We got coffee in Laporte before stopping in at the Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office to talk with Detective Everett Morse, who was working with the Pennsylvania State Police on the murder of twelve-year-old Timmy Walker Jr. and the disappearance of Ginny Krauss and Alison Dane.
Morse was collegial enough and showed us the murder book, but it had been months since Ginny and Alison had disappeared and Timmy’s body had been found. The trail had gone cold. Morse told us not to bother trying to talk to the girls’ parents. They’d barely spoken with Morse or the state police.
When we stopped at the Pennsylvania State Police barracks on the north side of Laporte, Investigator Nina Ford largely confirmed Morse’s take on the case. She allowed us to look through her files as well, and, like Morse, discouraged us from trying to talk to the missing girls’ parents.
“What about Timmy’s parents?” Sampson asked.
“Big T’s out of the picture,” Detective Ford said. “Lenore’s at the house. You could stop at Worlds End State Park, where Timmy’s body was found. By the time you have a look around and get to Hillsgrove, Lenore should be up and almost coherent.”
From GPS coordinates Ford gave us, we were able to pinpoint the exact location where Timmy Walker’s corpse had been discovered—roughly a mile east of the parking lot at Worlds End State Park and several miles from where the missing girls’ car was found.
But for an older model white Chevy pickup truck with a toolbox in the back and decals on the window from the National Wild Turkey Federation, the park’s lot was deserted when we pulled in twenty minutes later.
A cold, raw wind blew while we hiked the trail and followed the GPS navigator to the rugged ground where a hiker had come across Timmy’s arm sticking out from under a pile of branches and leaves.
“That’s a workout, getting up here,” Sampson said, chest heaving. “Trail was steep.”
I nodded, my heart still hammering. “Timmy weighed ninety-two pounds, so it was someone very strong.”
“And someone who knew how to get to this particular stretch of nowhere,” Sampson said about two seconds before the shooting started.
CHAPTER
88
BOOM! CA-CHING. BOOM!
Sampson and I whipped around and dived for cover behind a downed log.
Boom!
“Where the hell is he?” Sampson hissed.
Hearing popping noises, clucking, and branches snapping, I peeked up over the log and saw a flock of wild turkeys racing through the woods. Up the hill, I spotted movement. I grabbed my binoculars, focused them, and saw a teenage girl in camouflage scrambling down the steep hillside, a man carrying two shotguns right behind her.
“I got him, Dad!” I heard her yell and she threw her hands up in the air. “We both did!”
We stood and waved at the hunters as they got busy with the two dead turkeys. It wasn’t until we were close that they noticed us.
The father stood, glanced at the shotguns propped up against a tree. I guess it wasn’t often he saw two men wearing coats and ties in the turkey woods.
We both showed our badges. He got stiffer. “This was a clean hunt.”
“I’ll take your word for it,” I said. “We’re here looking into the death of Timmy Walker.”
He softened. “That’s a tragedy. My Ellie here went to school with him. I’m Howard Young, by the way.”
“Nice to meet you, Mr. Young,” I said. I shook his hand and then looked at his daughter. “Tell us about Timmy.”
Ellie played with a camouflage scarf around her neck and her expression soured. “TW-Two was nice growing up, but then he kind of became a creep.”
“More like a little pervert,” her father said.
“How’s that?” Sampson said.
Ellie looked around and then said, “I don’t know if it’s true, but he supposedly put a hole in the wall at school so he could look into the girls’ locker room. The rumor was he took pictures and showed them to his friends.”
Sampson grimaced.
I said, “Was that investigated?”
“The principal said so,” Ellie said. “The school even had police look at Timmy’s phone, but there was nothing on it.”
Her father said, “Doesn’t mean there wasn’t another phone or a camera. I wanted that boy thrown out of school, but they didn’t do a thing. And then he died, so we’ll never know, will we?”
“We’re hoping to help figure out why he died,” Sampson said.
Young nodded uncertainly. “Well, we’ve got birds to clean, and Ellie’s got classes this afternoon.”
We thanked them for their time and hiked back down the steep hillside to the parking lot. Had Timmy been killed for taking pictures he shouldn’t have? Had the killer brought Timmy up that trail in the dark? His mother had reported him missing well after sunset, so there was a good chance. That meant the killer had a headlamp or a helper. Did that matter?
I set that thinking aside and went back to the iPad, looking at an aerial view of the area with pins that marked the locations of the girls’ abandoned car, Timmy’s botched burial site, and his home. The car and the house looked about a mile apart, but the killer had dumped his body miles away.
Why? To try to separate the two cases in the minds of police?
I supposed that was likely, though any detective worth his or her salt would have known the two cases were related. Same day. Same general time frame. The proximity of Timmy’s home to where the girls’ car was found.
So what happened? Did Timmy see the kidnapping, blunder into it somehow, and get killed for it?
That was our working theory when we pulled into the driveway of Timmy Walker’s house, a restored Colonial with fresh paint and a new, seamless metal roof. It was by far the nicest home in this small mountain hamlet where most of the structures looked like hunting camps. Brown leaves covered the modest front yard. A tricycle lay tipped over by the birdbath.
Sampson knocked on the door. No answer.
He knocked harder, and the door opened. A young girl, six or maybe seven, stood there in food-stained pajamas. She had a Winnie-the-Pooh blanket around her shoulders and studied us with red eyes.
“Hi there, young lady,” I said. “We’re police officers. We’d like to talk to your mom.”
“She’s sleeping,” the girl said.
“Can you wake—”
“I’m up!” a woman said, pounding down the stairs.
Mom was in a blue terry-cloth robe and barefoot. Her hair was a mess. Her eyes were puffy, rheumy, and wild when she said, “You get him? Timmy’s killer?”
“Mrs. Walker?” I said.
She came up behind the girl, hugged her. “I’m his mom, Lenore. This is his sister, Kate.”
We identified ourselves, said we’d like to talk to her.
“So you didn’t get him?” she asked, bewildered.
“Not yet, ma’am.”
The dead boy’s mom swallowed thickly and looked off in despair. “No one tells me what’s going on. Months Deuce has been gone and no word from anyone in weeks, not the sheriff, not the state police, not the FBI … not even my coward of an ex-husband.” She broke down weeping.
Her daughter scowled at us and then turned around to hug her mother.
“It’s okay, Mommy,” the little girl said. “It’s going to be okay.”
CHAPTER
89
WHEN WE GOT Lenore Walker calmed down enough to talk, she invited us in, and we learned that she had, by her own description, led a fairly charmed life until the night Timmy disappeared. She’d grown up in the suburbs of Philadelphia and met Tim Walker her junior year at Pennsylvania State.
Walker got a good job working as an oil engineer right out of school and made enough in the fracking industry that they bought the house, restored it, and had kids. Timmy—Deuce—was his father’s favorite, and they spent many hours together early in the boy’s life.
Then Walker started moving up the corporate ladder and was gone a lot. And then he discovered “playthings,” as Lenore put it, and he was gone a lot more. After Deuce died, her husband, heartbroken and in love with a twenty-four-year-old, had left for good.
We asked her about the rumors, about the hole in the wall at the school. “Never happened,” Lenore said.
“Your son have a computer?” Sampson asked.
“Two, or one and a half, I guess, at the end. He was always buying and selling them on eBay.”