chapter Three
Don took the photograph from Casey’s hand and looked at it for a long moment before setting it on top of the pile. He scooted all of the pictures together and rapped them gently on the desktop to even them out. Finally, he pulled the folder across the desk, laid the photos on top of the papers, and closed it. “She was his girlfriend. They’d been dating a few months.”
“That hardly makes her his girlfriend.”
Death laughed. “So what does it make her? A friend with benefits?”
“Casey.” Don’s voice was gentle. “They were an item. He really liked her.”
She closed her eyes and let the idea sink in. “Okay. So they were going out. The cops can’t possibly think he did this to her.”
Don stayed quiet for so long Casey had to open her eyes to see what was happening. He looked gray in the office light, and the bags under his eyes seemed to have darkened in the past minute.
“No,” Casey said. “No way would Ricky do this.”
“I know that. And you know that. But the cops have leads, and evidence, and…” He shrugged. “They think they have their man. They’re not checking out anyone else.”
Casey looked at Death, who now hovered behind Don, eyes on Don’s cell phone, which lay alongside his briefcase on the edge of the desk. “What exactly did she say?”
“She didn’t say anything, Casey,” Don said. “She was dead.”
The phone in Death’s hand changed to imitate Don’s. Death poked at it uncertainly. “She said nothing about Ricky. Except to tell him good-bye. Everything else was about the Three.”
“The Three…”
Don’s brow furrowed. “What is this with the number three? Are you talking about the evidence? The three main things they’re banking on? But how did you even know about those?”
“I didn’t. I…What’s the evidence?”
“First, the final number called from her phone. According to the phone company, who had to check her records since her phone is missing, the last number dialed was Ricky’s, at about nine o’clock. The call lasted almost thirty seconds. Enough time for a brief conversation.”
“That doesn’t mean anything. Anybody could have dialed that number using her phone. And if she was his girlfriend it shouldn’t have been unusual for them to talk on the phone.”
“Second, there were…” He cleared his throat. “Used condoms in the trash. They’re guessing Ricky’s DNA. They’ll know for sure soon.”
“Again, meaningless. You said she was his girlfriend, right?”
“Third.” His eyes met hers. “Ricky was seen leaving her apartment Thursday night around eleven. The landlord was going to bed. He noticed movement on the street and saw Ricky’s car. Ricky got in it and drove away.”
“And the landlord felt the need to call the cops?”
“Only after he found Alicia’s body the next day. In fact, he didn’t remember about seeing Ricky at all until several hours later, long after he found her. He was in shock, I think, from seeing her that way.”
“So he offered up my brother as a sacrifice?”
“He was doing his duty, Casey.”
She shook her head, knowing he was right, but still angry. “He didn’t see anyone else after Ricky that night? Nobody else came to her apartment?”
“Like I said, the guy was going to bed. Ricky being at Alicia’s apartment wasn’t exactly unusual. The landlord didn’t think anything of it. He turned out the lights and went to sleep.”
And let the real bad guys arrive unseen. “Great.” Her mind spun. “Okay, those three pieces of evidence are all circumstantial. Phone calls, DNA they haven’t matched, visiting his girlfriend’s place. I suppose they raided Ricky’s house, too?”
“They searched it, yes, the next night. With a warrant.”
“And found…?”
He lifted his hands. “Nothing I’ve heard about. Well, except normal boyfriend kinds of things. This picture—” he tapped the folder, indicating the photo of the two of them at the restaurant “—notes in Alicia’s handwriting, a take-out menu from the restaurant where she worked. Clothes, make-up, that sort of thing, you know, that she probably left at his place over the past few months.”
“Everything that would show she actually was his girlfriend.”
“And nothing to show he didn’t kill her.”
“But nothing to show he did.” She stood up and paced in the small area in front of the desk. “Did they actually interview him after they found her, or only after the landlord called?”
“They didn’t know to talk to him. Like I said, Alicia’s phone was missing, and she had nothing else of his in her apartment. Not an address book with his information, or any kind of computer, or anything. The only reason the cops knew her name was because of the landlord.”
“Didn’t Ricky show up at her place, wondering where she was when he couldn’t reach her by phone?”
“Yes, actually. That’s the first the police talked to him. He went to her apartment on Friday, the night after she died. The landlord had remembered seeing him the night before, and the cops were getting ready to pay him a visit. They questioned him quite extensively right there at her place.”
“Were you there?”
“Not that time. He wasn’t a suspect yet—at least not officially.”
“And he told them stuff?”
“Of course he did. After all, they hit him with the news, right there where she died, and he was devastated. He wanted to help.”
“And incriminated himself.”
Don held up his hands, and dropped them. “He didn’t put up an argument about the night before. He confirmed he’d been there, and that he’d left her—alive—close to eleven. They arrested him the next morning, once they’d gotten her phone number so they could retrieve a list of calls.”
“So what can I do? I have to help him.”
“You can’t help yet.”
“Of course I can. It’s why I came. Why you told me to come.”
“Casey, the cops have other priorities where you’re concerned. You know you’re wanted for questioning about what happened in Ohio three weeks ago. If they see you, that’s all they’re going to care about, and you and Ricky will be headlined as homicidal siblings.”
Casey didn’t want to think about Ohio, about how she’d killed a man. About how she was on the run. Especially now that Ricky needed her.
“But you said Eric vouched for me. He told them it was self-defense.” This would be Eric VanDiepenbos, a sweet, good-hearted, handsome young man who had befriended Casey three weeks earlier and then watched in horror as she’d killed the Louisville thug. She hadn’t meant for him to see it. She hadn’t meant for it to happen. “Besides, the cops know the guy was a mobster.
“You know it was self-defense,” Don said. “And Eric knows that. But until the cops hear it directly from you, they’re obligated to hunt you down. You can’t just waltz into the police station—or the jail to visit Ricky—until your own issues are cleared up.”
“Then let’s go. Right now.”
“We can’t. The people we need are all asleep. And you’re not going to get on their good side by pulling them out of bed on a Sunday night for something that could just as easily be done in the morning.”
She glanced at Death, who was typing frantically on the smart phone. Death nodded, and said without looking up, “He’s right. Everything’s closed, and folks are finishing up the weekend. It’s best to put it on the back burner till morning.”
“Okay,” Casey said, throwing up her hands. “Fine. You win.”
“It’s not a competition.” Don put Alicia’s folder in his briefcase and stood up. “You have somewhere to spend the night?”
“Ricky’s is off-limits, I guess?”
“Still sealed off. How about your house? Or maybe,” he added quickly, “your mother’s?”
“She doesn’t even know I’m in town.”
“Right.” He heaved a heavy sigh. “So I guess that means you’ll be coming home with me.”
“I can’t. The cops will look there.”
“They don’t know you’re in town, either.”
“But don’t they suspect I’ll be coming around, with Ricky in trouble?”
“I don’t know what they suspect. They’re cops. They suspect everything.”
“So here’s what we’ll do. I’ll find a place to sleep—”
“Come home with me.”
“—and I’ll meet you here in the morning, at…what time does your office open?”
“Eight.”
“Seven-thirty. And then we’ll do it.”
“Do what?”
“We’ll go to the police station, and I’ll turn myself in.”