Chapter 6
So you’re the miserable thief? Amish, ha! Think you’re all high-minded and separate from the world with your clothes and your talk. You ain’t no better than a common criminal and jail’s where you belong. I’ll be calling the police now.”
Jacob had expected the malevolence from Granger and knew he deserved it. What the Englischer was saying was true, at least about him as an individual, but not about his people. He sighed silently and resisted the urge to rest his weight against the doorjamb as he let the man splutter out.
“Mr. Granger, please call the authorities. As you say, I’m a common horse thief. I made a mistake, and I deserve the consequences.”
“You bet you do.”
“But, I could have handled things differently maybe … maybe instead of stealing the mare I might have offered to buy her outright from you. You obviously aren’t happy with her for some reason.”
“Buy her from me?” The man sneered. “At a bargain no doubt, and a waste at that. She can’t handle a bit and deserves what she got.”
Jacob had to remind himself that he should not want to grab the man by the throat, especially when he mentioned the abuse of the animal as something deserved. But he collected himself and calmly offered the man triple the highest value of what the mare was worth.
“You’re crazy.” Granger eyed him with suspicion but also with a growing interest in his demeanor, which could only be called greed.
“In cash. Right now. I take the mare home. You give me a bill of sale and we keep the—purchase between us.”
The man stroked his chin. “Add another thousand. I’ve heard it said that you Amish are tighter with money than any people around. So, I guess making you pay is really making you pay— more than time in jail might.” Granger chuckled at his own joke.
“Fine.”
Jacob paid the ridiculous price without hesitation and waited for the receipt, all the while praising Derr Herr that he’d been allowed the lightest of consequences. Of course, Granger could always come looking for him, bringing the police, but Jacob had the feeling that all the Amish would look alike to the angry man, so he didn’t worry too much since he held the bill of sale.
He left Granger’s feeling sullied and exhausted, and he knew he needed rest badly. But the thoughts of the day kept him upright in the saddle. He was engaged to Lilly Lapp.
She said what?”
Alice Plank, Lilly’s best friend and fellow teacher, choked on the question with a look of horror on her pretty, round face. The two were seated at the Planks’ kitchen table in the light of early dawn, drinking tea. Alice’s father and brother were doing chores outside the small farmhouse that was situated next door to the Lapps’.
“She said, ‘No.’ Short and sharp—just like that.”
“Well, what did he say?”
Lilly sighed, reflecting on the night before. Jacob had not been very happy, to say the least. She wrapped her hands around the mug.
“Well, are you going to tell me the story or not?”
“Long or short version?”
“Long, of course, don’t leave any details out.” She leaned forward, eager to hear it all.
“All right then. I let Jacob inside—the hallway was dark of course. Mamm had set no light on the table. As usual, it smelled like pine disinfectant and mothballs. I so wanted to apologize for the smells, but I decided he might as well experience everything. I remember swallowing my apprehension as I made my way into the sitting room where the single lamp burned. He caught my hand in the dark and squeezed my fingers.”
“How sweet,” Alice said.
“I know. And I was so grateful. It made me feel strong enough to face Mamm. But I supposed that one meeting with her and he’d be running to the bishop to retract the engagement.”
“No kidding,” Alice said, then quickly put her hand on Lilly’s arm. “I mean no respect toward your—”
“Alice. It’s okay. It’s nice to have someone who understands what it’s like.”
Alice smiled. “So? Don’t stop now.”
“Before we even got to the sitting room, Mamm called, ‘Is that you, Lilly? I’ve been worried sick. It’s way past the time I told you to be home—whatever happened?’”
“I was so embarrassed. I felt like a boppli. But Jacob spoke up. ‘Forgive me, Mrs. Lapp. It’s my fault Lilly’s been gone so long.’
“‘Who do you have with you?’ Mamm cried out. I felt bad for her. I could see her kapp was actually quivering. She shrank back on the couch like he was going to attack her.”
“Your poor mamm,” Alice said. “It must be awful to be so afraid.”
“Well, it didn’t last for long. I took him into the small circle of light near her. I told her, ‘It’s all right, Mamm. It’s Jacob Wyse. He brought me home.’
“We walked into the room and I tried to see her as Jacob might. She looked so tiny with all those quilts round her. About all you could see were the lines on her face and dark shadows under her eyes as she peered up at us. That might have been okay. But then she started in on him.
“‘Jacob Wyse? Bringing you home? And on Sarah King’s wedding day.’ She looked at him like he was an insect getting into her bread dough. ‘I’m surprised you could bear to attend the service.’”
Alice sucked in a breath of shock. “What did you say?”
“I tried to plead with her to be silent. Then it got worse.”
Lilly closed her eyes as Jacob’s calm voice echoed in her head. “He said, ‘Yes, Mrs. Lapp, we both attended the celebration today, but we were delayed some by the weather and by our own talk.’
“Mamm wiped her nose with a hankie and stared at him. ‘What’s that now?’
“Jacob tried to be polite. He told her that we were delayed by our own talk—of our future together. ‘Sei so gut,’ he said kindly. ‘Forgive me for not following tradition and sending a schtecklimann to ask your permission first, but I was … caught up in the moment. I’ve announced our engagement to both the bishop and the community.’”
“Wow,” Alice said. “He sounds as though he was very formal and polite.”
“Yes, he was. I was impressed. But I hadn’t thought about the schtecklimann until he mentioned it.”
Lilly poured more tea into her mug and took a sip, thinking about the schtecklimann—a potential groom’s go-between. Normally Jacob would have asked one of the deacons to go in secret to ask her mother’s permission for her hand in marriage. Of course, it should have been her father who received the request.
“Then Mamm bolted upright. ‘What? Lilly? What’s he saying? That you’re engaged?’ I don’t really blame her. It was a shocking announcement.”
“What did you say?” Alice asked.
“Actually, I didn’t say anything. Jacob spoke up right away. ‘Yes, Mrs. Lapp,’ he said. ‘Lilly and I are engaged.’”
“For a brief moment I thought Mamm might have apoplexy as she choked and coughed into her hankie. ‘Say it isn’t true,’ she said, giving me that glare.”
“I know the one,” Alice said.
“I tried to speak in a soft voice, hoping that might help her hear the shocking news. ‘It’s true. Jacob and I are engaged, Mamm. I’m sorry for the short notice and the surprise. I hope you’ll be happy with the wedding though.’
“‘The wedding! When is the wedding—in a year’s time, surely?’
“‘Nee,’ Jacob said. ‘The wedding date has been given to the bishop as the twenty-third of December—this year.’
“‘Nee.’”
Alice gasped.
“‘What, Mamm?’ I asked her.
“‘I said no.’
“‘Does the date displease you, Mrs. Lapp?’ Jacob asked.
“‘No, young man, the engagement displeases me, and setting a wedding date for a few weeks out is entirely unacceptable.’”
“Oh boy,” Alice muttered.
Lilly nodded. “Of all the possible reactions from Mamm, this is one I didn’t anticipate. I didn’t know what to say. I started to open my mouth to say something, anything to fill the awkward silence. But Jacob cleared his throat and stood up to her again. His voice came out low, husky. It sent shivers down my spine.”
“Mmmmm.” Alice sounded as though she had just eaten fresh strawberry ice cream. She gave Lilly an understanding smile.
The image of Jacob’s bare back danced behind Lilly’s eyelids like a mirage just out of reach. She would keep that thought to herself.
“He said, ‘I understand you’re upset, Mrs. Lapp, but you can rest assured that I have Lilly’s best interests at heart.’
“Mamm actually snorted. ‘Don’t try to horse talk me, young man. You forget that I lived for more than twenty years with an animal whisperer; it’ll get you nowhere. Now tell me, is she pregnant?’”
Alice burst out laughing, then clapped a hand over her mouth. “Ach, I’m sorry, Lilly. But I can’t believe she’d say that.”
Lilly stared down into her cooling tea and resisted the urge to rub her temples. “Well, she did.”
“And—Jacob?”
“He wanted to wring her neck, I think, but he took it. Then he just said straight out that he was marrying me, with or without her approval.”
“And then she said yes?”
“Nooo, then she was mad enough to spit.”
“It sounds like they’re a matched pair,” Alice observed.
Lilly laughed. “Maybe so. But she finally settled down when he told her that he was moving in with us instead of me going to live at the Wyses’.”
Alice stared at her. “Lilly, really? He must genuinely care for you.”
“I wish I could believe that, but I think he’s just doing what’s right—to see to my mother’s health and provision. He said he spoke to the bishop about it at the wedding. I don’t even know when he found the time.”
Alice added a spoonful of sugar to her cup, then stirred thoughtfully.
“What is it, Alice?”
“Ach, I don’t know. I mean, I know how you’ve felt about Jacob all these years and that this wedding probably seems like some kind of dream. But, are you sure it’s what you really want? I mean—with Sarah and all.”
“I’ve got to believe that it’s the Lord who’s guiding this.” She swallowed the edge of anxiety that laced her words, then looked determinedly at her friend. “I know it’s the right thing for me to do.”
“Lilly, tell me how it could be right! It was so fast. A whim. A mistake.”
Lilly shrugged her shoulders and stared into the mug with the dregs swimming at the bottom. “I can’t explain it, Alice.” She looked up. “It’s a little like the way you felt about David before he moved away.”
Alice set her mouth into a grim line. “Intuition is risky, Lilly.”
“I don’t think it’s all intuition. I think it’s Derr Herr’s whisper.”
Alice looked at her with resolve. “Then I will stand by you. Always.”
“Besides.” Lilly laughed. “If I didn’t marry Jacob, I don’t think another man would survive my mother’s tongue.”
Alice laughed with her. She picked up the mugs and put them into the sink. “Did she finally give her blessing?”
“Jah. But she told Jacob he’d have to earn her approval.”
“Ach, Lilly. This is going to be some marriage.”
“I’m beginning to see that.” She glanced at her brooch watch and groaned. “I’d best move before Mamm wakes up. I’ll see you later. Oh, and thank you for being willing to be my wedding attendant.”
Alice stood with her and gave her a big hug. “I wouldn’t miss it, Lilly. Not for anything.”