“You knew we used to live in Caleb’s guest house.” I may as well voice it into the air, because it’s something I’ve been avoiding. “Right?”
She turns around slowly, clearing her throat. She seems nervous. “Yeah.”
“Well… He took me to his house, and the guys were there. They got into a fight—over me, I guess, I don’t know—so I ran. It was instinct to go back there.” I shudder. “Everything was the same as the day we left. They hadn’t even gotten rid of our personal things.”
“Oh, Margo,” Riley whispers, coming over and sitting next to me. “So you ran in there, and it was like jumping back in time?”
“Besides the dust, yeah. My room was untouched. Like, still a pair of jeans on the floor from the night before everything happened.” I swallow my heartache. “And then Caleb…”
She winces before I even say it.
“He was furious. And he hasn’t talked to me since.”
“I’d say he’ll come around, but he was mean to you, right? Maybe it’s better that you’ve escaped his attention for now.”
I nod halfheartedly. “Yeah, maybe.”
It was only a matter of time before Caleb’s attention moved on to something a little more… stable. He said it himself, I was only a game. Savannah was only a means to an end for said game.
It isn’t until the next day at school that I realize how awful of a prediction my words were. Amelie Page, former best friend, stands in the center of the courtyard. She flips her golden hair behind her shoulder, smiling at the circle of people around her.
And Caleb…
He’s smiling at her. She has a hand looped around his arm, and her fingers grasp his biceps.
“Amelie was studying in France as an exchange student,” Riley whispers.
Shame seeps into my skin. It’s a cold, vile feeling, and I almost turn away from them. I don’t need to see Caleb with another girl who I used to like. Yet, I’m transfixed on her hand.
And then she’s breaking away from the crowd, and murmurs chase her.
“Margo!” She has an accent.
I’d forgotten about that—or maybe it’s more pronounced now that she’s older.
“Welcome home.”
I smile. I hadn’t thought to ask about her, and now I’m unprepared for the warmth in her eyes.
“I should say that to you,” I answer.
She waves me off. “Nonsense. I’m just glad that you’re back. Have you been reintroduced? You’ve seen Sav…” Her perfectly sculpted eyebrow rises. “Oh, that isn’t a happy face on our dear friend.”
I follow her gaze to where Savannah looks like she’s bitten into a lemon. Amelie leads me over to her, throwing her arm around Savannah’s shoulders.
“Our friend is back,” Amelie tells her. “We’re welcoming her with open arms.”
That’s a decree from a queen if I’ve ever heard one.
“And you remember Caleb.” She drags me over to him. “My boyfriend.”
My whole world screeches to a halt.
I stare at her, unable to even look at him. His gaze is on me for the first time in a week, and my skin itches.
“What?”
“Darling, we’ve been dating since junior year,” she says, laughing. She flips her hair back and leans in close. “Sure, you may have had him first… and Sav got her pound of flesh. But he’s not yours anymore.”
I swallow. “Interesting. I wouldn’t have expected—”
She smiles. “The bell is about to ring. You know the way?”
“To—”
She drops my arm. “Let’s go, Caleb. We’re going to be late.”
The bell rings, and I flinch. Everything about the past five minutes has been… fake.
My stomach twists when he offers his arm to her again, leading her away. The courtyard empties in seconds, as soon as the doors are swung open to admit them.
Long ago, I thought Caleb and I would have a happy ever after. Clearly… I was so wrong.
Riley finds me in the same spot Amelie left me. Seconds or minutes later, I can’t tell.
“That was the most cunning and brutal thing I’ve ever witnessed,” she says.
I swallow shards of glass. Pretty sure my insides are all hollowed out. “Yeah.”
“Do you want to skip?”
I shake my head. “I really wish we had classes together,” I mumble. “I shouldn’t skip. I should go in there with my head held high…”
She chuckles. “Okay, well, I’ll check on you after our first class. We’ll see how you feel.”
When I get to homeroom, I shouldn’t be surprised that Caleb and Amelie are so close. She’s practically on top of him, leaning against his desk while he sits there. Her hand on his arm, his hand on her waist.
My phone vibrates.
Unknown: Told you to stay away. The weakest sheep get eaten by the wolf first.
I frown, glancing around the room. Half of the people in class are on their phones.
Me: Who are you?
Unknown: You’d like it to be that easy, wouldn’t you?
Yeah, I would. But I guess that would be too much to ask of an anonymous bully.
At least Caleb does it to my face.
I manage to successfully ignore the way Amelie brushes Caleb’s hair away from his face, and the hooting of Eli, and their friendly ribbing. Just kidding, I hear it all. But it gets easier after my first two classes. I don’t have anything to do with Amelie or Caleb until last period.
And because Robert decided to have us do our projects out of class, there’s no reason for us to even look at each other.
“You okay?” Robert asks.
I realize that the whole class is empty. “The bell rang a few minutes ago. Did you even hear it?”
I stare at my paper. We had been working on blending techniques with watercolor paints, and it’s a mess of muddled colors. “Sorry. I just had a bad day.”
He drags a stool over and sits next to me. He points to one of my groups, where I’d managed to make green fade into blue. “You did this one right. You can see the blue and the green, but there’s also the middle space where it becomes a new color entirely.”
I nod. “Yeah, it’s the only one I managed to do okay on.”
He shakes his head. “No, it just takes practice. Like this?” He taps his pencil next to the orange-into-pink one. “We don’t see the two separate colors. May I?”