“Shut up! I told you, he has nothing to do . . .” Bill stopped himself and carried on staring at them. Kate saw Tristan inching closer to Bill, his eyes on the gun.
“The phone call you got at four p.m.—it wasn’t from work, was it? It was from Joanna. We think that’s when she made the discovery that you and Nick were the same person. And Nick had killed those young men.”
Bill gripped the gun, taking deep breaths. “You can’t prove any of this. There’s no body. No car,” he said, almost chanting it like a mantra. “Bev’s car got nicked from outside her flat. You can’t prove otherwise.”
“Then how did Nick’s BMW end up outside Bev’s flat that night?”
“I’d parked on the road already,” said Bill with a triumphant smile.
“Why? On the morning of Saturday, September seventh, Bev picked you up from your flat on the other side of Exeter.”
“Okay, I’d parked it there the day before. There was no CCTV on that road,” he said.
“You got the call from Joanna. She’d worked out you were Bill and Nick . . .”
“You’re fishing. You can’t prove it!” he shouted.
“This photo proves it, Bill,” said Kate, holding up the photo taken in the commune. “We got this photo from Jorge Tomassini. Joanna had interviewed him about David Lamb, and he’d shown her some photos of the commune. And she’d taken the negatives without asking him. On the day Joanna went missing, one of her colleagues at the newspaper, Rita Hocking, said Joanna picked up some photos that she’d had developed that day, from negatives she’d stolen from Jorge Tomassini. This photo was amongst the photos that were developed. Jorge said that you had a thing about having your photo taken. This was the only photo in the pack where someone caught you by surprise and managed to get a photo of your face.”
“It was Joanna who phoned you that afternoon, wasn’t it?” said Tristan. “We know from Raj Bilal that the Teybridge House construction site was closed that day. Joanna saw this photo, worked it out, and phoned you. You asked to meet her, to try and explain yourself before she called the police. After you parted ways with Bev at Teybridge House, you drove to Exeter to meet Joanna at the Deansgate multistory car park. You knew it would be deserted. That’s where you grabbed Joanna and killed her, and you used Bev’s car to dump her body.”
Bill laughed and lifted the gun again.
“I say bollocks. And that’s what a jury will say too.”
“You were close to Joanna, weren’t you?” said Kate.
Bill’s face softened a little.
“Of course . . . I wouldn’t have hurt one hair on her head!” he said, raising his voice. He slammed the gun down on the table.
“That’s why it must have been tough to kill her,” said Kate.
“I did not! I did not kill her! You fucking shut your mouth!”
“You did. You abducted her and killed her because she had information about you and your double life. She knew you were responsible for the deaths of David Lamb, Gabe Kemp, and other young men,” said Kate. “You put her in Bev’s car and drove her here, didn’t you, Bill? You drove her up to this house. No one who knew Bill knew of this place. We’ve spoken to people who came to your summer parties, and we’ve spoken to your neighbor. They’ve all talked about Nick’s fear of people going down there on the sand when the tide’s out. We thought, at first, that you were a Good Samaritan, so scared of people drowning that you have a hovercraft to go patrolling the sand when the tide is low. But that’s not the case, is it? You’re scared that one day the tide will shift the sand and it will uncover where you’ve hidden Joanna’s body. You drove up here in Bev’s car with Joanna’s body in the back. You waited until it was dark, and you drove the car far out onto the mudflats, further than most people dare to go out, where you knew it would sink down and hide her body and the car. Afterward, you needed to get back to Exeter and meet Bev, so you drove Nick’s BMW back and parked it outside the Moor Side Estate. Bev’s car was never stolen. It never made it back that night because it’s buried out there in the sand with Joanna’s body inside.”
Bill was staring at her, and the blood had drained from his face.
“How many years have you been holding on to this terrible secret?” asked Kate. “You’ve kept it from Max. You kept it from Bev.”
“You have no proof. This is just you telling me what you think!” he cried. Bill picked up the gun, closed his eyes, and clutched it to his chest. Tears were running down his cheeks. He was quiet and still. Kate took a step closer, and so did Tristan, but Bill opened his eyes.
“Who are we talking to now: Bill or Nick?” asked Kate.
“It’s not like that,” said Bill, looking up at her. His voice was calm. “Nick was just a name I used when I met guys. I didn’t think about it back then. I didn’t want those guys to know my real name. It got out of control, and my two identities took on a life of their own.”
“Did Bill kill Joanna? Or did Nick kill her, like he did those young men?” asked Kate.
“Stop!” he shouted.
“I know it must have been frightening,” said Kate. “Out there in the dark. Sinking in the sand. With the tide rushing in . . . It plays on your mind, doesn’t it? That after all these years, Bev’s rusted car, with Joanna inside, will be exposed on the beach.”
“Why did you hire us to find Joanna?” asked Tristan.
“Bev,” he said quietly. “For Bev. I wanted closure. I thought you’d find nothing and we could draw a line under it all. I needed Bev to give up on Joanna. And leave it be.”
“Bev must know, deep down, that you killed Joanna,” said Tristan.
“You shut your mouth!” shouted Bill, slamming the gun repeatedly on the desk. “You can’t prove it. You can’t prove it!” he cried in a childlike singsong voice. His face was red and he was shaking.
“When we’re done here with you, Bill, I’m going to make sure the police search every inch of that fucking beach. They will find the car, and they will find Joanna’s body inside,” said Kate.
Her heart was now pounding, and her mouth was dry. Bill moved fast. He picked up one of the shells from the floor and loaded it into the gun. For a moment, Kate thought he was going to aim it at them and fire, but he closed the shotgun, turned it around in his hands, and put the barreled end in his mouth.
Tristan got around the desk just in time, knocking the gun from Bill’s mouth just as he pulled the trigger. The glass exploded in one of the cabinet doors behind Kate.
Bill and Tristan wrestled with the gun. They were the same height, but Tristan was stronger. Kate felt pain in her right arm, just below the shoulder, and she looked down and could see a spot of red expanding on the sleeve of her T-shirt.
Bill got the upper hand and shoved Tristan. He fell back against the bookshelves. Bill grabbed the other shell from the floor and ran out of the office with the gun. Tristan got up and saw Kate with the blood spreading from her arm.