Best Laid Plans

“Get the hell out of here, Casanova.”

A few minutes later, I knock on the door to A New Chapter. It’s dark inside. Only a few lights flicker. She walks to the door, looking as gorgeous as she did when I left her last night. Maybe more. She opens the door, and I half expect a kiss.

Wait.

I wholly expect a kiss.

Instead, she smiles faintly, the kind that doesn’t quite reach her eyes. “Thanks for coming.”

And no kiss is coming my way. Judging from her serious expression, I’m not getting the yes I was hoping for either.

My shoulders slump, but I keep my tone light. “No problem.”

“I thought about what you said.”

I grit my teeth, trying to swallow my own pending disappointment as I wait for her to speak again.

“I value our friendship too much. I don’t want to lose you, Gabe.”

“I don’t want to lose you either.”

“And today, I was thinking about all these things. Giving books to your mom, and telling you stories about my day, and hearing your stories, and visiting your pops, and rescuing Hedwig, and going bowling. I don’t know how we can do that. Because what if it doesn’t work out?”

“But . . .” I start, thinking of all the ways I can convince her it’ll work out.

Except maybe she doesn’t want to be convinced. Maybe she wants an out, and a gracious one. An escape hatch that’ll preserve what matters most—the foundation we’ve built of friendship.

And if she wants an out, I suppose this is the lesser of two evils—her letting me down now before we try to become something more, instead of her letting me down when I’m in even deeper.

I drum my fingers against the shelf, a little loose. “Hey, no worries. I hear ya. I get it.” I study the wood, grateful for the distraction. “Want me to fix this?”

“You don’t have to.”

I wave a hand, making it clear this is no big deal. “Nah, it’s easy. I know where you keep the tools.”

I head to her office, grab the tool set, and fix the shelf in two minutes. I want to show her I do understand. I do respect her boundaries. I don’t want her to think I’m going to vault past them simply because she shared some secrets with me about her sexual fantasies. Besides, she made her intentions clear from the start. Maybe we both crossed a line last night, but that happens in the heat of the moment, sort of like when two actors fall for each other on set. We were playacting, stage fighting, and stage fucking.

When the curtain falls, the romance ends.

I try to rattle the shelf, pleased it won’t budge. I pronounce it good as new.

“Gabe,” she says, like my name pains her. “I’m sorry.”

She’s not talking about the shelf. But a knife’s nicking away at my heart, and it’s hard to pretend it doesn’t hurt as I stare at the person wielding the blade. I do my best when I answer her. “Fixing it was easy.”

“I meant about—”

I slice that notion off at the knees. “Hey, we’re good.” I tuck my finger under her chin. “Never ever worry about us. We are all good. I promise.”

“You swear?” Her voice trembles.

I lie. “I do.” I pile onto the lie. “In fact, let’s go bowling on Saturday. Like we always do. Your week of studies is nearly over. I’d say you passed with flying colors, learned all you needed, and we can get back to seven-letter words that lead to pizza being on you.”

“Or maybe I’ll kick your butt,” she says, and she sounds like she’s faking it too.

Maybe we’ll both fake it for a little while, but for different reasons, until we return to our balance.

I return the tools to her office, and when I leave, a call comes in for a small restaurant fire. Battling the blaze takes my mind momentarily off the way my heart seems charred to a crisp by a word I once thought was wonderful.

Friend.





38





Arden





I stare at the dessert I made the other night.

The uneaten dessert.

Like a zombie, on Friday morning I trudge toward the plate of coconut bars tucked in the corner of my kitchen counter. I pick up one, studying it like a scientist, holding it to the kitchen light, considering it from this angle, that angle.

We didn’t touch any of these. They’ve been here since two nights ago when we made love.

“Ugh.”

I mean . . . when we fucked.

When he took me over the back of my couch like I wanted.

When he gave me a fantasy from my list.

That’s all it was.

That’s all I can believe it was, yet my spine shivers from the memory.

“Stop it, body. Just stop it.”

But I replay the scene again, picturing the moment when he hooked his arm around my waist, then when he went so deep I saw stars.

And the sensation returns. Intensifies. Builds like a storm inside me.

“You are a traitorous bitch,” I say to my lower half. “One taste of him and you’re hungry for more.”

I bite into a hunk of the coconut bar, chewing as I head to the back door, stepping onto the porch. The morning sun blinds me, like it’s fair that the sky is so perfectly clear, like it’s fair that the day is so deliciously warm.

After last night, the sky should be punishing me with pelting cold rain.

Last night was a punch to the ribs—of my own doing, but nonetheless, that’s what it was. My muscles ache, my head hurts, and my throat feels raw.

I take another bite of the bar, but the coconut is cardboard to me. Telling Gabe I only wanted to be friends tasted like the worst lie in the world. I don’t want to be friends. I want to be everything.

I sink onto the steps, sadness shrouding me, my heart caving. A robin swoops down, hopping across the grass.

I remember the robins and their hunt for cheese and crackers the day David dumped me at Silver Phoenix Lake. That same fateful day my friendship with Gabe launched.

I toss the remains of the coconut bar to the bird. Chirping, he pecks at it, and I try to laugh, to tell myself this is funny and I’ll share the story with Gabe. But it’s not any easier to return to our normal today than it was yesterday. The prospect of starting a Words with Friends game with him makes my head throb.