“No, Keith, I’m fine—I just woke up. Can you just give me a few minutes?”
There was another pause. “Er … um, okay. I’ll just sit out here. In the stairway, with two bags of Italian food and a bottle of wine.”
Elly smiled and leaned her forehead against the door, overwhelmed with longing to see his face. “I can’t let you in. I just woke up from a nap, and not kidding, I probably look like an actual hobo. Not even a normal hobo—the kind of hobo that murdered people in the thirties. I just need ten minutes to shower and clean up.” She heard Keith’s gruff laugh from the other side of the light pine wood, a sound she adored.
“Elly. I’ve seen you disheveled more times than I can count.”
Elly leaned away from the door with an amused smile. “Thanks, Keith, that’s really romantic.”
“Elly … wait, no. Okay, that came out horrible. What I meant to say is that I’ve never seen a woman look so messy.” He gave a low groan. “I can see how that also didn’t sound great.”
Elly folded her arms and gave an exasperated look to Cadbury, who sat obediently waiting by the door, his tail flopping wildly against the floor. He loved Keith much more than he loved Elly.
She heard Keith shuffle his feet. “What I’m trying to say is that….” Elly heard him sigh nervously. “If I think you’re the most beautiful woman even when you are covered in sweat, messy, and tired, then how bad could you possibly be right now?”
Elly’s heart spun in a dizzy circle and she opened the door into the hallway. Keith looked at her face with a grin. “Whoa. Pretty bad.” Elly smiled. With a devastating grin, he pulled her face toward him and softly nuzzled her nose. Elly took a minute to breathe him in. As her curtains curled in the breeze, the darkening pink sky played over his handsome features: a strong jaw, white teeth, soft lips. Keith was bald—but in the best possible way, in that he had a perfectly shaped head—and his dark-blue eyes reminded Elly of an angry sea at night. Tan Italian features occupied his sincere face that dimpled at the cheeks when he smiled, which was often. His smile was infectious and always proud, and he had a way of making the people around him want to be better. Years of throwing huge hunks of meat around and cutting endless sandwiches had given him a stocky and strong build. Elly ran her fingers over his thick arms, feeling herself sink into his steady embrace. He smelled like warm bread. They held each other passionately for a second and then released awkwardly.
We’re not quite there yet, thought Elly. We’re still a little nervous around each other.
Keith kissed her hand before holding her at arm’s length. “Let me see this so-called wreck.”
Elly looked down at her own clothing and grimaced. “I call this look ‘wildly inappropriate gym teacher.’” Her khaki shorts were so wrinkled that they looked more like tissue paper than the less-than-attractive shorts they were. Her baby-blue polo clung tightly to her body—it was a size too small—which might have been noticeable if it weren’t for the host of stains covering the fabric. Elly reached up and felt her hair. It was a tangled bird’s nest, and she could feel her cheeks were damp and clammy from sleep. She reached up to wipe her face with her palm. “I know I look awful. If you just give me a few minutes….”
Keith yanked her toward him and she almost bounced off his soft chest. He pushed her hair back from her face, strand by strand. The apartment faded from Elly’s eyes, and all she saw was Keith’s kind mouth inches from hers, his breath lingering on her lips. “I know you don’t believe me when I tell you, but you are perfection. In every way. Even when you are wearing some disgusting polo, and when you have—” he ran the pad of his finger down her profile, “couch imprints and some sort of stain on your cheek.” With a frown, he rubbed his thumb across her face gently, and then with more determination. “My word, Elly. Is this rust? How did you get rust on your face?”
Elly turned her mouth up in a half smile to kiss him like he’d never been kissed before. At that moment, her stomach gave a loud and embarrassing gurgle. Don’t ruin the moment by saying that you’re starving. Don’t ruin it, don’t do it…. “Keith?”
He was focused on the stain now, frowning as he tried to get it off her cheek. “Yes?”
“Can we eat?”
He laughed. “Of course. I’m glad I make such a romantic impression on you that your first question is ‘Can we eat?’”
Way to be ridiculous, she thought. She feigned humor. “You’re very romantic, but so is the garlic bread I’m smelling.”
Keith gave her a quick kiss on the rust stain and began putting the food out on the table. “I’m starving, too. And I love a woman who knows what she wants.”
Elly watched him silently. I do know what I want. And it’s right in front of me.