WHAT I THOUGHT WAS TRUE

Cass: (Sighing) “Yeah. Photo shoot.”

 

Me: (Incredulous) “Your family thing is a photo shoot?”

 

Cass: “Stop laughing. Yes. We do the annual photo for my dad’s company website, you know . . . It’s a tradition . . . sort of an embarrassing one, but . . .”

 

Then all at once, I remembered that. Mr. Somers and the three boys. I couldn’t see her, but Cass’s mom must have been there too. Standing on the deck of their big sailboat tied off the Abenaki pier, white shirts, khaki pants, tan faces. Cass bending his knees to rock the boat, his brothers laughing, me starting to climb down the ladder to clamber aboard. Dad catching me and saying, “No, pal, you aren’t family.”

 

“You still do that?”

 

“Every year,” he said. “I may be the black sheep, but appar-ently I photograph well.”

 

His tone was light, but I heard something darker in it.

 

Silence.

 

I could hear him breathing. He could probably hear me swallow.

 

Me: “Cass . . .”

 

Cass: “I’m here.”

 

Me: “Are you going to do it? What your family wants? Say it was all Spence, go back to Hodges?”

 

Cass: (Long sigh. I pictured him clenching his fist, unclenching.) “This should be easier than it is.” (Pause) “Black and white. He’s my best friend. But I’m . . . My brothers are . . . I mean . . .”

 

It’s not like him to stammer. I pressed the phone closer to my cheek. “Yeah?”

 

280

 

280

 

 

 

Cass: “I’m not Bill, the financial whiz kid. I’m not Jake, the scholar/athlete.”

 

Me: “Why should you be?”

 

Cass: “They want the best for me. My parents. My family.”

 

At that point, Mom came into the room, sighing loudly as she took off her sneakers, flipping on the noisy fan. I told Cass to wait, took the phone outside, to the backyard, lay down in the grass on my back, staring at the deep blue sky. We had never talked like that to each other. His voice was so close, it was as though he was whispering in my ear.

 

Me: “I’m back. And the best thing for you is?”

 

Cass: “The whole deal. An Ivy. A good job. All that. I may not be as smart as my brothers, but I know that it . . . looks better . . . to graduate from Hodges.”

 

Here’s where I should have said that it didn’t matter how it looked. But I couldn’t lie to him. I knew what he meant.

 

Instead, I asked, “Is that what matters? Looks? To you.”

 

Another sigh. Then silence. Long silence.

 

I remember Cass’s brother talking to him outside Castle’s that day. Saying Spence would always land on his feet.

 

Me: “Wouldn’t Spence be able to bounce back? He’s pretty sturdy. And didn’t his dad get the expulsion off his record?”

 

Cass: “Well, yeah. But if I sold him out, that would be on my record. In his head. In mine. Who would—I mean, who the hell would that make me?”

 

My next thought was unavoidable. That you ask? That you worry? Not who I thought you were.

 

Finally, Cass: “Okay, I really do need to go.”

 

Me: “Yeah, me too. I’ll hang up now.”

 

281

 

281

 

 

 

(No hanging up) Cass: “Maybe if we do it on the count of three.”

 

“One. Two. Three.”

 

I don’t hang up. Neither does Cass.

 

Cass: (Laughing) “See you tomorrow, Gwen.” (Pause) “Three.”

 

Me: (Also laughing) “Right. Three.”

 

Both phones: Click.

 

Mrs. E. insists that we drive her Cadillac to pick up Emory and then head to the beach for his lesson. Emory is clearly aston-ished being in a car that doesn’t make loud squealing noises, like Mom’s, and where the seats are overstuffed and comfort-able, not torn up like Dad’s truck. “Riding. A bubble,” he says, mesmerized, stroking the smooth puffy white leather. “Like Glinda.” His eyes are wide.

 

This time Cass has yet more Superman figures for Emory to rescue, and a fist-sized blue-and-green marble. He places that one pretty far out in the deepening water, and tells Em he has to put his entire face under to get it. Em hesitates. Cass waits.

 

I squeeze Mrs. E.’s hand. I’ve set up a beach chair for her and am sitting in the sand beside it.

 

“My Henry was afraid of the water as a little boy,” she tells me quietly. “The captain was most impatient. He tried every-thing, saying he was a descendant of William Wallace and Wallaces were not afraid of anything—although I must say I doubt William Wallace could swim—and promising him treats and giving him spankings—that was an acceptable practice back then. But Henry would not go near the water.”

 

282

 

282

 

 

 

Cass is lying down on his stomach next to Em, tan muscled back alongside small, pale, bony one. I can’t see Emory’s expression. I have to grip on to the armrest of the beach chair to stop myself from going to the water, pulling Emory out, saying this was a bad idea. Mom’s words echo, that he’s my responsibility, that he can’t care for himself, that it will always be my job. I start to rise, but Mrs. E. presses down on my shoulder lightly. “No, dear heart. Give him a little time. I have faith.

 

You must too.”

 

I sit back. “So, how did Henry ever learn to swim?”

 

“Well, one day the captain took him to the end of the dock and dropped him in.”

 

I’m completely horrified. “What did you do?”

 

“I wasn’t there. I heard about it later. You must understand that some people were much tougher with children in those days. I would never have allowed it, but this sort of thing happened.”

 

Cass has rolled over on his side in the water, propping himself on an elbow. He ducks his head sideways, completely under, then pops it back up, says something I can’t hear to Emory. I hear the husky sound of Emory laughing, but he still doesn’t lower his head.

 

“So what happened? Did he sink? Did someone dive in and save him?”

 

“No, he doggy-paddled his way to the pier. He was too ter-rified not to. But he didn’t speak to his father for two weeks.”

 

Can’t say that I blame him. The captain sounds like a jerk Slowly, slowly, Em ducks his head. I catch my breath, as if I could hold it for him. His hand reaches out, out, out and then 283

 

283

 

 

 

his head splashes up at the same time his hand does, trium-phantly holding the marble.

 

“Way to go, Superboy. You saved the planet!” Cass calls, and Em’s grin stretches nearly from ear to ear.

 

“He’s not your young man?” Mrs. E. leans over to ask, her lavender perfume scenting the salty air.

 

“No. Not mine.” Cass is talking to Em, folding his fingers around the marble, pointing out to the end of the pier. Emory nods, seriously.

 

“Then I may ask him to be mine.”

 

“Gwen, wait up!” Cass calls as I’m pulling out of the parking lot at the beach, Mrs. E. and Emory equally worn out and drowsy.

 

He’s got his backpack slung over his shoulder and his hair is still dripping wet, scattering droplets onto his shirt. “I thought maybe I’d come by tonight.”

 

Grandpa informed me this morning that he was the bingo host tonight, so no way. If things were awkward with my family, they would be even worse with Grandpa’s friends raising and lowering their eyebrows and nudging one another over the fact that Ben Cruz’s granddaughter is finally being seen with um joven. Even if she’s just helping him with English.

 

“Not a good night for tutoring.” I look down at his feet, rather than at his face. Man, he even has nice feet. Big, neatly clipped toenails, high arch. I’m checking out his feet? Jesus. He edges the sandy gravel of the parking lot with his toe.

 

“Yeah, well, not tutoring,” Cass says. “I thought . . .

 

maybe . . . I’d just come by.”

 

284

 

284

 

Huntley Fitzpatrick's books