WHAT I THOUGHT WAS TRUE

 

“This was not exactly a date.”

 

“Yeah, what was this? Another little kick in the heart?”

 

“What do you care about my heart, Cass?”

 

He opened his mouth, then shut it again. Folded his arms and stared stonily out the window. Rigid. Faintly judgmental.

 

Which brought a pull of anger out of my coil of shame. What right did he have, anyway?

 

“Big deal, anyway, Cass. It was just sex.” I snapped my fingers. “You’re certainly familiar with that concept. Thanks for bringing me home.” I searched around for the car handle and pushed it open, but before I knew it, Cass was standing outside it, reaching out his hand for me.

 

“What are you doing?”

 

He looked at me as though I was either crazy or not very bright. “Walking you to the door.”

 

“You don’t have to do that. I’m . . . really not the kind of girl who gets walked to the door.”

 

“Jesus Christ, Gwen!” he said, then shook his head and pulled on my hand. “Just let me get you safely in.”

 

“I can make it from here.”

 

“I’m walking you to the door,” he told me, leading me up the worn wooden steps. “Not taking the chance that you’re going to go throw yourself off the pier or something. Because, forgive me for noticing, you seem a little impulsive tonight.”

 

“That’s one word for it.”

 

“Gwen . . . I . . . Would you . . . I mean . . .” He stopped on our doormat, beside Nic’s sneakers and one discarded rubber fishing boot of Grandpa Ben’s, apparently running out of 159

 

59

 

 

 

words. “I’d like to . . .” He shut his eyes, as if in pain.

 

I waited, but after a second he just said, “Never mind. The hell with it.”

 

And turned, crunching back across the clamshells to the car.

 

Did I use Spence? Did he use me? I don’t know. In the end, did it even matter? We’d just been bodies. Arms, legs, faces, breath.

 

Just sex. No big deal.

 

Still.

 

Explaining that night was never going to be easy. Not then, to Cass. Not tonight, to Nic. Not ever, to myself.

 

160

 

60

 

 

 

 

 

Chapter Sixteen

 

 

Cass is apparently fighting with a bush when I pass him the next day on my way home. He’s got hedge clippers and is whacking away, making a big dent in the side of one of Mrs.

 

Cole’s arborvitaes. It’s completely lopsided now. As I watch, he stops, takes a few steps back, then starts making a dent on the other side. The bush, which used to resemble an O, now looks like the number 8. After a few more unfortunate trims it looks like a B.

 

I can’t help it. I stop, cup my hands around my mouth, and call, “You should quit while you’re ahead—it’s only getting worse.”

 

He turns off the hedge clippers, “What?”

 

I repeat myself, louder, because Phelps, Mrs. Cole’s terrier, is yapping away inside the house, scritching his claws frantically on the screen door. Cass sighs. “I know. I keep thinking I’ll fix it and . . . I don’t want this woman to come out and have a heart attack. She seems a little high-strung. Screamed when I knocked on the door to ask where the outdoor plug was.”

 

I study him. He seems to have shaken off our weirdness from yesterday, and the whole Henry Ellington . . . thing.

 

He takes a few steps back again, tilting his head, scrubbing 161

 

61

 

 

 

his hand over the hair at the back of his neck. “D’you think she’d notice if I dug this up and replaced it with another bush?

 

That may be my only hope.”

 

“Got a spare arborvitae up your sleeve?” At least today he actually has sleeves, as in a shirt, thank God. I open the gate and walk in. “Maybe if you just trimmed down that top part and made the other side a little flatter?”

 

He revs up the hedge clippers, begins trimming on the wrong side. I wave my hands in a stop motion. Cass flips the off button again. “What now?”

 

“Not that side! You’re making it worse again. Just hand it to me.”

 

“No way. This is my job.”

 

“Yes, and boiling the lobsters was my job. You had no prob-lem barging in there.”

 

“Christ almighty. Can we move on from the lobsters, Gwen?

 

You honestly have this much of an issue with accepting help?”

 

“I’m pretty sure the issue at the moment is you not being able to accept help. Just give me the clippers.”

 

“Fine,” Cass says. “Enjoy.” He hands the clippers to me, pull-ing his hands back quickly and shoving them in his pockets.

 

Then he studies my face. “Actually, you do seem to be enjoy-ing yourself. Too much. You are planning to use those on the hedge, right? Not on me?”

 

“Hmmm. That hadn’t occurred to me.” I turn the hedge clippers on and look him over speculatively. He bends down, wrenches the plug out of the wall.

 

“Hey! I was trying to help.”

 

“I didn’t like the look on your face. It made me worry for 162

 

62

 

 

 

the existence of my future children. I haven’t forgotten that butter knife that was the only thing standing between you and Alex Robinson singing soprano.”

 

“I just never thought I’d see you be inept at anything. Haven’t you done this before?”

 

“Hey, I’m not inept. I’m just not . . . ept yet. And since you’re so curious, no, mowing our lawn is my only landscap-ing experience.”

 

“Did Marco and Tony know this when they hired you? Why did they hire you?”

 

“I don’t know. My dad talked to them first, and when I came in they just asked if I minded hard work and being outdoors most of the day. I figured I’d be mowing. Period. Maybe some weeding. I didn’t think I’d be planting and trimming and tying bushes to fences and I sure as hell didn’t think I’d be raking the beach.”

 

I’ve plugged in the hedge clippers again and now I turn them on and start in on the top of the hedge. “You can always quit,” I shout over the whir.

 

“I don’t quit. Ever,” he shouts back. “I think you’re making it worse.”

 

I lop off a few more branches, then run the clippers down, making the bumpy side as flat as the other. Then I stand back.

 

It definitely looks better. I move over to the matching arborvitae on the other side of the steps and start working on that to make it look the same.

 

“Now you’re just showing off,” Cass calls. “I can do the rest.”

 

“No way, Jose. Clearly you can’t be trusted.”

 

163

 

63

 

 

 

This sentence drops between us like a brick shattering on the pavement.

 

Again I get a flash of his white-knight rescue from Spence’s party. Granted, a cranky white knight, but still . . .

 

Jaw tight, Cass walks over to the Seashell truck, pulls a plastic bin out of the back, and starts scooping the severed branches into it. I buzz the sides of the other tree flat.

 

“There you are, garota bonita!” Grandpa Ben calls. He’s trudg-ing along up the road with his mesh bag full of squirming blue crabs, holding Emory’s hand and dragging the unenthusias-tic Fabio by his leash. Em is in his bathing suit, clutching a sandy-looking Hideout and looking sleepy. “I bring you your brother. Lucia is working tonight and I have the bingo.”

 

“Superman! Hello, Superman! It Superman,” Emory tells Grandpa, his face lighting up.

 

“Hey there, Superboy,” Cass says easily. My brother runs over and immediately throws his arms around Cass’s leg. And kisses him. On the knee. Cass seems to freeze for an instant, then pats Em’s bony little back.

 

“Hey buddy. Hello, Mr. Cruz.”

 

“Superman,” Emory repeats. Clearly, for him, all that needs saying. He gives Cass his shiniest smile and plunks down in the grass, nuzzling Hideout against his neck.

 

“I will not lie, querida. He’s been cranky. Está com pouco de bug today. We got ice cream, but no. No help.” Grandpa Ben pulls his watch out of his pants pocket. It’s not a pocket watch, but he keeps it there, out of habit, afraid, from his fishing days, that it would snag on something. “I need to go now. I get there late, Paco stacks the deck.”

 

164

 

64

 

 

Huntley Fitzpatrick's books