30
HENRY SAT in his most comfortable chair in the privacy of his library, a room full of books that had helped him pass more than a few lonely nights. Yet he felt little comfort. This Saturday night had been like countless others; he’d eaten whatever Mrs. Gio had put before him. As usual, it pleased his senses and filled his stomach, but the passage of yet another meal alone left him wanting.
He reread a line of the book in his hand, one he’d recently begun: Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. Asked to tell of Hyde, one of the characters said: “He is not easy to describe. There is something wrong with his appearance; something displeasing, something downright detestable. I never saw a man I so disliked, and yet I scarce know why. He must be deformed somewhere; he gives a strong feeling of deformity, although I couldn’t specify the point. . . .”
Henry slammed the book shut. A deformity of the spirit might be what Hyde suffered, but if so, it was precisely Henry’s condition as well. Why else had he done what he’d done all those years ago and let it get the best of his entire life? Little had he known that his youthful impatience, his lack of trust in himself to work hard and earn his way honestly and slowly, would ruin him forever.
He stood, abandoning all effort to pass the time with a book, no matter how interesting. Despite the fact that tomorrow night at this time the entire house would be lit and full of polite guests, there was nothing for Henry to do tonight. The event, as always, had been placed in the capable hands of his butler, Mr. Barron, and Mrs. Gio. A dozen deliveries had been accepted that week, all in preparation for a meal that would accommodate twenty guests, the maximum number his dining room could comfortably hold. Already cloths draped various tables throughout the rooms as well as ornamental niches in the hallways, ready to accept the dozens of flower arrangements that would arrive in the morning to fill and warm Henry’s cavernous home.
It was too early for Henry to go to bed. Perhaps he would take a walk. Fresh air now might help him sleep later.
But he made it no farther than the front hall before a knock at the door called his attention. Dismissing Barron of his duty—he saw the man even now hurrying from behind the butler’s pantry in the nearby hall—Henry opened the door himself.
It came as no surprise to find Tobias there. Henry opened the door wide, about to welcome him in—glad for the company—when he saw that his uncle wasn’t alone.
The slight shadow beside Tobias’s wide and tall one was easily missed in the dim light of evening. But there she was. Henry’s mother.
They stared at one another for what could have been too long a moment, or perhaps too short. Henry didn’t know which, he was so lost in a rush of emotion. Two years suddenly seemed far too long, especially when preceded by years of scant contact. Knowing it had been Henry’s decision, and his alone, cast a burden onto his shoulders he hadn’t planned to face. Not tonight.
“I’m sorry.”
How strange a greeting that might have seemed, but to his mother it appeared welcome. She raised a petite, gloved hand to her chin, and the moment he saw her tremble he stepped closer, ushering her inside with one hand around her shoulders and the other finding one of her hands.
“Come in, Mother, come in. Sit down. Are you hungry? Thirsty?”
“No, no,” she said, her voice more tremulous than her fingers. Beneath his embrace he felt the quiver of her slight frame and wished—not for the first time—that he hadn’t been such a fool. Especially since his father had died some eight years ago. How alone had his mother been? As alone as Henry?
“Come into the parlor, will you? Both of you? It’s comfortable in there, with the windows open. The breeze is pleasant.”
His mother, still holding his hand as if she were as reluctant as he to let go, looked around. To Henry’s shame, she had never before seen his home. He’d never invited her. He wished the flowers had already been delivered, because she saw it now for what it was: half-decorated, void of any personal touch. Clean, orderly, but stark. Cold. The single portrait of her father looked as lonely as Henry’s life.
A maid appeared—Ulla, Mrs. Gio’s niece, who had been brought in for the party. She offered tea, but the moment she left to retrieve it, and just as soon as he helped his mother to a settee, Henry went to the table at the side of the room to pour himself a glass of water. The others declined, but he was glad to have the cool glass in his grip.
“I’m sorry I didn’t let you know I was coming early,” his mother said. “But Tobias seemed to think it would be a good idea if I stayed here tonight, and that I might be of help with the party tomorrow.”
“The staff—” Henry began, but stopped himself. He smiled, taking a seat near his mother. “That would be most appreciated, Mother. Thank you.” Then a warm thought struck him. “And you’ll come to church with me in the morning, of course.”
Her mother raised rounded eyes his way. “Church? I didn’t know you . . .”
“I only recently began attending again.” Then Henry smiled wider. He knew he was on the right road, and now his mother’s presence allowed him hope of forgiveness. But he still had much to prove—to himself and to others. “To be honest, it’s been very recent. Though you may not yet believe it, something has changed in my life, something that makes me regret very much the way I’ve treated you. I hope you’ll forgive me, and that I can be a better son to you.”
She held out a hand that still trembled, and the sparkle of a tear caught the light in her eyes. “You’ll have to forgive me too, then, Son. The road between your house and mine travels both ways. I could have been more diligent in using that road myself.”
“No, Mother. I was the one who pushed you away.” Henry set aside the glass. He glanced nervously from his mother to his uncle, uncertain how to explain, or if an explanation was needed. Would revealing his past help her to understand, or would the knowledge of what he’d done only make her ashamed of him? Make her do the pushing away this time?
“Tell her, Henry. It’s time.”
Tobias’s words reached Henry loud and clear, almost as if his own conscience had somehow spoken them for all to hear. Henry gazed at him, his surprise turning to confusion.
Slowly, without another word, Tobias pulled something from his pocket. That old brown handkerchief.
But no, Henry saw now that it was cut too roughly, frayed at the edges as if it had been torn and not neatly sewn. It had not been made for any gentleman. It was tattered, too, or so it seemed when Henry caught a glimpse of a hole.
Tobias took the material and held it up in both hands, revealing what Henry had guessed. It wasn’t a handkerchief at all. But what he slowly suspected it to be made his head spin.
It was a mask—one Henry recognized.
“What’s that you have, Uncle Tobias?” The question, entirely unnecessary, was meant to buy Henry some time. But it wasn’t enough. No words, no explanation, no excuses came to mind.
“It was yours once, Henry. Do you recall? I found it the day of the robbery, when I chased after you and the wind blew it from your hand.”
“I—” He didn’t know what he’d been about to say, especially with such a confident start. A worthless, untrue denial? So he stopped. He nodded.
His mother rose, taking the scrap of material gently from her brother. “I’ve known about it for some time, Henry. This was from my sewing basket—material Tobias and I brought with us from Manchester when we were children.”
He turned an astonished gaze from his mother to his uncle.
“I brought the material to her, knowing she’d recognize it just as I did. I never meant to tell her, but after so long, I thought she ought to understand why you kept yourself away.”
His mother stood very near, placing a hand over Henry’s clenched ones. “I took it as some comfort that you didn’t flaunt what you’d done, Henry. But it’s time we all faced the truth. Isn’t it?”
Just then Ulla returned with the tea tray, pouring efficiently, silently. Tobias and Henry’s mother accepted the cups, but the moment Ulla left they both set their tea aside.
“I’ve wanted to speak to you about this ever since, Henry. I’d hoped the notes I sent would remind you of God’s willingness to forgive.”
Henry stared at his mother, wide-eyed. “You sent them?”
She nodded. “I’m sorry they were so mysterious, but I was too much a coward to come to you directly. I’d hoped you would go to Tobias with them. If you’d spoken to him first, it might have been easier to come to me next.”
Henry looked at his uncle. “You knew about the notes?”
Tobias nodded.
“Don’t blame him if they were troublesome,” his mother said, patting Henry on his jacket lapel. “I made him promise to keep my secret until I could speak to you myself.”
Tobias shrugged, as if embarrassed. “We believed you would become curious enough about them to open up the entire subject for the first time. Evidently a failed plan.”
“But, Henry,” his mother said softly, “what’s to be done . . . now?”
“After all these years? I don’t know. I returned the money, if it’s any consolation. Anonymously, of course.”
“Yes, we knew that, too,” she said. “It was in the papers, at least around Leadville. I know there is no warrant for your arrest, Henry, and I know you’ve tried to do the right thing. In fact, the boys back home play a game pretending to be the bandit tricking everyone with a make-believe gang behind him, just as you did.” She smiled, just a little smile, then replaced it with a frown. “But I don’t know why you did it in the first place, and I don’t know why you haven’t allowed me in your life all these years. Was it the shame of having been a thief?”
“Partly.”
“And the other? Why did you steal? How did your father and I fail you so?”
“You? Fail me?” Henry shook his head and turned from her, too ashamed to face her unnecessary and groundless guilt. “It was my idea, my fault. My impatience. I saw how you struggled to grow the businesses—first that smithy, then the mercantile. I didn’t want to waste that kind of time. It was me, Mother. All me.” Then he sucked in a deep breath. He might as well confess it all; they knew the bulk of it anyway. “Sit down again, won’t you?”
Once seated, Henry told it all. About the girl he’d fallen in love with in college, about how pleased he’d been to have already secured his successful life—built upon the lie he’d concocted about a wealthy investor giving him money. He would return home not only with enough to start his business, but with a wife, ready to start his family.
But then that same girl’s brother, a lawyer, had been convicted of embezzling funds from the estates of several clients. His theft cast the entire family into shame. Henry would have married her anyway and taken her to Denver, far away from Chicago. It seemed a perfect solution, even to her and her family.
Until he realized that was precisely the kind of shame he risked putting her through again, should his own theft ever be uncovered. It was then he’d discovered he would never do such a thing, not only to her, but to any woman he might come to love. Or to his family.
As he spoke, the reminder of that shame resurrected a wall that had been crumbling lately, one Dessa Caldwell had successfully, unknowingly, chipped away. He’d thought he might risk it after so many years, after having made restitution. Even lately, he hoped he might find forgiveness from God—the very God she worshiped, who forgave all those she so desperately wanted to care for in the Fourth Ward. Surely he might find forgiveness from both God . . . and her?
But the social shame—that was something he wasn’t sure he could risk. Not even for her.
“The entire family suffered for that man’s mistakes, Mother.” He took, then squeezed, one of her hands. “I didn’t want that for you. I thought if I were ever caught, it was best if I were already out of your life. You wouldn’t miss me.”
“Oh, Henry!”
He moved to kneel before her, taking her into an embrace as she released her tears. “I know it wasn’t worth it, Mother. It’s taken me a dozen years to figure it out, but I know it now.”