over now and all, I just think you should know that I'm aware of how you feel about me."
"How I feel about you," I repeated.
"Dude," Michael called out from the right corner pocket. "Stop before you say something you regret."
"Shhh," Nick told him, waving his arm. He turned back to me. "Annabel," he said, his voice serious, "it's okay that you have a crush on me."
"Oh, God," Michael groaned. "I'm so embarrassed for you right now."
"I mean, it makes sense," Nick said, slurring slightly as I tried not to smile. "I'm a senior. An older man. It makes sense you'd look up to me. But…" Here he paused, taking another swig of his beer. "It's not going to work out."
"Oh," I said. "Well. It's better to know now, I guess."
Nick patted my hand, nodding. "I'm really flattered, but it doesn't matter how much you love me. I just don't feel that way about you."
"Like hell," Michael said, and Emily laughed.
"I understand," I told Nick.
"You do?"
"Totally."
He was still patting my hand, although, at this point, I was not sure he was aware of it. "Good. Because I'd really like, if you can get past your feelings, for us to remain friends."
"Me, too," I said.
Nick sat back, tipping his bottle to his mouth. Then he brought it back down, turning it up. One drop fell out. "Empty," he announced. "I need another."
"You really don't," Michael said, then winced as Emily shot the cue ball, knocking two of his stripes into a pocket.
"How about a water?" I asked Nick. "I was just about to get one for myself."
"A water," he repeated slowly, as if this was a foreign concept. "Okay. Lead the way."
"We'll be back," I said to Emily as I got to my feet, Nick then doing the same with considerably more trouble. "You need anything?"
She shook her head, bending down for another shot. "I'm good," she said.
"Too good," Michael said as two more of his balls disappeared. "'Kind of play, my ass."
Nick and I only made it about halfway down the hallway before he announced he'd changed his mind.
"Too tired," he said, plopping down next to a bedroom door. "Need to rest."
"Are you okay?" I asked him.
"Dandy," he replied. "You just go get that, that…"
"Water," I said.
"Water… and I'll meet you right here. 'Kay?" He sat back, his head bonking the wall. "Right here."
I nodded, then continued on to the stairs. On the way, I stopped to look down at the living room below, which was now considerably more crowded. Sophie was gone from the couch, as was Will, which I figured was either a good sign or a really bad one.
Downstairs, I located two bottled waters, then stopped to talk to a few people. When I got back to the hallway, Nick wasn't there. I figured he'd headed back to the game room. I was just about to do the same when I heard a voice.
"Annabel."
It was soft and faint. I turned. There was a bedroom to my right, the door slightly ajar. Handy if you were stumbling or, even worse, puking. Poor Nick , I thought. I stuck one water in my back pocket, opened the other one, then pushed the door open and stepped inside.
"Hey," I said. "Did you get lost?"
As I stepped over the threshold into the dark, I had my first prickling sense that something wasn't right.