“Don’t you think they’re kind of overreacting?” I say tentatively.
“Oh, they’re definitely overreacting. At least with my dad I can understand why he overreacts all the time. Considering everything I put him through during high school.”
As usual, her vagueness piques my curiosity. But I force myself not to press for details. She’ll tell me when she’s ready. I hope.
“I bet your parents are so chill, right?” Brenna says enviously.
“Yeah, they’re awesome,” I confirm. “Except for their constant nagging about how I don’t have a girlfriend. They’d probably throw a party if they knew I gave you a drawer.”
She laughs, then closes said drawer and turns to me. “Done. What do you feel like doing?”
“Want to watch a movie?” I suggest. “I can make some popcorn.”
“Oooh, I like that idea. Let me put on comfy clothes and I’ll meet you out there.”
I give her ass a playful smack on my way out the door. In the kitchen, I experience a wave of déjà vu when I find Kayla at the sink, pouring a glass of water. This time she’s wearing clothes. And instead of filling with hunger, her eyes cloud over when they land on me.
“Hey,” I grunt.
“Hey.”
I open the cupboard and grab a packet of microwave popcorn.
“Movie night?” She sounds a tad testy.
“Yep. You and Brooks can join if you want. I’ll make another bowl.” It’s a bogus offer—I ask only because I’m confident she’ll say no.
No way Kayla is going to willingly spend time with Brenna. The moment my girl walked through the front door, Kayla had reacted like a territorial cat. The claws came out, and she might as well have hissed. What made the entire encounter awesome was Brenna’s complete disinterest in the chick.
“So… Jake Connelly’s got a girl spending the night.” Even testier now.
“Yeah.”
“Must be serious.”
I don’t answer. Turning my back to her, I stick the popcorn in the microwave and punch in the time.
“Or is it not serious?” she prods.
Again I refrain from answering, because guess what—it’s none of her fucking business. But then Brenna speaks up from the doorway.
“Oh, it’s very serious.” She saunters over, and even in a pair of plaid pants and a T-shirt, she’s so sexy that my body instantly responds to her. Or at least it does before I notice the Briar hockey logo on her chest.
“That’s blasphemy,” I say, pointing at her shirt.
“No, that’s blasphemy,” she replies, pointing at my shirt.
I glance down and remember I’m wearing a gray tee with the Crimson logo over the left breast.
Near the counter, Kayla makes a disparaging sound.
Which spurs Brenna to twist around and beam at her. “Aren’t we so cute?” she gushes. “We’re like Romeo and Juliet!”
For a second, the blonde looks like she’s going to hiss for real. Instead, she flashes a mocking smile. “Uh-huh, you two are the cutest.”
“Aw, thank you, Kaylee.”
“Kayla,” she snaps before stomping out.
Brenna starts to laugh.
“You’re such a bitch,” I tell her.
“Yup. That girl wants you, though.”
“Who doesn’t?”
“You might be right about that. I swear, I can’t go anywhere without bumping into someone who’s into you. The chick in the bathroom, Bubble Butt’s girlfriend, your friend Hazel.”
“Hazel?” I frown at her. “Why would you say that? You don’t even know Hazel.”
“Oh, you mean she didn’t tell you she ambushed me on campus?”
What?
“I’m sorry—what?” I vocalize my shock. Hazel hadn’t mentioned that at all. Granted, we haven’t spoken much this week, but if she actually had confronted Brenna, you’d think that would be something she deemed important enough to share with me.
“She tracked me down at the Coffee Hut,” Brenna explains. “She basically gave me the whole what-are-your-intentions-with-Jake speech and the I’m-gonna-kick-your-ass-if-you’replaying-him threat.”
I chuckle. “Yeah…she’s kinda protective of me. We grew up together.”
Brenna gives a faint smile. “She’s a lot more than protective.”
“Nah.”
“Remember that thing we were saying about men being dumb?”
I scowl at her. “When were we ever saying that?”
“Oh, right. That was me and Summer. Forget what I just said, Jakey.” She blinks, the poster child of innocence. “Men aren’t stupid at all.”
Neither of us pays much attention to the movie. We snuggle up under a blanket and spend the next hour teasing the hell out of each other. Brenna’s hand constantly brushes my dick. At one point she starts giving me an over-the-pants hand job…before reaching for the popcorn again and leaving me with the biggest case of blue balls.
I return the favor by stroking her nipples through her shirt until they’re harder than icicles and straining into my palm. When she tries to push her tits into my hands, I take the popcorn bowl and start munching.
About halfway through the movie, Brenna presses Stop and sets the remote control on the table.
I look over in mock outrage. “I was really into that.”
“Oh really? Tell me what that movie was about, Jake.”
I dig into my memory bank and come up empty. “Aliens?” I guess.
“Incorrect.” Snickering, she practically drags me to the bedroom, where she plants her hands on her hips and says, “Lie down.”
Because I’m not the stupid man she thinks I am, I lie down.
And before I know it, I’m naked and at her mercy. She’s kissing me everywhere, her soft lips gliding over my chest, warm tongue grazing my abdomen on her teasing journey south. She licks my oblique muscles, her breath tickling my skin, and then she abruptly sits up and removes all her clothes. Now we’re both naked, with my erection poking up between us like a huge spike.
She moans happily. “You are so effing sexy.”
“Right back at you.”
It’s my turn to give a happy moan, because her mouth lowers and suddenly she’s sucking my dick. I lazily thread the fingers of both hands through her hair, guiding her along the length of me. “Feels nice,” I murmur.
“Just nice?”
“Very nice.”
“Just very nice?”
“Jesus Christ, babe.”
Her laughter heats the tip of my cock. “I’m kidding. Sorry. Summer pulled that on me earlier and I told her she was a brat.”
“Mmm-hmmm, and then you decided to do the same thing to me?”
“Yup.”
“And men are the stupid ones?”
“Are you calling me stupid when I’m giving you a blowjob? Because to that I say, I rest my case.”
Dammit. She’s right. Men are dumb.
“Forgive me,” I beg.
Grinning, she resumes the task of torturing me. When her tongue scrapes the underside of my cock, pleasure sears into my balls, drawing them up tight. She cups my sac, squeezes it, and my hips arch off the bed. “Oh fuck. That feels so good.”
She jacks me faster, her tongue swirling around my tip at every upstroke while her other hand continues to tease my balls. They start tingling, my heart beats faster, and I fist one hand in Brenna’s hair to stop her.
“No,” I croak. “I don’t want to come this way. I want to be inside you.”
“I want that, too.”
She grabs a condom from the nightstand and rolls it on me. I pinch the tip to make sure we’re good, then beckon at her with my cock.
“Have a seat,” I say graciously.
“Oh my God, Jake. That was so lame.”
“Really? So this isn’t enticing you at all?” I wave my dick again.
“It’s enticing,” she relents, but although she straddles me, she doesn’t guide me inside her yet.
My erection rests heavy against my stomach. Brenna places both palms on my chest and bends down, her breasts swaying seductively as she brings her perfect lips to mine. We kiss, and it draws a husky groan from my throat. She swallows the sound, and then her tongue touches mine and it’s like an electric current running from the tip of my tongue to the tip of my cock. Fuuuuck. This girl turns me on something fierce.
“You like being teased,” she remarks. “I find that interesting.”
“Why’s that?”
“Most guys don’t have the patience for it.” Her mouth travels to the side of my jaw. She rubs her cheek over my stubble, before kissing her way down to my neck. “Other guys would have flipped me over by now and started drilling into me from behind.”
“How about we don’t talk about other guys? How about we talk about this guy?” I tug her head back to my lips, and this time it’s my tongue filling her mouth and her moaning against my lips. “But yes,” I whisper, “I like foreplay. I like dragging it out.”
“You like begging?” Her voice is throaty.
“Who’s begging?”
“Not yet, but you will be.” She goes back to kissing and sucking on my neck like it’s candy, all the while rubbing her naked body all over me. My dick remains trapped between us, weeping inside the condom, because it needs somewhere to go so damn bad and— “Please,” I plead, and she gives an evil laugh, because she succeeded in making me beg.