A Terrible Kindness

She was so pleased when he called the day after, her warmth and concern so palpable she may as well have been standing next to him. And he knew, as he answered her questions with lone words, like yes, and no, and terrible, and unbearable, that he was building a barricade between them. That when she said she’d love to see him soon, his maybe had made it clear to her as well.

William loves Gloria, has done ever since he met her lodging with her family for his embalming training. He’s loved her without a moment’s wavering through all that happened – things that would have sent other men running. And then, at last, at the dinner dance, with that kiss, he dared to believe they had a future. But Aberfan has scooped out the core of him, stretched it thin and catapulted it into the wild blue yonder. Maybe that’s why he’s here; to try and get himself back.

The path twists to the right, above the graveyard, on top of the mountain. William climbs quickly, heart thudding. Skinny autumn trees stand sentinel every two feet or so, their lower branches reaching straight out, as if to shield him from what’s about to happen. He’s glad of the criss-cross limbs, for he too is obscured. Across the valley, on the opposite hillside, are hundreds, maybe thousands of people gathered in stunned solidarity.

The world has been watching Aberfan, and the floral cross dominating the mountainside above the graves shows that it has also sent flowers. Mourners swarm the hillside. Some add their own bouquets to the cross, before heading towards the gaping wound where the coffins are laid. From up here, they look like beige piano keys, occasionally white; the ones Jimmy brought from Ireland. Two or three rows deep, mourners lean towards the open ground. Some drop a flower, some simply touch the earth, as if to be blessed, or to bless. What boundless capacity for pain, William thinks, is expected of such tiny, frail humans.

A robin lands on a branch to his left at eye level, its twig-legs seeming too delicate to support the plump feathered body. The bird cocks its head at him once, then it’s gone. Jimmy was only half right, William is not one of them, but neither is he merely an observer. He wishes Jimmy were here now, so he could tell him how he’s afraid that part of him is being buried with those children, that the village’s brokenness has broken him.

A violent sawing cuts through the sky, then a thup-thup-thup of dashed air, so loud and close that William drops to his knees on the muddy path. When he looks up he sees photographers at the helicopter window, their giant black lenses trained on the hillside.

He’s indignant at their intrusion, yet along with its racket, a feeling of liberation steals over him. He imagines the bodies within those coffins, some of which he was the last one to touch. He remembers the girl’s hand in his and something in him shifts. His throat clears, his lungs draw in the cold air, as his body prepares to give its best to these shattered families.

‘Paham mae dicter, O Myfanwy, Yn llenwi’th lygaid duon di?

A’th ruddiau tirion, O Myfanwy, Heb wrido wrth fy ngweled i?’



The memory of Martin’s beautiful voice comes to him so clear and complete, it’s as if they’re singing their favourite duet again right here on this mountaintop. His voice is warm and elastic; his hands unclasp and conduct with smooth, generous sweeps. William sings like he hasn’t sung since he was a boy. It doesn’t matter that no one hears him. It matters that he’s doing it.

‘Anghofia’r oll o’th addewidion A wneist i rywun, ’ngeneth ddel, A dyro’th law, Myfanwy dirion I ddim ond dweud y gair “Ffarwél”.’



As if rehearsed, at the final verse the helicopter pirouettes and whomps away across the landscape with its loot. The smell of soggy bracken and trampled ferns fuses with a sense of being untethered, of floating free across the mountains.

The gentle patter of dog’s claws on the path behind stops just as William registers it. He turns. Ears pricked, head to one side, the Jack Russell looks at him before trotting off, sniffing the road, lifting its leg. William wipes his sleeve across his face. Time to clamp his defences back down before the flotsam and jetsam of his own life is washed up by the tidal wave of Aberfan’s grief; his father’s death, the abrupt end to his chorister days, the rift with his mother, with Martin. And now, Gloria. The cold hardens around him and the weight of the white sky seems to push down on the hillside. He can tell by the rise and fall of their voices that the villagers are singing ‘Jesu, Lover of My Soul’.

Afterwards, they drift down the mountainside and along the pavements towards home. William watches, hands deep in his pockets, his thumbnail catching on the loose lining.

The vivid grass tufting down the middle of the lane is so bright it seems to be singing to him, its pointed blades distinct and intense. And the phone box, the reddest of reds, shouts out to him at the turn of the path. He pulls a threepenny bit from his pocket.

It’s colder inside the phone box than out; the air is dank and solid. The click-click-click-click of the dial grinding back into position, the distant purr of the dialling tone – all of it particular and sharp in the enclosed space. At the shrill pips, William pushes the coin into the slot.

‘William? Is that you? Are you all right?’

William tastes his stale breath bouncing back from the heavy Bakelite. ‘I’m fine.’

‘We’ve been out of our minds,’ Robert says, ‘where are you?’

‘Aberfan.’

There is a pause. ‘The funerals.’

‘Yep.’

‘You sure you’re all right?’

‘I think so.’ The silence, William knows, is his uncle’s wariness of giving advice, being overly parental. ‘I sang to them.’

‘What did you sing?’ The urgent pips cut in between them and William fumbles in his pocket to find another coin, shoving it in with numb fingers. ‘Hello?’ Robert says.

‘Hello.’

‘What did you sing to them?’

‘“Myfanwy”.’ The pause is so long William breaks it. ‘Uncle Robert?’

‘Lucky them,’ he says eventually, ‘I bet they thought it was beautiful.’

‘No one heard, but it doesn’t matter.’

Robert laughs softly. ‘Come on home, boy.’

‘Uncle Robert?’

‘Yes?’

‘Thank you.’

‘What for?’

‘Making me an embalmer.’

‘You’ve done that yourself, William.’

Jo Browning Wroe's books