In the course of my investigation, I discovered that neither of the two profiles taken from the homicide victim’s body at the crime scene had ever been uploaded into CODIS. One of those profiles had, of course, belonged to the boyfriend, who was also the presumed killer. The second profile wouldn’t have rung any investigative bells at the time, because at that point the person involved was still a juvenile with no police record. It wasn’t until much later when I came along that the second crime-scene profile was finally uploaded into the system. Once that happened, alarm bells started going off all over the place, because by then that innocent-looking kid from way back then had turned into a convicted serial killer, and Emily Anne Tarrant had been his first victim.
Over the years I had done a lot of work with the folks at the Washington State Patrol Crime Lab, and I knew many of them personally. When I had asked Gretchen Walther, one of the crime lab’s DNA techs, to look into the Emily Anne Tarrant homicide, she did so as a personal favor to me. Although she hadn’t been responsible for the clerical error that resulted in the profiles not being uploaded in a timely fashion, she happened to be the one who discovered the oversight.
After that all kinds of hell had broken loose, and I don’t doubt that a crime-lab head or two had rolled as a result. Not long ago I’d heard that Mateo’s wrongful-imprisonment lawsuit had been settled for “an undisclosed amount.” That generally translates into big bucks, in which case a few more people might have found themselves out of jobs.
As for me? My involvement in the Mateo Vega debacle probably meant that I was definitely persona non grata at the crime lab these days. Still, fools rush in where angels fear to tread. I found Gretchen’s name in my contacts list. Since she usually works swing shift, I tried calling her cell phone. She answered after two rings.
“Are you kidding me?” Gretchen demanded once she figured out who was calling. “You actually have nerve enough to call me after all the trouble you caused?”
“That’s me, all right,” I answered as cheerfully as I could, “more nerve than a bad tooth.”
To my relief, Gretchen laughed aloud at that. “You ended up taking a couple of obnoxious muckety-mucks down a few pegs, which wasn’t such a bad thing, so the grunts who have to work around here don’t mind you all that much, me included. What’s up?”
By then Harriet had returned with the banker’s box in hand.
“I’m working a case,” I said.
“Big surprise there.”
“A seventeen-year-old kid named Christopher Danielson went missing from Homer, Alaska, in 2006. Unfortunately, he was never reported as missing, not at the time he disappeared and not anytime since either. I’ve been talking to Professor Harriet Raines up here in Anchorage. She has a set of unidentified human remains that were found in the spring of 2008. It’s possible they might be a match.”
“Oh, I know Dr. Raines,” Gretchen said quickly. “We’ve worked together a couple of times. Tell her hi for me, would you?”
I held the phone away from my mouth. “Gretchen Walther from the Washington State Patrol Crime Lab says hello.” I wasn’t doing a FaceTime call, so there was no video, but I put the phone on speaker.
“Hi right back at you,” Harriet said.
“What do you need, Beau?” Gretchen asked.
“I got involved because the presumed victim’s older brother, Jared, sent me searching for him,” I continued. “My client’s name is Father Jared Danielson, and he’s a priest currently staying at a monastery in Woodinville. Professor Raines asked if I had a DNA profile for him, which I currently don’t have. I was wondering if it would be possible for me to send him by so you could collect a sample and create a profile.”
“I can’t do it for you,” Gretchen said at once, “but we have a mutual-aid agreement with the state of Alaska, and I could certainly do it for Dr. Raines. Does she have a case number on that?”
“We’re on speaker, so why don’t you ask her directly?” I suggested.
For the next several minutes, the two women talked back and forth, still on speaker, with Harriet Raines providing all the necessary details Gretchen needed to create a case file on her end. Finally Gretchen asked me for a phone number for Jared.
I started to give it to her but then thought better of it. I needed to talk to him about what Harriet Raines and I had discovered and what we suspected before anyone else did. I was the guy Jared had sent searching for Christopher, and I was the one who needed to tell him that his brother was most likely deceased.
“I’ll need to do the next-of-kin notification first,” I said, speaking from across the table. “How about if I give Jared Danielson your number and have him call you?”
“Good thinking,” Gretchen agreed. “Have him call me whenever he’s ready. I’m working swing shift tonight, so if he wants to drop by this evening, we could probably have a profile for you in short order.”
I ended the call feeling as though things had gone far better than I could have hoped. Still, phoning Jared to deliver the news wasn’t going to be easy.
“Do you want me to leave you to it?” the all-knowing Harriet Raines asked.
“No,” I told her. “I’d rather have you here in case he has questions I can’t answer.”
I glanced at the time before locating Jared’s number. I had spent far longer in Harriet’s basement lab space than I had expected, and unless she’d found refuge in a coffee shop, Twink Winkleman could well be frozen to her unheated car seat by now. Since it was already close to noon here in Anchorage, that would make it a little later in the afternoon in the Seattle area. I found myself hoping that priests had something urgent to do at this time of day so Jared wouldn’t answer the phone, but of course he did.
“Hey, Mr. Beaumont,” he said at once. “Have you found him?”
His voice sounded chipper and happy. Now was no time to remind him to call me Beau.
“I’m afraid I have some potentially bad news for you,” I replied. “I’m sitting here in Anchorage in a forensic-anthropology lab with the director, Professor Harriet Raines. She has some unidentified human remains dating from 2008 that may or may not be a match for Christopher.”
What followed was a moment of stark silence. “You’re saying Chris is dead?” Jared asked finally.
“He may be dead,” I cautioned. “We’re going to need a sample of your DNA in order to know for sure.”
Additional silence followed. I’ve done more than my share of next-of-kin notifications through the years. Initial reactions from loved ones can be all over the place, ranging from absolutely nothing to screaming hysteria. I prefer the latter, because in those moments my heart is usually screaming, too.
“I sent my DNA sample to Ancestry.com yesterday,” Jared said when he finally spoke. “I don’t have any idea how long it takes to get a profile back.”
I had to give the guy credit. He’d gathered himself far more quickly than I could have, switching within a matter of seconds from hearing the shocking news to looking at all the practicalities.
“We’d like to move a little faster than that,” I told him. “I’ve been in touch with one of my friends at the Washington State Patrol Crime Lab, a DNA tech named Gretchen Walther. Professor Raines here has forwarded the applicable case number to her. If you could drop by her office this evening sometime, she can take a swab and create a profile. That would be the fastest way to get this settled.”
“How do I find her?” Jared asked.
“I’ll text you her number and address as soon as we finish this call. She’s expecting to hear from you. That way she can tell you where to be and what time.”