"I don't know"
"And St. Louis and Nashville and Kansas City?"
"I don't know, I don't know, I don't know" She threw up her hands, once again frustrated. "You think I haven't asked these questions? You think I haven't wondered? Every time we moved, I spent countless nights trying to figure out where I went wrong. What I did that was so bad. Or what threat I didn't see. I never got it. I never got it. By the time I was sixteen, in my best judgment, my father was simply paranoid. Some fathers watch too much football. Mine had a penchant for cash transactions and fake IDs."
"You think your father was crazy?"
"You think sane people uproot their families every year and give them new identities?"
He could see her point. He just wasn't sure where that left them. "You're positive you don't have any pictures from your childhood lying around? Photo album, pictures of your old house, neighbors, schoolmates? That would help."
"We left it all in the house. I don't know what happened to it after that."
Bobby frowned, had a thought, made a note. "What about relatives? Grandparents, aunts or uncles? Someone who would have their own copies of your family photos, be happy to hear you're back?"
She shook her head, still not meeting his eyes. "No relatives; that's one of the reasons it was so easy to move away. My father was an orphan, a product of the Milton Hershey School in Pennsylvania. Credited their program, actually, for giving him his academic start. And as for my mother, her parents died shortly after I was born. Car accident, something like that. My mother didn't talk about them much. I think she still missed them.
"You know," she said abruptly, head coming up. "There is someone who would have photos, though. Mrs. Petracelli. Dori and I lived on the same block, went to the same school, attended the same neighborhood barbecues. She might even have photos of my family I never thought of that. She might have a photo of my mother."
"Good, good idea."
Her voice grew hesitant. "Have… have you told them?"
"Who?"
"The Petracellis. Have you notified them about having found Dori? It's horrible news, and yet in the perverse way these things work, I imagine they'll be grateful."
"Yeah," he murmured quietly "In the perverse way these things work… But no, we haven't told them yet. We'll wait until we have evidence to support the ID. Or, more likely, we'll end up approaching them for a DNA sample to use for matching." He contemplated her for a moment, then made a quick judgment call, one D.D. could hang him for later. "You want the inside track? The remains are mummified. Something the news reports haven't managed to learn yet. Given that, it's going to take a bit before we have more information on any of the bodies."
"I want to see it."
"What?"
"The grave. Where you found Dori. I want to go there."
"Oh no," he stated immediately "Crime scenes are for professionals only. We don't do public tours. Lawyers, judges, D.D., frown on that sort of thing."
She worked that tilt of her chin again. "I'm not just a member of the public, I'm a potential witness."
"Who, by her own admission, never saw anything."
"Maybe I just don't remember. Going to the site might trigger something."
"Annabelle, you don't want to visit a crime scene. Do your friend a favor: Remember her as your happy seven-year-old playmate. That's the best thing you can do." He closed his notebook, tucked it inside his jacket, then finished his water before placing the empty glass in the sink.
"There is one thing," he said suddenly, as if the thought had just occurred to him.
"What?"
"Well, I don't really know. I mean, Dori Petracelli went missing in '82; everyone's sure about the date. What's so puzzling, however, is that her kidnapping bears a resemblance to another case from 1980. A man named Richard Umbrio kidnapped a twelve-year-old girl and, get this, kept her in a pit. Probably would've killed her, too, except hunters stumbled upon the opening and set her free."
"She lived? She's still alive?" Annabelle's voice perked up.
He nodded, tucking his hands in his pants pockets. "Catherine testified against Umbrio, sent him to prison. That's what's so odd, you see—Umbrio was incarcerated by January of '82 and yet…"
"The cases seem related," she filled in for him.
"Exactly" He looked her up and down. "You're sure you've never met Catherine?"
"I don't think so."
"For the record, she doesn't think she's met you either. And yet…"
"What does she look like?"
"Oh, about your height. Dark hair, dark eyes. Actually, not so dissimilar, come to think of it."
She blinked uncomfortably at that news. He decided it was now or never.