“He is not a doctor.” Morgan frowned. “He should have called an ambulance. She could have had a head injury or been under the influence of drugs. She could have been raped.”
“I agree.” Lance moved to the next page. “But he didn’t. And when she finally was examined, there was no evidence that any of those things occurred.” He held up a hand before she could protest. “We know too much time had passed for some of those tests.”
“But I’ll never be able to convince a jury the deputy didn’t make the right call.” Morgan rubbed the back of her neck and then went back to reading her computer screen. “At that point, the deputy gave up on getting any information out of her. She was wearing only the thin black dress. Her lips were tinted blue, and she was shivering. Not knowing what had happened inside the house, he didn’t want to enter the building without backup. The temperature was below freezing that morning. Concerned for her welfare, but also worried that she could be the killer, he handcuffed Haley and put her in the back of his car with the heater running to wait for the sheriff, who was on his way.”
Lance skimmed the next page. “Once backup arrived, the deputies cleared the house to make sure no one else was inside, dead or alive. The crime scene was secured, and the medical examiner and forensic team were called in forty-five minutes after the initial 911 call. The sheriff interviewed Haley in the back of the patrol car. The inside of the car was warm, but she still appeared to be cold, so he got her a blanket. During this very brief interview, Haley repeated her initial statement of ‘What have I done?’ Then she turned away and refused to speak anymore.” Lance lowered the papers.
“Colgate didn’t push very hard.” Morgan leaned back in her chair, picked up a pen, and drew circles on the bottom of her legal pad.
“At that point, he didn’t know about the fingerprints on the knife. He was covering his bases and not making assumptions.”
“Good point.” Morgan pointed her pen at her computer screen. “The deputies found her purse inside the house and identified her via her driver’s license. The sheriff decided to bring her into the station for further questioning.”
“He hoped the trip to the sheriff’s station would get her talking.” That’s exactly what Lance would have done.
“No doubt.” Morgan nodded. “That’s the end of the on-scene interview.”
“That’s a good start.” Except that Morgan’s new client looked pretty damned guilty.
Lance’s stomach rumbled. He glanced at his watched. It was two p.m. “We should eat. We missed lunch.”
Engrossed in her reading, Morgan waved a hand. “You go ahead. I’m going to watch Haley’s video interviews at the sheriff’s station.”
“You need to eat.” Lance sighed. “Do you want me to make you one of Sharp’s protein shakes or order pizza?”
Morgan’s head snapped up. “Did you say pizza?”
He pulled out his phone. “Extra cheese and mushrooms?”
“Yes, please.” She turned back to her computer.
“Don’t start that video without me.” Lance placed the order and requested delivery.
Morgan wrote on her legal pad. “The sheriff began questioning her at 1:53 p.m. The forensics team had taken her fingerprints and swabbed her cheek for DNA at the scene. They also sampled the dried blood on her body from multiple locations and scraped under her nails. I’m surprised they didn’t request her dress as evidence.”
Lance rounded Morgan’s desk and perched on her credenza to watch the computer screen over her shoulder. The video was frozen on the first frame. Haley huddled in the metal chair in the sheriff’s station interview room. The sheriff and a young deputy sat on the other side of the table. Haley was no longer handcuffed, and she clutched a blanket around her shoulders. Her face was smeared with makeup.
“The dress is tight and skimpy,” Lance said. “She looks uncomfortable in it. I suspect the sheriff wanted her to remain that way. Besides, the dress wasn’t going anywhere. It’s not torn or damaged. She had no way to dispose of it. She’s already complied with their requests for physical evidence, and she wasn’t claiming to have been raped. Plus, he’d have to find something for her to wear or let her use the phone to make a call. If he offered her the phone, she might have called an attorney. Once suspects lawyer up, they stop talking.”
“She’s clearly not trying to hide anything,” Morgan noted.
“No. She doesn’t look like she’s formulating any grand plan to exonerate herself, but she isn’t answering questions either.”
“She looks traumatized.” Morgan drew more overlapping circles on the yellow notepad.
“But from what?” Lance reached forward and clicked the “Play” button to start the video.
On the screen, Sheriff Colgate identified himself, Deputy York, and Haley. He noted her address for the official record. Then Colgate read Haley her Miranda rights, slid a paper and a pen across the desk, and asked her to sign to acknowledge that she understood her rights. She ignored his request. Colgate didn’t press the issue. Instead, he spoke to the camera in the corner of the ceiling. “Let the record show that Ms. Powell has been verbally apprised of her rights.”
Haley blinked, her gaze resting on the sheriff for a few seconds, then drifting away.
Colgate’s shoulders were planted against the back of the chair. He was giving her space, feeling her out at this early stage of the interview. “Ms. Powell, how did you come to be at the residence of Noah Carter this morning?”
Haley’s breath hitched, and one shoulder lifted and dropped, the movement almost imperceptible.
“You were at the nightclub Beats last night.” The sheriff shifted forward slightly, resting his forearms on the edge of the table. “What time did you leave the club?”
“I don’t know,” Haley mumbled and stared down at her fists, which were clenching the blanket edges together in front of her belly.
“You were covered in blood this morning.” The sheriff’s tone was firm but gentle, as if he were talking to a teenager who’d wrecked her dad’s car. “How did that happen?”
“I don’t know.”
“Did you go home with Noah last night?”
“I don’t know.” Haley’s voice rose both in volume and pitch, then dropped to a whisper. “I want to call my mother.”
The sheriff stood, walked around the table, and perched on the corner next to her. He was getting in her personal space now, applying pressure through body language. “Did you kill Noah Carter?”
“I don’t know I don’t know I don’t know.” Haley’s words ran into one sentence. She stifled a sob. A tear rolled down her cheek. She folded her arms on the table, laid her head down, and wept. The sound of her sobbing ripped at Lance’s heart.
On the video, compassion flickered briefly over the sheriff’s face.
For the next fifteen minutes, the sheriff asked her multiple times and in multiple ways if she had killed Noah Carter. But Haley had shut down. She wouldn’t even lift her head. A knock sounded on the door. A deputy stuck his head in and waved frantically for the sheriff.
“The first interview ended at 2:12 p.m. Saturday,” Morgan said.
“That’s right about the time Shannon Yates’s car was found.”
Morgan sat back in her chair, twirling her pen in her fingertips. “Haley sat in the holding cell until Monday morning, when the sheriff realized he was running out of time and needed to either charge her or let her go.”
“But they weren’t entirely ignoring the case. In the meantime, they matched her fingerprints with those found on the weapon and expedited a DNA test of the blood that was all over Haley, confirming that it was Noah’s.” Lance thought the sheriff had handled the situation well, except for not taking Haley to the ER. “Haley never specifically told the sheriff that she didn’t remember the night before.”
“She wasn’t thinking straight.” Morgan tipped her head back and closed her eyes. “She was clearly confused, or ‘out of it,’ as the responding officer noted.”